Greetings. I've just subscribed to your email list. I'm interested in
finding someone that will develop and manufacturer (in volume) a PSRU for a
new rotary engine coming on the market. You were recommended as someone who
may be able to do it, or would know whom I could partner with.
S. Eric McCall
321.632.3399
"S. Eric McCall" wrote:
You added a subject "Wanted: investors for new rotary engine" to my email
when you published it to your mail list, but my original email subject was
merely a reply to yours: "RE: radiator caps". Nothing in the body of my
prior email (included below) said I was trolling your email list for an
investment for a new rotary engine.
I am looking for a technology vendor to partner with on everything needed to
put a rotary engine in an aircraft, from fuel injection, starters, cooling
systems, exhaust systems, and yes, PSRUs. It seemed a request that was
relevant to your group's topic.
I am compelled to agree with one of your readers (the one who suggested that
you at least find out what's going on), and respectfully disagree with your
characterizations of Dr. Moller, Moller International, Freedom Motors, and
the Rotapower Engine.
The fact is, Moller will NEVER make his proprietary version of the Skycar
engine available to the amateur-built and experimental aviation marketplace.
Freedom Motors will NEVER warrant their "industrial/recreational" version of
the engine to the aviation marketplace (putting their engine in an airplane
or helicopter voids the warranty and all factory liability). Rotary
Applications International is the only company that has a sales relationship
that allows us to void their factory warranty, retrofit the engine for the
amateur-built and experimental aircraft sector, to offer a separate aviation
warranty on this third version of the Rotapower engine.
There is a licensed manufacturer of Freedom Motors engines that plans to be
in production by Q2-04. Will they get to market? I don't know yet. But, when
they do, Rotary Applications International will have engines to sell into
the amateur-built and experimental aircraft marketplace.
The best thing to do is just wait and see. Be cautious. Be skeptical. Wait
until the Rotary Applications International version of the Freedom Motors
engine is available for sale. Buy one. Test it out yourself. You want to
know what the SEC said happened with Moller and the SEC? Look up the
allegation on EDGAR (MLER is the OTC stock symbol). You want to know the
truth? Contact Moller directly and they'll put you in touch with the
stockholders who are planning the class action suit, and will provide you
with ample documentation on what really happened.
S. Eric McCall
Rotary Applications International
321.632.3399
1061 Fairlawn Drive
Rockledge, FL 32955
This has nothing to do with radiator caps. It didn't then and it does not now.
A partner implies an investor. We have heard all of this before starting in 1998.
Here are just three of many old messages on the Moller subject over the years.
**********************************************************************
Subject: Freedom motors
Date: Fri, 12 Feb 1999 21:39:55 -0800
From: Paul <rotaryeng@earthlink.net>
Thought you would like to take a look at the Freedom Motors web site. This
company is associated with the Moller skycar that uses four rotary engines.
Interesting info on ducted fan engines.
http://www.freedom-motors.com
Mike Perry
We got a guy on here that worked for Moller as a project engineer
on the Moller rotary engine. I can't wait to here what Jeff says
about this :-)
Paul Lamar
Not much. If Paul Moller had made a decent attempt to market the engine to
jet ski's five years ago I might still be working there.
Jeff Spitzer
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org
******************************************************************************
Subject: moller skycar m400
Date: Fri, 19 Jul 2002 11:19:56 -0700
From: ACRE NL <rotaryeng@earthlink.net>
http://www.moller.com/skycar/m400/
Looking at these numbers the average lay person would say no
way. Are the engines turbo charged to allow 29,000 feet?
Not necessarily. I don't have the lapse rate at my finger tips
but if you start with 650 HP you might have enough power left over
at
29,000 feet to go 345 MPH. No matter it really does not make
any difference.
Cruise... 345 mph
Range.... 900 miles
Fuel..... 28 mpg
Alitude.. 29,000 feet
Gross.... 2400 pounds
Max Power 645 hp
Let us say he got the BSFC down to .4 on all four engines.
A very good number for rotaries.
This trip will take 2.6 hours. 28 MPG is 32 gallons
of fuel. 32 gallons is about 193 pounds of fuel.
193 divided by 2.6 hours is 74 pounds per hour total for all
four engines. At a BSFC of .4 that is 185 total cruise HP
for 345 MPH at 29,000 feet for a four passenger airplane.
Not bloody likely!! Particularly with low efficiency ducted fans.
See the chart below.
Did I do the numbers right?
With friends like Paul Moller the rotary does not need any
enemies.
Paul Lamar
"Bruce E. Calkins" wrote:
Paul Lamar apparently sees himself as knowledgeable of aircraft
performance.
As such he should know that maximum mileage or range or L/D does not
occur
at maximum speed. Since when does your car get its maximum mileage
at its
maximum speed?
What we have published and stand by is that the Skycar gets its
maximum
mileage at 215 MPH at 29,000 feet or at 140 MPH at sea level. A
specific
fuel consumption of .4 pounds per horsepower-hour can only be
achieved at
altitude by turbo-charging some of the Skycar's engines.
