Subject: NY Times review of RX-8
From: ACRE
Date: 12/25/2003, 9:33 PM

Jack Beale wrote:

P,

    After reading so much about your RX-8 on this list, I just have to 
write and update you on my Acura RSX-S.  Sure, I drove
the RX-8, and the Nissan 350-Z as well when evaluating which 
car I wanted to buy.  I even drove the Subaru WRX and thought it
was THE car - until I drove the RSX-S.  And, by the way, 
the "S" is the key here, meaning 200 hp with iVETC.

    You recently wrote:


         I love to drive my RX8 fast and it is hard to avoid speeding 
tickets.  It's a real hoot to drive.  If I leave it
     in 6th gear 90% of the time and putter around town with the rest of 
the traffic it gets 20 MPG.

         Due to the total lack of valve overlap the RX8 engine 
does that very well unlike other six speed manual
     transmission cars. If I hotrod it around town with max 
acceleration away from every stop light I do see as low as 15
     MPG.  If I drive it at the 65 MPH freeway speed limit it 
gets 25 MPG.  If I drive it 85 to 90 MPH on the freeway
     (common here in Southern California in those rare times 
when traffic is light) it gets about 20 MPG.

     Paul Lamar

    I gotta say that the RX-8 is a great performing car.  It looks great 
and handles better.  But...  I'll put my RSX-S up
against the RX-8 anytime for handling, acceleration or mileage...  
I too drive the car quite fast.  My experience here in FL is
that I average about 25 mpg for most of my driving (by the way, 
little passes me, normally, so I don't 'baby' it by any
means).   I have yet to see anything south of 25 mpg average.  
While on the highway, under cruise control, at about 78-79 mph,
the car gets 32/33 mpg...!

    It'll travel along in city traffic in 6th gear with no problems,
 and it'll pull in 6th gear when I need to maneuver in
traffic.  Sure, if you want max performance, you need to drop down 
a gear, or two, to get the rpm's up - but, not a big problem,
given a competent driver to do it smoothly.

    Now, let's talk performance - 1/4 mi times are in the mid 
to high 14's at 94 mph.  It'll run 0 - 60 in about 6 seconds - the
only limiting factor being that the peak torque and horsepower aren't 
available until 6,000 rpm.  That hurts the
'standing-start' times, otherwise, I'd guess you'd be seeing sub 
6-sec runs quite easily.

    According to Road & Track, the RSX-S can put together as 
series of turns at the track to equal many of the much higher
priced hardware - BMW's included.  I don't have the opportunity 
to test that around here, due to the flat terrain and mostly
straight roads.  What I can tell you is that the car is nimble and willing.

    To sum, the RSX-S has stunning performance (and mileage) for a 
$24,000 auto.  I believe it'll run with the RX-8.... and beat
the Hell out of it in the mileage department.  Oh yes, I almost 
forgot to mention that the Mazda RX-8 is nearly $10,000 more
expensive than the Acura RSX-S...!

Jack Beale
jack.beale@att.net

What are you doing on this list Jack? :) To really appreciate a rotary you have to
own one. This is my sixth rotary powered car. An RX8 will beat any four passenger 
200 HP car around any road course. Front drive cars unload the inside front tire on
slow speed turns and unload both front tires on low speed acceleration. That 
is why all real racing cars have rear drive. That is also why rear drive cars
are in a whole different class in import drag racing.

You might equal the RX8 in zero to sixty but the RX8 will leave you in the 
dust from 60 on up to 140 MPH. I do it all the time on the freeway as we 
have millions of Acura's and Honda's around here. The Honda and Acura racer 
types see my RX8 on the freeway and they want to challenge me. No contest 
from 60 MPH on up :) 
 
The base price of the RX8 manual TX is $26,000. Not $10,000 plus $25,000 or 
$35,000 as you say. The RX8 auto tx base price is $25,000.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.