I think you are missing something here Jon. When you are in a car or a boat and your engine boils over it is not life threatening. You pull over to the side of the road
or row home. Not so in an airplane. Perhaps having the boiling temp (not necessarily the operating temp) up around 300 degrees is a safety issue. Perhaps we can find something better than 90%, 95% or pure ethylene glycol. I think it is a worthwhile goal.
No argument whatsoever. What I would try to address is "what might cause the coolant to boil?" First of all, with a properly designed and operational cooling system, it WILL NOT boil under any conditions that one will encounter. What failure modes will cause it to boil? (I hope others will add to this brainstorming list...)
1. Water pump stops turning -- belt failure.
2. Water pump stops turning -- seizure or other pump mechanical failure
3. Thermostat sticks closed
4. Airflow to radiator impeded
5. Collapse of hose
6. Blockage of fluid flow with debris
7. Loss of sufficient coolant allowing pump to ventilate (NOT cavitate!)
8. Loss of system pressure (in conjunction with high power / high altitude) due to failure of pressure cap
9. Loss of system pressure due to loss of coolant.
Will any of these be addressed by a different coolant media? Perhaps numbers 3, 4, and
8. I think 3 could be addressed as you have proposed -- design the system to leave the damn thing out (although I think they are pretty reliable devices, especially if they are changed on a reasonable PM schedule). I would guess that number 4 is pretty unlikely to occur.
Jon
That reminds me of what Jim Mederer said when we were talking about apex seal fracture
when the turbo engines detonated. Jim said; "Well then just don't let it detonate!" :)
A fuel pump could fail, a filter could plug or an injector could fail causing a too lean
mixture.
Those cooling system failure modes you mentioned above are rare in our aircraft fortunately. Most people are competent enough to handle all those details in a very reliable manner. Those issues are straight forward and easy to deal with. True those failure modes can lead to emergencies in the air just like a failed fuel system.
What is common is improperly designed radiator installations and air ducting. This leads to marginal cooling systems that tend to boil over when ambient air temperatures hit 90 F and above. A ten or twenty degree F increase in the boiling temperature can be very helpful because of the rapid rise in heat transfer with the increase in delta T.
Properly designed is the key. It is not easy to design a cooling system in an airplane. People make mistakes and there is a lot we still don't know. We are slowly evolving towards a properly designed cooling system but at this rate it will take another ten years. It took the aircraft industry 50 years starting in 1903 and cooling system design was still evolving up until the liquid cooled aircraft engine was replaced by the turbojet. Since then other than what we and the other alternative engine guys are doing the design evolution has stagnated.
You would think I was asking for the moon here. I would not be a bit surprised if many people are running their car engines with a 80% EG mixture as we speak. These engines are not automatically catastrophically failing because of it. All I want to do is go to a 90 or 95% mixture.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.