Since I have a hard time believing Mr. Lamar could really possess
such
faulty reasoning I have to assume he purposely chose to mislead his
readers.
Paul Moller
Hey I am just going with what is on your web site Paul.
It says cruise "345 MPH"
Here is a capture of your page.
I'll rerun the numbers for 215 MPH.
215 MPH 900 miles 4.18 hours. 28 mpg 32 gallons 193 pounds of fuel.
Total. 46 pounds of fuel per hour. .4 BSFC 115 HP! Equally
unlikely.
A turbo will not change the BSFC by much. In fact it might increase
it some what. Lets say the BSFC is .45 then the HP comes out
at 102 HP for 215 MPH equally unlikely.
Most of the guys on here are struggling to get 200 MPH on 160 to 180
HP with a high efficiency prop. It is a rare airplane that
will go 200 MPH on 100 HP.
If indeed cruise is only 140 MPH the numbers are
900 miles. 6.42 hours. 28 MPG. 193 pounds of fuel. 30 pounds per hour.
0.4 BSFC... 75 HP! Possible. I know of nobody flying a 345 MPH
airplane
that cruises it at 140 MPH. Kind of weird.
I think it is you Paul that are trying to mislead people.
You can clear it up by stating on your web site at what cruise speed
you are getting 28 MPG.
Paul Lamar
Who cares about mpg. It looks cool!
Actually, 160 HP RV's at altitude are probably not producing more than
100 HP
(65%) and yet approaching 200 mph. Still, the "345 mph cruise" and "28
mpg" could
easily make one assume it's 28 mpg at cruise (e.g. 345 mph).
Finn
After thinking about it a bit and considering its "wing area" or lack
thereof I kind of doubt it could maintain level flight at 140 mph without
some down thrust from the ducted fans. That takes additional HP. That
would severely cut into the "28 mpg".
According to this chart from Kuchemann & Weber ducted fans are only 60%
efficient compared to 80% for a good prop. That means you would
get 128 net HP out of the 160 HP engine with a prop but only
96 net HP out of the 160 HP engine with a ducted fan.
In other words to achieve what an RV achieves with 160 HP engine
the Moller Skycar engine would need 213 HP.
Don't get me wrong about all this. I like the idea of the SkyCar
and I have defended Paul Moller in the past as Perry Mick will tell
you and you would find out if you read some of the real old messages
on the CD.
I am getting a bit tired of waiting however for a first flight.
A tethered flight does not count. I see no reason why the control system
could not be achieved with the computer technology we had ten years ago.
Unless of course there is something seriously wrong somewhere that I
don't know about. Perhaps the engines are not generating the HP claimed.
Perhaps the real time computer control system design is beyond Paul
Moller.
Perhaps the duct efficiency is worse than I think it is. What in hell is
holding them up? Why isn't the military falling all over themselves
lining up to buy SkyCars? What do they know that we don't know?
The other thing that is bothering me about this Freedom Motors subsidiary
operation is we were promised Moller rotary engines in production back in
the first quarter of 2001. It is now the second quarter of 2002 and no
sign of any engines at all anywhere for any purpose. Who is getting
the engines if anyone? Where can I go to see any Moller engine run?
Paul Lamar
Well with vapor ware I guess you can make any claims you want since you
will never have to prove them. This thing has been on the cover of Pop
Science
and Pop Mech about a dozen times, and one time is the kiss of death,
I am just thankful that he is not using my money (and I intend to keep
it that way) Vance
************************************************************************
Subject: Freedom motor announcement?
Date: Tue, 06 May 2003 09:30:52 -0700
From: ACRE <rotaryeng@earthlink.net>
> >>>>>>>> Paul
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> I just checked up on the Moeller site and see where Freedom
>> Motors
>>> is
>>>>>>>> taking orders for their
>>>>>>>> engines.
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> "Beta versions of the RotapowerŪ 650 and 1300 will be available
>>> this
>>>>>>>> summer and priced at $5,000
>>>>>>>> and $7,000, respectively. Volume pricing reductions will be
>>> announced
>>>>>>>> as production levels
>>>>>>>> increase later this year. "
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> www.freedom-motors.com/
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> Thought I would pass this along to the group.
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> Mike Perry
>>
>>>>>>> What ever you do don't send them any money.
>>
>>>>>> They have had the same message up for 3+ years. Paul Moller
>> recently
>>>>>> plead guilty to stock violations.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Hans Conser
>>
>>>> "Bruce E. Calkins" wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>> The Rotapower 650 announcement went up a few days ago. If you will
>>> notice,
>>>>> Freedom Motors had planned to put the 530cc engine into production
>>> first,
>>>>> but because of the interest received in the larger
>>> displacement/horsepower
>>>>> output engine the 650cc is being produced first.
>>>>>
>>>>> Also, Dr. Moller did not "plead guilty" to anything. Rather than
>>>>> go
>>> into a
>>>>> long battle with the SEC, he agreed to pay a fine.
