Subject: Major Break through in rotary engine cooling.
From: ACRE
Date: 2/5/2004, 7:24 PM


 >      You would think I was asking for the moon here. I would
      not be a bit surprised if many people are running their
      car engines with a 80% EG mixture as we speak. These
      engines are not automatically catastrophically failing
      because of it. All I want to do is go to a 90 or 95%
      mixture.

 As you correctly pointed out in an earlier post, conditions are very
 different for a car and an airplane. Cars do not run sustained high
 output (except in certain racing classes -- and you can bet that the
 successful cars are pretty careful about their cooling systems and
 coolants). Typical car engine average road load is something less
 than 30%. I would bet the farm that 99% of car engines NEVER see
 full power even for an instant in their entire lives. The few that
 do never do it for more than a few seconds at a time. You could
 probably run a car engine for its whole life on almost any liquid
 that you can pump through the block without failing it, as long as
 you stay at 30% power. Also, piston engines with their century plus
 of development by thousands of companies and tens of thousands (if
 not hundreds of thousands) of tier two and tier three suppliers are
 pretty robust animals now (in the applications for which they are
 intended). The poor little 13b (and its 12a sibling) are about the
 ONLY liquid cooled rotary engines that have had any meaningful
 operational experience outside the laboratory. Its a glaring
 difference in maturity.

 I don't know what would happen if you ran 80% EG in a high output
 rotary engine... just not sure to what benefit? The radiator would
 have to be even larger than it is now... if you just stuck that same
 larger radiator in the airframe (ASSUMING that the air flow was
 right)  with 50-50 coolant, you would solve the boiling problem with
 zero additional risk.

 Jon


It does happen out here in the west. People use their cars and pick up
trucks
to tow trailers over mountains. As much as 150 to 200 HP can be
required.
As I mentioned they are not generally careful about the antifreeze
mix. Could be 20% or it could be 80% This can happen on a 100 degree F
day here on what we call the Grape Vine. A long infamous grade up over
the mountains surrounding the LA area. Now you do indeed see some
pulled over to the side from time to time but thousands of others make
it with no problem. The ones that pull over let their engines cool a
bit and then add some water from the road side reservoirs that are
provided for that purpose. Obviously this changes the mix. If all the
antifreeze is gone they may wind up with pure water. They then
continue on their way with no permanent engine damage. It would be
interesting to hang around out there and
gather samples.

Paul Lamar


   I have been running propylene glycol for many many years, long
before Sierra was ever around.
  I got it from the diesel truck world as they found that it stopped
cavitation of the water pump and cylinder walls and damage of the
cylinders from the cavitation.
  The VW waserboxer engine that I was pumping over 500 hp out of and
my snowmobile suffered the same kind of cylinder damage as the
diesels did and the propylene glycol eliminated that.
   I have only run Sierra and Evans propylene glycol in my coot in the
1100 hrs of flying and they seem to work fine.
  The Evens is run strait with no water and boils at 360 degrees and
worked great but I was concerned about the fact that it gelled in sub
zero temps that I fly in so I went back to a 60 Sierra 40 water mix.
  I would never think about running ethylene glycol and I also think
that ethylene glycol should be banned and as a manufacturer of off
road race car parts I am about one of the biggest anti
environmentalists there are, there just ain't no reason for it any
more.

  Ken

Thanks Ken. Well there you have it Jon.

Paul Lamar

The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.