Jim Brewer wrote:
http://www.nytimes.com/2003/12/21/automobiles/21AUTO.html
The New York Times sucks. You can't get on with out giving them a lot
of personal information. God knows how they will use it.
I could care less what they say. Good or bad.
They have an agenda anyway and everything they publish is slanted
to fit their agenda.
Paul Lamar
After watching the Wright Experience on the Discovery Channel, one
particular thing sticks in my mind. After Langley's Aerodrome
failed for the second time, the NY Times declared that "man would fly,
in about a million years". That was December 8th, 1903. I
don't think their expertise has improved much in a hundred
years, let alone a million.
Rick Girard
CBarber wrote:
I don't really care if the NYTimes has my info....figure it is easy to get
anyway. So for those that haven't seen the article due to concern about
giving out personal info, here it is. [below] Not TOO bad.....or too good.....even
though he seems well under informed about rotary redlines etc. <g>
Christopher Barber
Barber & Pi, LLP
Attorneys and Counselors at Law
11930 S Sam Houston Pkwy E
Suite 103
Houston, Texas 77089-4755
281-464-LAWS (5297)
One of the many problems with the NY Times and other print publications is
writers are chosen for their writing ability (and sometimes for their ethnic
diversity :)) and not necessarily for their knowledge of the subjects they
are writing about. I really don't care what Tony drove in high school.
Like any car with 238 HP if you use the HP you will use the fuel.
Of course hybrids gets good fuel mileage because they have only 80 HP.
In order to fairly compare two engines the fuel consumption must be measured
when both engines are generating the same amount of HP. That is what BSFC
Brake Specific Fuel Consumption is all about. So many pounds of fuel are
burned for each HP generated for each hour.
The trouble with the EPA mileage number is cars are only required to complete
a standard driving cycle where acceleration and speeds are closely controlled.
Since most comparable four passenger cars weigh about the same (in the range
of 3000 to 3500 pounds) and have the same widths, heights, frontal areas
and aerodynamic and rolling friction drag factors more or less they will
have similar EPA fuel consumption numbers because they are using the same
amount of HP More or less. Namely about 20 MPG city and 25 MPG highway more
or less. The RX8 is no exception.
It does not take much HP to have a 3000 pound car complete the
EPA driving cycle. Required accelerations and speeds are very modest
with time spent idling no less. If you restrict the HP of
the RX8 to that required by the EPA driving cycle it would get
about the same EPA mileage numbers but it would be nowhere near
as fun to drive. The main thrust of Mazda engineering for the last
twenty years is to reduce the rotary fuel consumption when it
is idling or generating the modest HP required to complete the
EPA driving cycle. It has always had, within a few percentage points,
comparable BSFC numbers to piston engines when running at or near full power.
I love to drive my RX8 fast and it is hard to avoid speeding tickets.
It is a real hoot to drive. If I leave it in 6th gear 90% of the time and
putter around town with the rest of the traffic it gets 20 MPG. Due to
the total lack of valve overlap the RX8 engine does that very well unlike
other six speed manual transmission cars. If I hotrod it around town
with max acceleration away from every stop light I do see as low as
15 MPG. If I drive it at the 65 MPH freeway speed limit it gets 25 MPG.
If I drive it 85 to 90 MPH on the freeway (common here in Southern
California in those rare times when traffic is light) it gets about 20 MPG.
Paul Lamar
*******************************************************************************
A Sports Car With Family Values
By JEFF SABATINI
Tony was the captain of my high school water polo team. Athletic. Popular.
And if that wasn't enough to fuel the fires of jealousy, Tony drove a silver
second-generation Mazda RX-7 that was the envy of all us red-blooded
teenagers with sports car lust in our hearts.
Fifteen years later, most guys like Tony aren't driving sports cars. Instead
of stepping up out of something low and sleek, they are hopping down from
the running boards of big S.U.V.'s or extended-cab pickups.
Mazda is begging the Tonys of the world to come back to the fold.
Recognizing the practical appeal of the utility vehicles that are now often
the choice of the cool and uncool alike, the company has added a degree of
practicality to the successor to the RX-7, which Mazda pulled from the
American market nine years ago. The new RX-8 is a sports car with not two
doors, but four, and an equivalent number of seats.
Yes, sedans have been promoted as "four-door sports cars" before, and Saturn
has tried to convince us that we should be impressed by the diminutive rear
doors on its coupes. But the RX-8 actually delivers the goods: four doors
plus styling, handling and performance befitting a sports car.
The RX-8 certainly screams "sports car" - and loudly at that. Its protruding
front fenders initially call to mind the Ferrari Enzo supercar, but the more
you stare at the front of the RX-8, the more those pontoonlike fenders look
as if they belong on a vintage pickup.
The styling is indeed the weakest part of the package, and part of the blame
falls on those rear-hinged doors. There is no way to make their seams work
in concert with the rest of the car's manic lines. These swoop rearward over
the hood, dart up to a crease along the trunk, and bulge over the wheels,
all with the reckless styling abandon common in this era of computer-aided
design. The rear end, cluttered with Mazda's oversize badges, is especially
busy.
As expected from Mazda, handling is where the rear-drive RX-8 excels. A
superbly tuned suspension - double-wishbone configuration in the front and
multi-link in the rear - makes enjoyable sport out of twists and turns,
allowing little of the leaning movement known as body roll. Even more
impressive is how well the car soaks up bumps and poor pavement.
