> I have only run Sierra and Evans propylene glycol in
my coot in the
> 1100 hrs of flying and they seem to work fine.
> The Evens is run strait with no water and boils at 360
degrees and
> worked great but I was concerned about the fact that it
gelled in sub
> zero temps that I fly in so I went back to a 60 Sierra
40 water mix.
> I would never think about running ethylene glycol and
I also think
> that ethylene glycol should be banned and as a
manufacturer of off
> road race car parts I am about one of the biggest anti
> environmentalists there are, there just ain't no reason
for it any
> more.
>
> Ken
Thanks Ken. Well there you have it Jon.
Paul Lamar
Hi. First, I want to clarify my intentions on this thread... I'm NOT
out to pick a fight or prove someone wrong or right... just trying
to raise what I think are very valid engineering concerns and to
recognize that the risk-benefit analysis should be made pretty
carefully. I don't know enough about the properties of the Evans
coolant to offer an opinion. I also don't know how long Ken ran on
straight Evans. Running on 60-40 Sierra shouldn't be DRASTICALLY
different from running 50-50 EG-Water. Lastly, I don't know how much
margin there is in the design of the 13b -- in other words, at what
power level does rotor housing cooling become the limitation,
and can some of that margin be sacrificed safely by using a less
efficient heat transfer fluid. That last sentence is, I think, the
crux of the issue.
Regarding cars / trucks overheating in the mountains when towing
trailers... It happens (I think) because the vehicle cooling system
is woefully underdesigned if the intention is to pull a lot of power
continuously. Also, I stand by my statement that NO cars run full
rated power, even hauling trailers through the mountains. Full rated
power occurs at or near the "redline" RPM, with foot on the floor!
Not living in the mountains, I don't know for sure, but I doubt that
one is running the car at 5500RPM wide open throttle for more than a
few moments even when trying to climb a steep grade. As a "sanity
check" on the cooling system design, look at the fan and radiator
size of an American V-8 sedan or pick up truck rated at about 300
hp. Now, look at the fan and radiator size of an over the road
tractor trailer. The power rating is pretty similar, and the diesel
engine's heat rejection to the coolant is quite a bit lower than for
the car... but the heavy duty truck's radiator is probably four
times the size of the pick-up truck's radiator.
Jon
Good points Jon. One big difference is the big trucks go up the hill
at
30 MPH where the dynamic pressure to force air through the rad is
1/4 of what it is at 60 MPH. With a big rad you can use a bigger
higher
HP fan. On a five percent grade at 30 mph or 44 FPS forward speed
is 2.2 FPS straight up. At 60,000 pound gross weight that is 132,000
ft pound seconds or 240 HP not counting the considerable tire rolling
drag. That is why they only go 30 MPH.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.