Subject: Turbo 3 rotor flying boat crash.
From: ACRE
Date: 11/26/2003, 10:09 PM


 > >>>NTSB Identification: LAX03LA267
 >>>                                         14 CFR Part 91: General Aviation
 >>>                                Accident occurred Thursday, August
 >>>28, 2003 in Tracy, CA                                    Aircraft:
 >>>Petz Flying Boat, registration: N1216Z
 >>>                Injuries: 1 Fatal.
 >>>
 >>> This is preliminary information, subject to change, and may contain
 >>>errors. Any errors in this report will be corrected when the final
 >>>report has been completed.
 >>>
 >>>On August 28, 2003, approximately 0815 Pacific daylight time, an
 >>>experimental Petz Flying Boat, N1216Z, lost control in flight and
 >>>collided with terrain approximately 660 feet south of Tracy
 >>>Municipal Airport, Tracy, California. The airplane was operated by
 >>>the private pilot/owner under the provisions of 14 CFR Part 91. The
 >>>pilot, the sole occupant, sustained fatal injuries, and the airplane
 >>>was destroyed. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed and a
 >>>flight plan had not been filed. The flight originated at New
 >>>Jerusalem Airport about 0835.
 >>>
 >>>A Federal Aviation Administration inspector at the scene reported to
 >>>the Safety Board investigator that the airplane wreckage was found
 >>>in a rock quarry gravel pit and was completely consumed by fire.
 >>>
 >>>Family members reported that they believed that this was the first
 >>>flight of the airplane, which was designed and built by the pilot.
 >>>

 >>>Surely the local EAA guys know something about it.
 >>>Anybody have any further information on this airplane.
 >>>Bill Jepson or anybody else in that area.
 >>>Can you do a little detective work for me on this?
 >>>
 >>>Rumor and supposition has it the exhaust melted the composite prop.
 >>>So make sure your pusher engine is not dumping the 1750 F exhaust
 >>>right at the prop.
 >>>
 >>>Paul Lamar


 >Perry Mick wrote:
 >
 >
 >>That's bizarre, you know my installation, the exhaust exits in front of my
 >>composite prop. I have no muffler, just the stock exhaust manifold and a
 >>short pipe. Prop has been fine for 430 hours, gets some soot on it but
 >>doesn't get warm because of all the airflow over it. If the blade was
 >>sitting still in front of the exhaust I could see it failing!
 >>
 >>Perry

 >Perhaps it is the increased volume of heat from a turbo 3 rotor Perry.
 >
 >I don't really know anything about this accident. In fact I am not
 >sure the engine or prop even failed. The guy may have merely spun in
 >due to defective aerodynamic design, aft CG  or just a plain old
stall/spin.
 >
 >Paul Lamar

 I forgot to mention that I have a stator blade behind my fan that is
 almost inline with the exhaust. All I did was rivet a very thin sheet of
 aluminum in the area where the exhaust impinges on the stator blade,
 that has also worked to protect the composite stator blade. My guess is
 the guy had some other problem, like stall/spin.

 --
 > Perry

   I have argued with the Coot people on the Coot group about test
flying off water and I feel there is a disadvantage to it as there is
a suction and drag on the nose and in taxi testing it feels nose
heavy but when you break off the water suddenly the nose pops up and
you have to push the nose down and readjust the trim.
  Is just very hard to tell in taxi testing whether the CG and trim is
where it belongs until its flying where on wheels you can and on a
flying boat you don't have that option so I would also lean toward
the classic stall, spin on first flight that happens all to often.

  Ken Welter

The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.