Hi Mark, [Mazda PR Japan]
Hate to bother you with this question but it keeps coming up
over and over again during the past five years.
I know there is nothing in the RX8 manual about it but I checked
with the service manager at Santa Monica Mazda and he said he went on
line with Mazda Service and asked the question, The answer he gave
me was synthetic oil was not recommended. One person said synthetic
does not burn cleanly and could cause seal sticking.
Why not? What happens in the engine when synthetic is used?
That is the question we have all been wondering about for years.
There is an after market device available that allows a auxiliary tank of two cycle
oil to feed the metering pump instead of burning lube oil out of the
engine sump. The advantage is two cycle oil does a great job of lubing the apex
seals and burns cleanly. Rotary engines disassembled after years of service
are near spotless with low apex seal wear. From an emissions point of view
an apex seal oil might be formulated that burned with less pollutants.
Here is the person that invented this device, manufactures it and sells it
along with a few pictures.
Richard Sohn
unicorn@gdsys.net
http://www.gdsys.net/WWWmembers/unicorn/
The problem with this is it requires the average owner to buy and
keep the auxiliary tank topped up with two cycle oil. The solution to this
problem is have the car computer light a warning light on the
dash when the two cycle tank is empty and have the oil feed to the metering
pump switch to sump oil temporarily until the owner replenished
the two cycle auxiliary oil tank.
In any event we are all wondering why Mobile 1 synthetic oil is not recommended
for the rotary engine.
Paul Lamar
-Mark Schirmer Wrote:
Good question. In earlier rotaries as you know, synthetic was not recommended
because it damaged the oil seals.
Not so in the RX-8 says Katabuchi-san. Either oil should be fine.
I mentioned this to our global Customer Service director -- considering
what you heard from Santa Monica. Will see what's going on.
mhs
[Mazda PR Japan]
Turns out that this News Letter message from Oct. 2001 was right on the mark.
With hundreds of messages and opinions on this subject the truth was buried.
We now and forever hence fourth know the truth.
Paul Lamar
************************************************************************
Subject: More on syn oil per very reliable person
Date: Mon, 08 Oct 2001 13:12:19 -0700
From: ACRE NL <rotaryeng@earthlink.net>
From: "David Lane"
Subject: (rx7) Amsoil address the synth-oil question
After many years of discussion on this topic, I finally ran across
something from a manufacturer that addresses the history of the
issue directly.
My source was, believe it or not, a wall in the office at Sun Auto--a
junk yard specializing in 1st and 2nd gen RX-7s. It is in the form of
a letter written on Amsoil letterhead, and signed by someone in the
Technical Services Department. The letter was written to a private
individual, but it looks like a form letter, and I saw it in a public
place, so there should be no harm in paraphrasing it here. I am
working from a copy.
The letter says the reason Mazda did not recommend synthetic
oils was due to problems with the rotor seals (part numbers 0820-
11-341 and 1202-11-343). The problems were apparent with "at
least one" synthetic oil.
Amsoil had been sponsoring RX-7 racing since the '70's, and thus
had always been concerned with this.
When Mazda came out with their caution in 1988, Amsoil tested
for seal compatibility.
The letter implies that the seals in question were designed to swell
as a means of replacing worn material and maintaining component
integrety. The idea was to control this swelling within an
acceptable range, which Mazda specified as being between ten
and twenty percent.
Amsoil used Pennzoil 10-30 as a reference and measured an 18.5
percent swell rate. Several Amsoil multi-weights were tested and
found to range in "swell rate" between 14.5 and 17.3 percent.
The following line is a direct quote:
"Since that time, Mazda has rescinded their recommendation not
to use synthetic oil in the Rotary engine."
End of paraphrase.
Now, this letter is dated September of 2000, and the notion that
Mazda didn't caution against using synthetics until 1988 was
enough to send me scurrying to the owner's manual for my 1985
GSL-SE. No mention of synthoil there--nor in the shop manual.
The only requirement is an SD, SE, or SF oil.
The last line--that Mazda had recinded their anti-synthoil stance--
was also a shocker. I would have assumed any information like
that would have hit this list like a clap of thunder. Of course, I am
in no position to confirm the assertion, or to argue with it.
Nothing above is going to change anyone's mind about the issue,
but it does tend to reinforce some of the points made in past
discussions, and to put things in historical perspective.
If anyone has a direct source to verify the notion that Mazda
currently has no prohibition against using synthetics, I would like to
know about it. Last time I saw a Mazda reman in a crate, I
THOUGHT I saw a tag on it with a warning that using synthoil
would void the warranty. (Note: these engine seem to have about a
dozen tags tied on them when delivered. You'd think someone
would save time and energy by supplying a detailed instruction
sheet instead.)
And, of course, there are no rotary cars currently in the United
States with original engines still under warranty, so the point is
moot from that perspective. We'll have to see what happens when
the new rotary cars hit the showrooms.
Best wishes,
David Lane
'85 GSL-SE (CarTech turbo)
Info on the car at:
http://www.wankel.net/DavidLane/
End of original message.
*************************************************************************************
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.