Subject: Lighntening holes in bellhousing
From: ACRE
Date: 9/16/2003, 5:44 AM


Hi, George....I have been closely following the work you have
been doing on the bell housing.  Really looks great.  We all
benefit from experimenters like yourself.  One question, if
I may.  One of the features that I found attractive about your
design, is that it is "closed" similar to the Ross unit, which
prevents foreign matter from entering the spinning flywheel
mechanism.  One of the drawbacks on Tracy's system is that
it is open, and although it allows for inspection, my greater
concern
is that it also allows for foreign matter (fod) to enter,
which is not a good thing.  Will the bell housing be offered both
with
and without the lightening holes? I was hoping to cut one
inspection hole, and cover it with a removable light weight
aluminum inspection cover.  I would much rather trade a
little extra weight for peace of mind.  Mind you, this is only one
opinion, however it is most likely a purchasing opinion.
 Thanks again for all of the time and effort you have put into this
project. We will all benefit from it.  sincerely, Paul Conner


Foreign matter is unlikely to enter any holes in a bell housing as
there
is a centrifugal vortex of air in the interior. Many Ross bell
housings
have had holes cut in them. It has never been a problem in over
ten years of use. Ed Anderson's Ross had holes as I recall. Nobody
running Tracy's PSRU have reported any problems along these lines
in years of use.

I think the cooling effect on the rubber bushing torsional vibration
dampener far outweigh this minor consideration.

Paul Lamar

Paul Connor,
In reference to the bellhousing - anyway you want it mate!
George (down under)


If you don't cast the holes in George the cost of machining will be
much higher for you or for us than to put them in during the machining
process.

If we have to do it on this end it is really expensive as it must
be done on an NC mill or on a rotary table and an ordinary
mill. No other practical way of doing it. Unless of course you
want to cut and reweld your band saw blade ten times. Once for
each hole.

With the given wall thickness casting limitations there is no other way
to get the weight down to a reasonably number.

Paul Lamar


Paul,

I'm hearing you, but everytime I mention it (the holes) to someone their
eyebrows nearly go through the roof, the head shakes, shoulders shrug - I
get this uneasy feeling.

When I say I need to make it lighter (thinner) - I get similar sorts of
responses.

Can we take one small step at a time and test it through the process. It the
housing fails at the end of testing we know how far we can go, but if I cut
holes everywhere and it then it fails we haven't achieved anything.


I've checked-out permanent castings and they have their own particular
problems - no good !!

I've discussed the lost foam process and the cost benefits are not there.

If I remember you have a chap with a CNC mill that can do work for you. The
chap who did the cut -outs in the flat plate), is he one of the web group?

George (down under)

Don't worry about it George. If it is 5 mm thick it is way over designed. The ribs
take the major load. If you want to wait fine. It just takes time.

I have lost touch with him as my contact Jerry Hey has moved out of the state.
He was not very convenient to my location anyway.
We can always find a guy with an NC mill but usually at a high cost.
The guys in the states all want to do high quantity and you pay lots
for doing a one off.

BTW Jerry if you are reading this let me know if you still have
the test fixtures. I have not heard from you for awhile.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.