Tracy Crook wrote:
>
> To those anxiously awaiting their RD-1C gear drives, here is the good news /
> bad news story.
>
> Just got the results on some troubling spline fit anomalies with the RD-1C
> propeller shaft. The problem was that a Genuine Ford planet carrier would
> fit nicely on the shaft but an aftermarket part simply would not slide onto
> the shaft. To the naked eye they looked the same and the major & minor
> diameters measured identical.
>
> At first I though the aftermarket part was just made wrong and I would
> simply have to use only Ford parts. On close inspection (backlit spline fit
> with a 10x eye loop), it looked like the spline teeth only had a point
> contact at the tips of the planet carrier spline teeth (this was on the Ford
> spline). This would result in very fast spline wear, increased lash and
> possible failure. The attached picture tells the story.
>
> After getting the data from Ford on the planet carrier spline it was clear
> that the pressure angle on the prop shaft spline did not match the carrier.
> Result: $7200.00 in scraped shafts. The only good news is that new shafts
> are in process. Still not sure who absorbs the cost but either way,
> someone gets the shaft. (please forgive tasteless pun) Actually, the
> supplier has agreed that if the problem turns out to be what I just
> described, they will accept responsibility.
>
> Isn't product development fun? I'll post an update to shipping schedule
> when we have it nailed down.
>
> Tracy Crook
> tcrook@rotaryaviation.com
> www.rotaryaviation.com
>
Thanks for the info Tracy. I am still a few months away from needing
it. I certainly hope that you don't get left
holding the bag. It is in all our best interests for your
company to be kept profitable.
Dick Gregory
Stuff happens. I had 20 scrap water pump castings I donated to the local
college so the machine shop students could get real world experience
machining a real casting.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.