Subject: Resonance- was PSRU / answer on Seal set
From: ACRE
Date: 12/9/2003, 8:04 PM


 > > >  > > >>  Sorry to disagree Ken, but on our best drag bikes we use
 lightened
 > >>  > >>crankshafts
 > >>  > >>  and clutch baskets. Inertia is inertia, rotational inertia
 is the
 > >>  > >>same. It will
 > >>  > >>  take you longer to accellerate the heavy flywheel no matter
 what
 > >>  > >>else happens.
 > >>  > >> [snip]
 > >>  > >>  Bill Jepson

 > >>  An acquaintance of mine who manages an IRL team said something I
 found
 > >>  extremely interesting while showing me some stuff.  I was asking
 why they
 > >>  use lighter suspension components on less demanding tracks since
 the
 > >>  difference in weight is extremely small and the final car weight
 will be
 > >>  exactly the same anyway.  He said they have found that over
 building
 > >>  components tends to lower reliability.
 > >>
 > >>  Keep in mind, I don't speak for him and I'm not a P. Eng.
 > >>
 > >>  Lightened flywheels on two stroke drag outboard engines do help
 performance
 > >>  but only in a barely measurable way.  To go from a stock aluminum
 flywheel
 > >>  to the lightest flywheel that will hold a ring gear will only make
 about a
 > >>  1/10th second difference over a quarter mile.  The flywheels are
 lightened
 > >>  to raise their resonant frequency.  Many stock OMC V6 outboards
 have a
 > >>  resonance at 6200~6400 RPM and they will shear cranks if propped
 to top out
 > >>  at that engine speed unless the flywheel is lightened to raise
 that
 > >>  resonance above WOT engine speed.
 > >>
 > >>  Lightened pistons and rods can help reliability also but I would
 tend to
 > >>  think that roughly anything that reduces vibration, lighter or
 heavier,
 > >>  will be beneficial to reliability.
 > >>
 > >>  My $0.02,
 > >>
 > >>  Tom

 >     One thing that Atkins said is that there is bad resonant vibration
 > in the 13b at 6200 rpm and try to stay out of that zone so I try to
 > run at 6000 or 6500 but in the early days I didn't know that and may
 > have been beating up the dampers in that zone.
 >   He also said that the 20b doesn't have that vibration zone.
 >
 >    Ken

 That is nonsense Ken. I have owned six rotary engine powered cars, read
 all the
 engineering information published on the rotary engine for the past 35
 years
 and there are no resonant zones in any RPM range up to 11,000 RPM.  One
 can
 learn how to overhaul a rotary engine and overhaul thousands without
 understanding the physics and kinematics involved in its operation.

 Paul Lamar


 Perhaps the condition Atkins was feeling was related to his particular
 prop/psru combination.  Also, I looked at an old Mazdatrix catalog and
 the gasket set did contain the water orings as well as the oil control
 orings ($105 as of 1999).

 Ken Powell


    Yes very well could be that it was particular to that setup, that
is why the FAA demands vibration tests on different prop. engine and
aircraft setups, different combinations give different results.

   Ken

 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.