Tom Webber wrote:
Well the rotary is not most ICE's. It is unique. As I said the problem is
combustion chamber wall temperature in most ICE's. Especially the area
between the exhaust valves and spark plug holes. The wankel rotary is
a rotating combustion chamber engine. Therefore the wall temperature
are much lower and they are lined with steel and cast iron.
Yes if you are using an aluminum intake manifold which I am sure
Lynn is. The 300 degree F engine was well researched in the early
1930's and again by Continental with the Voyager series.
The engine that took Dick Rutan and Jeana Yeager around the world
was designed to run at 250 F. That is how they got the BSFC so low.
In fact I don't think it would have made it if it was running at 180 F.
I highly recommend getting this SAE paper. In fact I highly recommend
everybody obtain the books and technical papers listed on the ACRE NL web site.
It would certainly make my job a lot easier.
I don't make this stuff up.
Paul Lamar
So, if we keep the combustion charge hotter, the intake charge cooler, we will increase the BSFC. The problem is the increase in heat will transfer to the engine through the housings, which is detrimental to the integrity of the engine and its longevity. So if we keep the heat in the combustion area and reduce the transfer to the engine we may see the benefits. So has anyone had the combustion face coated on the rotors? I was thinking of doing this but am leery of the coating coming off. The rotor faces are not a wear area so if would be just expansion and contraction of the rotor itself that may cause the coating to crack and flake. Any help here is greatly appreciated. I must say I really appreciate the depth of experience and knowledge in this group. There is not a day that I don't learn something from this list. My thanks to all of you, Regards, Tom Webber
I think coatings are not worth the risk.
The facts are nobody to my knowledge has instrumented the combustion chamber walls in a rotary and then changed the water temp or coated anything to see the effect on the metal temp.
Continental experimented on the Voyager series and found going from 250 F water to 290 F water had no effect on the metal temp. That too was a large surprise for me. Perhaps there is some local boiling going on near the combustion chamber. I also suspect it is highly configuration sensitive such as the absences or presence of internal fins in the water jacket. In theory for a given amount of heat there are far more square inches of combustion chamber walls in a rotary.
Just going from boiling at 220 F to boiling at 275 F would give us a huge benefit. That is because the ambient air can be 100 F while the rad is 220 F or a 120 F differences. the rate of heat transfer is directly proportional to the temp difference. If we got to 275 F the difference would be 175 F or close to a 50% increase in cooling capability. This fact was what was driving the liquid cooled aircraft engine builders to develop high temp engines.
BTW air cooled engines run at cylinder head temperatures of 400 F to 500 F and nobody is saying they have any problems with loss of HP or sudden catastrophic failure. Sure we all know they fail from time to time. The most likely failure mode is exhaust valve failure. Well guess what? Rotaries don't have exhaust valves. I am sure that does not come as a surprise to anyone on here.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.