The ride is always firm but rarely harsh, and the driver benefits from great
road feel and response through the electrically assisted power steering.
With perfect 50-50 weight distribution, the car has excellent balance and a
nimble feel.
The engine is a 2-rotor, 1.3-liter rotary, or Wankel, so-named after its
inventor, Felix Wankel. This design allows for a compact and lightweight
engine with prodigious power potential, making it an obvious choice for a
sports car. Unlike conventional piston engines, in which the up-and-down
motion of pistons turns a crankshaft, rotary engines have triangular rotors
that rotate within housings, turning eccentric shafts that run through their
centers.
Rotaries have been Mazda's unique calling card since the 1960's, so it is no
wonder that its new flagship features the latest developments in rotary
technology, which offers lower emissions and higher performance, Mazda says.
The new unit makes 238 horsepower (at a lofty 8,500 r.p.m.) but only 159
pounds-feet of torque (at a high 5,500 r.p.m.). That low torque number means
the 3,000-pound RX-8 doesn't move off the line as quickly as you might
expect, but satisfaction comes a second or two later as the engine soars
toward its 9,000-r.p.m. redline.
For people unaccustomed to urging the tachometer needle that far up the
gauge, driving the RX-8 may take some adjustment - by delaying your shifts,
for instance. Though indeed high-strung, the mellow-sounding little rotary
never feels short of power; Road & Track magazine recorded a 0-to-60 m.p.h.
time of 5.9 seconds, compared with 5.8 for a Nissan 350Z. Nor is it a
painful aural experience to rev it full-tilt.
The pain comes at the gas pump. My test car had a federal fuel economy
rating of 18 miles per gallon in town and 24 on the highway. As they say,
your mileage may vary: I achieved only 18 m.p.g. in combined driving and 14
in a strictly urban setting.
The six-speed manual transmission has shift throws short enough to ruin the
business plan of an aftermarket supplier. A four-speed automatic, with
gear-change paddles on the steering wheel, is also offered, but this version
comes only with a detuned 197-horsepower version of the engine.
The brakes are grabby four-wheel discs with an antilock feature and
electronic force distribution. Dynamic stability control with traction
control is an option, bundled to cost you at least $1,200. Ditto the
moonroof; the least expensive package that will get you one is $2,800.
My $31,200 test car included the $4,000 grand touring package, the only way
to get a leather interior. A navigation system is also offered, for $2,000.
Clearly, Mazda arrived at the reasonable base price - $27,200 for the
six-speed model - by being stingy with the standard equipment.
Would you like a spare tire? The scrooges at Mazda give you only a can of
flat-tire sealant goo unless you pay an extra $395 for the fifth wheel and
additional rubber.
Mazda explains that the spare was left out because it takes up much of the
trunk. But the company's Miata roadster, an even smaller car, has always had
a standard trunk-mounted spare that owners could choose to leave in the
garage to increase luggage capacity.
Inside the RX-8's cozy cockpit, the driver is greeted by a low instrument
panel fitted with nicely illuminated gauges, including a large center
tachometer with integrated digital speedometer. Visibility to the front and
side is excellent, and an over-the-shoulder glance finds the right rear
door's small window perfect for checking blind spots before darting into the
adjoining lane.
As a whole, the interior is rather plain and functional, well assembled from
plastic materials of average quality - though those who judge sports cars
based on interior trim are probably not driving enough. One oddity is the
parking brake, shaped like a right triangle and resembling a heavy-duty
stapler. Even when it's down, it looks as if it's still up.
The center console runs from the dashboard clear back to the cover of the
small pass-through to the trunk. Despite this intrusion on the occupants'
personal space, the rear buckets do not feel as cramped as they do in many
coupes with vestigial back seats. The second row is fairly comfortable for
adults, provided they are not tall. Mazda includes rear safety-seat anchors
so you can teach your children heel-and-toe downshifts from an early age.
While you wouldn't necessarily want to travel cross-country in the back of
an RX-8, it could be done, and the rear doors would make it a lot easier to
get out and stretch. It is possible to slide into the rear seats without
forcing the front seat occupants to get out first, or to tilt their seats
forward, provided no one involved is of large build. Alas, regardless of
where they might plan to sit, the big and tall might do well to just pass on
the RX-8, as even Mazda calls the interior "comfortably snug."
Which brings us back to Tony and the inevitable question: Is this four-door
design the right selling point to put guys like him back in a sports car, or
is it just a gimmick?
I would say it is neither. The back seat is a nice feature, though its
practicality might have been enhanced if the car were designed to be a
hatchback. Regardless, Mazda did an excellent job of packaging, even
including a reasonably large trunk.
But while extra doors, seats and trunk space may make the RX-8 easier to
live with, they don't necessarily make it cool. After all, practicality is
not what sells sports cars - or even, often, trucks.
The RX-8 works because it drives better than competitors like the 350Z and
the Audi TT. In the RX-8, Mazda has created a wonderful sports car and a
worthy successor to the RX-7. If this doesn't cause the Tonys to take
notice, nothing will.
INSIDE TRACK: A sports car good enough to make you forget the back seat.
******************************************************************************
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.