Tracy Crook wrote:
To those anxiously awaiting their RD-1C gear drives, here is the good news /
bad news story.
Just got the results on some troubling spline fit anomalies with the RD-1C
propeller shaft. The problem was that a Genuine Ford planet carrier would
fit nicely on the shaft but an aftermarket part simply would not slide onto
the shaft. To the naked eye they looked the same and the major & minor
diameters measured identical.
At first I though the aftermarket part was just made wrong and I would
simply have to use only Ford parts. On close inspection (backlit spline fit
with a 10x eye loop), it looked like the spline teeth only had a point
contact at the tips of the planet carrier spline teeth (this was on the Ford
spline). This would result in very fast spline wear, increased lash and
possible failure. The attached picture tells the story.
After getting the data from Ford on the planet carrier spline it was clear
that the pressure angle on the prop shaft spline did not match the carrier.
Result: $7200.00 in scraped shafts. The only good news is that new shafts
are in process. Still not sure who absorbs the cost but either way,
someone gets the shaft. (please forgive tasteless pun) Actually, the
supplier has agreed that if the problem turns out to be what I just
described, they will accept responsibility.
Isn't product development fun? I'll post an update to shipping schedule
when we have it nailed down.
Tracy Crook
tcrook@rotaryaviation.com
www.rotaryaviation.com
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.