>>>>>
>>>>> -MI
>>
>>>> I'll believe after I see it run for 500 hours Bruce. Its going to
>>>> take
>> you
>>>> years to overcome your image. Best change your company name and hide
>>>> the owner ship of the new company.
>>>>
>>>> Paul Lamar
>
>
>> wadebush wrote:
>>>
>>> Bruce,
>>> Instead of being defensive about the engine why not put one of your
>>> 650cc
>>> engine in an airplane and fly it around to all the shows
>>> demonstrating
>> that
>>> it works. Better yet, one of each.
>>> After some real air time hours, people not wanting to "roll their
>>> own" can
>>> go "drop in" for their aircraft engines through you guys (Moeller /
>> Freedom
>>> Motors).
>>> Until then the only "proven" (real air time rotaries) are the ones
>>> that
>>> actually fly and are able to make it to the shows.
>>
>>> Paul has to be somewhat conservative especially on anything not
>>> flown. To
>>> tell
>>> everyone "yes, go and buy one" would put him at odds with potential
>> lawsuits
>>> and mad patrons should some unforeseen problem arise in the Freedom
>>> motor.
>>> The engine is different enough thats its reliability is yet unproven
>>> especially without a flying example. Of course people would be
>>> interested
>>> but there will always be those that choose to pioneer their own way
>>> or, as
>>> in my case, save tons of money while learning a subject extremely
>>> interesting to me.
>>> Just my take on this, but I could be wrong.
>>>
>>> Wade Bush
>>
>
> "Bruce E. Calkins" wrote:
>>
>> Dear Wade,
>>
>> We have been working with a group which intends to offer the engine
>> to the
>> aviation community and they, in turn, have been talking with a
>> aircraft
>> builder. My understanding is that they will be getting one of the
>> first 50
>> engines that come out of our partner's facility in Minnesota and that
>> it
>> will be modified and used in some sort of aircraft application. I
>> have not
>> been part of that discussion. We are concentrating on the engine
>> production
>> requirements and meeting specifications for a number of non-aviation
>> related
>> applications as our top priority.
>>
>> Like Mr. Lamar, we do not suggest that one of the first applications
>> of this
>> engine be in an aircraft. We would prefer to establish a performance
>> history with a less safety-critical application. But we have little
>> control
>> of the engine once it is sold and, realizing this, when we were
>> approached
> >> by the group mentioned above, we suggested that they run independent
>> tests
>> and do their own evaluation. Given the outcome is positive and the
>> "first
>> articles" coming out of our manufacturing effort are suitable for
>> their use
>> in an aircraft, they will proceed.
>>
>> Again, we want our rotary engine to gain acceptance in a wide range of
>> applications and have been working steadily (although slowly) towards
>> that
>> goal since we acquired the OMC design in the mid-1980's. I know that
>> many
>> people have become frustrated with our apparent lack of progress, but
>> we
>> continued to work on both the 530 and 650 designs at our own expense.
>> Our
>> requirements lead us to look first at the 530, but other industries
>> needed
>> the additional horsepower of the 650 (50 hp vs. 75 hp, respectively).
>>
>> We have slowly acquired all the specialized equipment needed to
>> produce the
>> engine in volume and built tooling for both the 530 and 650 engines,
>> with
>> custom tooling for the version required for our ducted fan
>> application.
>> Furthermore, we've been testing the engine in various configurations
>> in our
>> dyno facility nearly continuously for the past three years
>> (two-to-three
>> builds a week), and in a ducted fan test stand for about two years.
>> The
>> eight 530 engines in the Skycar have now been in used periodically
>> for about
>> 2 years and in a more than 20 brief hover flights over the past year.
>>
>> I appreciate that it has taken us a long time to bring the Rotapower
>> engine
>> to this point but I hope that we can get an unbiased appraisal of the
>> engine, regardless of how long it takes. As rotary engine
>> supporters, I
>> continue to think that this could be your goal as well.
>>
>> Sincerely,
>>
>> Bruce E. Calkins
>> General Manager
>> Moller International
>> (530) 756-5086
>> www.moller.com
Bruce, I think we all want you to succeed. However, over the years
people keep sending emails to the list announcing that they read on
your website that you are about to go into production with the motors,
and we haven't seen it yet despite it saying so on the website all
these years... So we are understandably skeptical.
I am curious as to just who is your partner in Minnesota, RotaMax, Inc?
Web searches don't find it listed anywhere except on your website.
The only snowmobile manufacturer I know of in Minnnesota that I know of
is Polaris, very conservative company, unlikely to put a wankel in
their machines.
Paul is right about the aviation market of course, at 75 HP you are
competing against very inexpensive two strokes...
Hans Conser
They wont make it in the snowmobile world as most of them are
putting out 125 to 175 hp off the showroom floor and the freedom
motor costs dam near as much as the whole snowmobile.
Ken Welter
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.