Subject: Powersport and Bill J
From: ACRE
Date: 1/28/2004, 9:00 PM


I'm not sure but I think the Vans engines - though new - are not
certified.
Also, I just checked the prices they offer. (BTW 200hp 33,500 + install)
By the time you add all that is needed to run the Lyc you speak of it
will add up to
significantly more than our package. (they need mounts
etc too.)


Tedd,
 I am going to write on this subject once more. First, to present my own 
personal situation, and second to offer some clarification.
 COST is MY FIRST, LAST, and MIDDLE consideration. I am not wealthy,
 and work a 9 to 5'er. I have changed the plane I wanted to build 
several times, not due to wanting to but because of COST. I first 
looked at Lancairs, (who didn't) fast good looking and, to my despair 
hideously expensive. Second I looked at Glassairs, nice kits but at 
the time the company was having money problems. The new Glassair 
company is doing a good job, but alas again the kits were too expensive.

 I then had the good fortune of running into Rich Trickel, and the KIS. 
I was ready to buy, (in fact negotiating the loan), when Rich sold the 
kit line to PULSAR. They have done a good job carrying on the KIS line 
but raised the price 10K over what I had agreed to pay to Rich. Bummer. 

I was pursuing a 4 place since I am a big guy, over 6' and heavy at
 near 300. I don't want a 30" wide cockpit or even a 36"! The Vans 
2 place kits would be fine but I am a press fit in any of the 2 place 
machines. The RV 10 came out and I bought one as fast as I could. I 
believe I'm in the first 20. The Kit price is still probably going 
to be more than I would like but I can take my time. Vans will be here for a while.


 I have long been a alternate engine fan and I was able to acquire 
a 20B for $2500 in what seems like good shape. I looked at the 
Powersport conversion but could not afford it.

 I still like the Powersport reduction drive. The clarification 
I think needs be made on the powersport drive is the tooth contact
 comment Paul made. The Powersport drive has multiple tooth contact
 built into the design and should handle power well. The design went 
the "high stiffness" route which I personally like as an engineer. 
Tracy went the low stiffness route, a different but equally valid 
approach. 

I spent time speaking to Steven W. the engineer of the 
drive. He is a knowledgeable professional engineer and could qualify 
all of his compromises. Tracy openly discusses the design trade 
offs on his site as well. My problem is once again the cost. Tracy 
needs make fewer parts since his design uses auto trans parts. It is 
much cheaper than Powersports. I won't argue the Planetary/ring gear 
reduction, other than to say that planetary MUST be held to VERY close 
tolerances if it is to be successful. There is no way to adjust the 
sun gear centerline and to achieve the multiple tooth contacts we desire 
in the six pinion carrier the accuracy needed is ±.001 inches. Far from 
impossible but difficult. 

Many of the Ross failures I have seen I would 
attribute to sun gear misalignment, (causing single tooth engagement 
until the drive tooth deflects enough to engage the next pinion), 
over stressing the single or perhaps two teeth in contact. This is 
never more important than is the 20B turbo producing higher continuous
power. Tracys units look very well made. If I buy one I still plan to 
do a 100% inspection to assure myself of the units accuracy. The 
Powersport unit is adjustable on pinion contact, an excellent feature. 
I also like the integrated flywheel and counter weight, which buys 
back some of the weight difference.

 There, I have offered both sides of the story. Even if I preferred 
the Powersport unit, cost, $6500 list plus more if I want to use 
the Powersport engine mounts, may price it out of my range. Tracy 
offers an great price, and I can get several ratios which I like. 
I differ from Paul in that I am not a complete planetary affectionado. 

Tedd the one thing in which I TOTALLY agree with Paul is that if you 
want to sell units you must, fly that thing all over the country. You
need to take a hard look at the radiator location since you lose 
tremendously by mounting against the firewall. Paul has PROVED 
his point here and has often given out the NACA data and SAE papers 
to back up what he says.

 WE (capitals), all the rotary lovers, must remember the words of 
Ben Franklin, "We must all hang together, or we will all surely hang 
separately". I think the rotary is a great aircraft engine and I intend 
to prove it in my plane prices permitting.
Bill Jepson

PS. Tedd the vans engines are ALL certified, they don't even offer 
an non certified version since they are brand new from Lycoming! 
Don't try to wriggle around about prices, face facts as we the 
customers must. Mattituck, a fairly well known engine builder, 
is offering the ASSEMBLED superior TMX IO-360 200 HP engine at 
$18,800 and Fadec equipped at $23,900 These are experimental 
engines built from certified parts. WRJ

Whew! Wrap them lines a bit shorter Bill please.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.