Subject: Acura RSX-S and Mazca RX-8 - was: NY Times review of RX-8
From: ACRE
Date: 12/27/2003, 10:20 AM


I did a little more research on the RSX-S. Jack has a little pocket rocket there.  Little is the key word. Sort of a four pax
motorcycle that Honda does so well.  And I thought the RX8 was small for four pax.  No doubt about it. The RSX-S has a lot of
performance for the buck if you don't mind tiny high revving piston engines.

-----------  RSX-S ---- RX8
______________________________
Height       55.1       52.8
Width        67.9       69.7
Length       172.2      174.2
Weight       2780       2940
Wheelbase    101.2      106.3
Frt. Volume   50        52
Rear Volume   26        38
Trunk Volume  18        8
Total Volume  94        98

The RSX-S scores on trunk volume because it has front wheel drive.
If you take 10 off for the extra trunk volume the scores
are 84 total interior volume for the RSX-S verses 98 for the RX8.
The RSX-S is a smaller car.

BTW Car and Driver said the RSX-S has down sides "Lows:" as they put it. "Way too much
cockpit noise on textured roads, engine too whirry-whiny around town, straight
line stability is a bit fuzzy.

I can't say the rotary engine was ever accused of being "too whirry-whiny" :)
The RX8 is also rock solid in a straight line due to the wonderful
electric rack and pinion steering. On the other hand the RX8 has a bit
of freeway hop on certain concrete freeways we have here in So Cal.

Car and Driver put the RX8 in an entirely different class which it
was number one. You need to own a rotary to really appreciate it.
At $27,000 the manual tx version of the RX8 it is a real bargain.
Snap them up. The price will go up next year.

Paul Lamar

Jack Beale wrote:

Paul,

    You're correct, the RX-8 has quite a bit more room in the back seat
 area.  The trade-off was trunk-for-seat room.
Personally, I rarely take along more than one passenger, but use the 
trunk more often.  This may be a problem for some - not for
me.  The rear seats are adequate, but not exemplary.

    I like to think of it as a 'pocket-rocket' too; and, no doubt 
about it, it is high revving - to about 8,000 rpm.  I guess it
compares favorably to the RX-8 in the high-revving department.  
When I drove the RX-8, I noticed that you had to get the revs up
to produce the torque we all love to feel.  The RSX-S is no different
 on that score, and you gotta be a 'driver' in both cases
to realize the full potential of the engine.  Both engines are 
extremely smooth - the RX-8 being just a bit smoother when wound
up.  The RSX-S has the nod when you compare low-end torque.

    I agree about the "lows" too.  The cabin noise is just a 
bit high - something I plan to improve by swapping out the Michelin
Pilots that came as standard equipment with a quieter compound 
(the mags all state that the Pilots are much more noisy that the
competition).  Any suggestions for a replacement...?

    And, yes, the straight-line tracking is a bit 'vague'.  
I liken it to the difference between downhill skis and slalom skis.
The slalom skis love to be on edge in a turn and hate to be 'flat' 
on the downhill sections - they wander.  I think the RSX-S is
set-up to slalom...!  But, the more I drive it on the freeway, 
the more refined are my steering inputs, and the better it seems
to track.  Still, it could be better.  Around town, it's very 
agile and easy to maneuver.

    Again, you're right.   C&D put the two vehicles in different 
classes for evaluation.  The RX-8 was tops in it's category,
beating out the other two contenders; and the RSX-S was tops 
in it's category, beating out four of it's rivals.

    Both great cars in the performance category.  Neither is 
perfect by any means.  There are a couple more nit-picky areas that
could have been improved, but nothing that 'bugs' me...

    Paul, I've driven both cars; and, I'd encourage you to 
take a test-drive in the RSX-S, because I think you'll be much more
impressed with it than you THINK you'll be...


Jack Beale
jack.beale@att.net

I don't think so. According to Car and Driver the RSX-S has atrocious braking
compared to the RX8. The RSX-S braking distance from 70 to 0 was 196 feet!
For the RX8 the same number is 161 feet. Another drawback of front weight bias
front wheel drive. 

On the skid pad the RXS-S could manage only .83 G while the RX8 will do .91 G.
In real life that is a tremendous difference.  On a real road course
that would translate into tremendous lap time differences.

IMHO you made a big mistake Jack :)

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.