Subject: Acura RSX-S and Mazca RX-8 - was: NY Times review of RX-8
From: ACRE
Date: 12/27/2003, 3:39 PM


    Paul Lamar wrote:


     I don't think so. According to Car and Driver the RSX-S has 
atrocious braking compared to the RX8. The RSX-S braking
     distance from 70 to 0 was 196 feet!  For the RX8 the same 
number is 161 feet. Another drawback of front weight bias
     front wheel drive.

     On the skid pad the RXS-S could manage only .83 G while the 
RX8 will do .91 G.  In real life that is a tremendous
     difference.  On a real road course that would translate 
into tremendous lap time differences.

     IMHO you made a big mistake Jack :)

     Paul Lamar

    I wrote to C&D yesterday about the Road Course numbers they 
printed in the article we've been discussing.  I asked them
about what course they used and if both cars were evaluated on 
the same course.  I'll let you know if they answer and what they
say...

    However, in the article, the RSX-S beats the RX-8 
around the road course by 12 seconds.  The times given were:

     RX-8        1:20.61    51.4 mph avg. spd.
     RSX-S     1:08.08    52.9 mph avg. spd.


    Given the wide margin in favor of the RX-8 on the skid
 pad and slalom, I'd have given the nod to the RX-8.  However, the
'real world' numbers posted in Road Course results make the RSX-S a 
clear standout...  Could be a different course.  Could be a
tight course, favoring the RSX-S.  Could be that the RSX-S makes 
it easier for a new driver to put together a series of turns
quickly.  Hopefully the editors will shed some light on this.

    But, you know, I'd have to say that it wasn't a mistake, 
per se.  The RSX-S is a wonderful performer.  My problem is that I
can't afford both cars and places to house them, so I could enjoy 
ALL my top picks.  Incidentally, I'd still like to have an
all-wheel drive WRX to play with too...!  Then, there's the BMW M-5, etc., etc., etc.

    Really, just for a lark, take the RSX-S for a test drive 
some slow Saturday afternoon.  Let me know what you think
afterward.  My bet is, that you'll be pleasantly surprised.  
I understand why you picked the RX-8. It's a great car.  I nearly
chose it myself.  In my case, I thought the RSX-S was just a 
bit better bang-for-the-buck.  You don't have to change you mind
about the RX-8 or buy the RSX-S, for that matter - just check it out for kicks...!

Jack Beale
jack.beale@att.net

In your wildest dreams Jack :) Some turkey was driving the RX8.
A 50 MPH average road course is a tight road coarse indeed. A go cart
would have the all time lap record.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.