Subject: Major Break through in rotary engine cooling. History
From: ACRE
Date: 2/10/2004, 1:15 AM


     >      "The nature of vapor production in pressurized
     water is
     >      that the
     >      temperature remains constant as long as liquid is
     present,
     >      a very
     >      desirable
     >      feature within the heads."
     >
     >      Jon,
     >      This comment from the above passage from the Vee's
     for
     >      Victory book
     >      hint at the nonlinear relationship between the
     metal
     >      temperature and
     >      the coolant temperature discovered by Continental
     in the
     >      Voyager
     >      series experiments. I see no fundamental
     differences
     >      around the spark
     >      plug bosses in the rotary. I hope to verify this
     with the
     >      thermal
     >      couples placed within a mm or so of the combustion
     >      chamber.
     >
     >      Paul Lamar
     >
     > Your data will be very instructive.
     >
     > The quoted comment states the facts about nucleate
     boiling very
     > concisely, but it must be carefully read in context...
     They are
     > saying that as long as there is liquid available to
     recondense the
     > nucleate boiling bubbles, and thus preventing film
     boiling, the
     > metal temperature will rise very slightly even as the
     heat flux goes
     > up quite a lot. This is fully consistent with everything
     I have
     > written. The unwritten flip side of the coin is that if
     nucleate
     > boiling is NOT present (hence no "vapor formation" in
     the
     > pressurized water) the metal temperature WILL rise with
     increasing
     > heat flux. The most important part of what I have
     written previously
     > is that the use of a fluid with a higher boiling point
     will
     > delay the start of nucleate boiling at the high heat
     flux zone of
     > the rotor housing. This WILL result in higher metal
     temperatures.
     > This MAY reduce the durability of the engine.
     >
     > Jon

     I don't understand your passion on this Jon. You have an
     unlimited
     supply of cold water to cool your rotary boat engines but
     we are
     forced to use 100 F ambient air. As such this is far more
     important in
     the context of cooling the aircraft engine.
     Drag for us in terms of smaller radiators are also very
     important
     while the amount of cooling water drawn from the ocean
     hardly matters
     at all. I just think we need to take another look at this
     problem from
     our new perspective.

     Paul Lamar


My "passion" on this has nothing to do with marine applications,
where cooling is really, really, really easy, as you say. It comes
from having been down this path before (yes, for aviation
applications), and I'm just trying to give you the benefit of my
experience. I will NOT say that you shouldn't try things... the only
opinion that matters in all this is that demonstrated by the ENGINE!
So, despite how I might come across, I heartily encourage you to try
stuff and share the results... But I would use a great deal of
caution in drawing conclusions without the benefit of sufficient
testing.

The fact that Ken used Evans PG for 1100 hours without cooling
problems is very encouraging. PG has similar characteristics as a
cooling fluid to pure EG.

Paul Lamar

"Weinstock, Rob" wrote:

The last time I plowed through the Evans website, I discovered that PG
is much more viscous than water. The implication is that the standard
water pump probably won't be sufficient, and indeed there are "heavy
duty" water pumps sold on the Evans website for common engines, e.g.,
Chevy small block. The other consideration is that the power required to
drive the pump will be greater, too.

I would think that if this stuff were so great, it would popular with
say, diesel truck fleet owners. But, it isn't, yet.

Regards,

Rob--

In working with liquid cooled rockets, the only thing that was demonstrated
better than water was hydrogen. With water you can extract heat at up to
about 20 BTUs per square inch second (that is second - 1/60th 0f a minute)
That is way higher than you could possibly ever use, With about 6000F
and 3000psi on the shuttle engine they are pulling about 90 BTU/inch
squared second at the sonic throat.
Vance

 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.