Subject: Acura RSX-S and Mazca RX-8 - was: NY Times review of RX-8
From: ACRE
Date: 12/26/2003, 10:22 PM


Jack Beale wrote:

Paul,

  First, to answer your question about why I'm on the list...
I'm interested in learning all about the rotary engine
vis-a-vis application to airplanes (probably in pusher
configuration, as in COZY or SQ2000).  I'm kinda lurking and absorbing,
but I did attend the Rotary Fly-In at Tracy Crooks place
for a little 'hands-on' last summer.


MEANWHILE, BACK AT THE RANCH:

 I didn't mean to imply that the RSX-S would necessarily BEAT the Mazda RX-8.
My intent was to show that it had nearly equal
performance, but with vastly improved fuel economy.  But, since we're talking
performance, I'll call your attention to a
recent Car & Driver Magazine Road Test Annual.  It's the 2003 Ultimate
Comparisons, in which they rank 54 vehicles, including
the RX-8 and the RSX-S.

    On page 12, you'll find the results of the RX-8 tests, and on page 24
you'll find the RSX-S results.  I'll summarize


  Road Course    Street Start
     0-60    0-100    0-130  1/4-mi mph    5-60        Car    Price

     5.9    15.8    33.5   14.4     51.4    7.5     Mazda RX-8   $27,200/$28,300

                   0-120

     6.3    17.2     28.1   15.0    52.9    7.1      Acura   RSX-S  $23,650/$23,650
(yes, I know. same #)


  Yes, the Road Course numbers are suspect.  The magazine doesn't say
what course it is or where it's located.  They may even
be different for the two tests.  I tried to call the magazine to find out,
but wasn't successful.  Also, the Acura wasn't tested
to 130 mph, only 120, so there's a difference there.  However, these numbers
show that the RSX-S runs the road course at a
higher average speed than does the RX-8...!  Surprising...!!

 The price differential works out to $3,550/$4,650 - a far cry from the $10,000
I mentioned in my previous post - sorry.  I
must have gotten a quote from my local dealer at 'retail', leading
to my inflated numbers. At the time, they were trying to
get a premium for the car.  Then, I had thought the cost of the car
would have approached $30,000.  What did you pay for
yours...?

  In the 1/4-mi, there's only a 0.6 sec differential between the
RX-8 and the RSX.  But, as far as time to 140 mph goes, I've
never gone 140 mph - ever.  Fastest I've ever personally piloted a
car was just a shade over 133 mph.  So, for most 'practical
purposes' time to 140 mph is a 'non-issue'.

 Now, if you consider the 'street-start' times, given in the magazine
article; you'll find that from 5-60 mph there's only a
0.4 sec differential.  And, at that, the Acura is the winner - not the RX-8...!

  I guess, what I'm implying is that the RSX-S is a better 'bang-for-the-buck'
than the RX-8.  It has nearly equal performance
and gets much better mileage (25/33); plus, it's about $4,000 bucks cheaper.
Too bad we don't both live in near Laguna Seca...!

To finish, let me quote the article, written by Patrick Bedard, about the RSX-S:


 Occasionally, a machine comes along that's so self-confident, so tightly
screwed together, and so highly trained for
its game that we all just nod our heads and say, "Yup, this is the benchmark."
This little Acura is that sports
     coupe.



Jack Beale
jack.beale@att.net

One thing you need to understand about car magazines they are strongly driven
by new cars advertising and Car & Driver thinks they will get more advertising
revenue out of Acura than Mazda on the RX8. They are not always objective. I
know as Chaba Csere, managing editor of C&D, is a former student of mine.

It's a good car for a piston engine. No doubt about it. It is smaller and lighter
than the RX8 at 2767 pounds. It appears to have the 2L Honda S2000 sports car engine
with a 7900 RPM redline. Max torque at 142 foot pounds is 16 ft lbs less than
the RX8 engine. EPA mileage according to the "S" brochure is 24/31 and not 25/33.
The front suspension is less sophisticated with mcpherson struts instead of
double arms and the wheels and brakes are smaller at 16" and 11.8" rather than
18" and 14" for the RX8. Then again the empty weight is 230 pounds lighter.
It is more of a front drive two door 2+2 sports coupe while the RX8 is more of a four
door sports sedan.  I am sure a two door lighter weight pure sports car version of the
RX8 would do much better. Acura/Honda did a great job keeping the weight down.
Honda certainly builds state of the art piston engines.

The thing that has us all excited about the rotary is it is possible to
get extremely long life out of a rotary. If you keep the cooling system
in good shape and change the nylon lines that feed oil to the apex seals
every ten years 500,000 miles is not out of the question. The engines
are very relaible indeed.

Yes, the Road Course numbers are suspect.  However smaller cars do better
on slaloms or very short road courses.

Paul Lamar

I did a little more research on the RSX-S. Jack has a little pocket rocket
there. Little is the key word. Sort of a four pax motorcycle that Honda does
so well. And I thought the RX8 was small for four pax. No doubt about it. The RSX-S
has a lot of performance for the buck if you don't mind tiny high revving 
piston engines.


-----------  RSX-S ---- RX8
______________________________  
Height       55.1       52.8  
Width        67.9       69.7
Length       172.2      174.2
Weight       2780       2940
Wheelbase    101.2      106.3
Frt. Volume   50        52
Rear Volume   26        38
Trunk Volume  18        8
Total Volume  94        98

The RSX-S scores on trunk volume because it has front wheel drive.
If you take 10 off for the extra trunk volume the scores
are 84 total interior volume for the RSX-S verses 98 for the RX8.
The RSX-S is a smaller car. 
  
BTW Car and Driver said the RSX-S has down sides "Lows:" as they put it. "Way too much 
cockpit noise on textured roads, engine too whirry-whiny around town, straight 
line stability is a bit fuzzy.

I can't say the rotary engine was ever accused of being "too whirry-whiny" :)
The RX8 is also rock solid in a straight line due to the wonderful
electric rack and pinion steering. On the other hand the RX8 has a bit
of freeway hop on certain concrete freeways we have here in So Cal.

Car and Driver put the RX8 in an entirely different class which it
was number one. You need to own a rotary to really appreciate it.
At $27,000 the manual tx version of the RX8 it is a real bargain. 
Snap them up. The price will go up next year.
   
Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.