Subject: Maybe We Don't Need One... RE: Aux. Oil Pump for PSRU
From: ACRE
Date: 2/19/2004, 11:23 PM


Mark Steitle wrote:

Paul,
The recent article on the custom built 4-rotor talks about an auxilary oil
pump fitted to the metering pump pad.  I was curious if it would be
beneficial to use the metering pump pad to mount a separate psru pump,
along with a separate oil reservoir.  This would allow the use of gear
lube
vs. engine oil in the psru.  While this would add weight and complexity,
it
seems that if it would extend the life of the psru considerably it might
be
worth it.  I would appreciate your thoughts on this.

Mark S.


I think that is a good idea. I am a bit skeptical if the drive has
enough
torque capacity to drive a high pressure engine oil pump however.
The gears are kind of small. Here is a small oil pump I made out
of pinion stock.

Paul Lamar


We may not have to change the gearboxes or their fluids - this was one of
the areas I wanted to cover with the oil analysis project.  It seems that
the fluid we need for our redrives is something that can handle the heat of
the engine while retaining enough high-temp performance to provide strong
protection for the gears and bearings of the redrive.  We need something
with enough extreme pressure (EP) capability to protect like a gear lube in
the gearbox where we have metal-to-metal contact.  We also need something
that can handle the heat of the rotors without turning to carbon.  If we had
a fluid that would transfer the heat to the case of the gearbox better, that
would be a plus.  I'll bet we can use off-the-shelf 10w40 synthetic motor
oil and get decent performance in both ends of the drive system.

The synth will flow much easier than even a synth gear lube (an 80w90 gear
lube viscosity at 100c is roughly equal to an SAE 50 motor oil).  The
synthetic lube has more than enough high-temperature capacity to resist
breaking-down in the engine, and will offer superior gear protection.  We'll
want oil with a strong high-temperature/high shear capability so that our
10w40 stays a 40 and isn't sheared down to a 20 or 30 by the gears.  (This
will tend to eliminate most petroleum products.  To get multigrade
performance with petroleum, companies generally use a fluid with a lower
viscosity and add viscosity improvers (VI) to the mix.  The VI additives are
polymers that shrink when cold and expand with hot - lower viscosity at 40c,
higher at 100c.  The downside is that these polymers are the first
components to be severed by gear action - they're actually 'sheared' into
shorter strands and the fluid no longer has a hot viscosity of 40 - it's
more like a 25 or 30.  The full synthetic base stocks naturally have the
temperature range and generally don't need VI additives - thus they aren't
there to shear down.)  If we want to strengthen the EP capability of the
oil, we can start with a premium product with higher levels of EP additives,
or add a bit of STP.  The zinc (ZDDP - zinc dithiophosphate) in the STP is
the primary EP additive and oxidation inhibitor in most motor oils - along
with calcium and phosphorus compounds.  Another benefit of a synthetic fluid
is that it transfers heat better than petroleum.  The gearbox will run
significantly cooler due to decreased friction and better heat transfer.
While a 20-50 degree decrease in temp is common in transmissions, we're
sharing our oil with the engine and the temps will be determined more by
water temps (this will take a little load off our radiators though...).

I have two volunteers for the oil analysis project that are using belt
reductions.  These gentlemen will give us a picture of the way the engine is
wearing and how the oil changes with the addition of the 2-cycle oil.  (And
that's it!  Who's flying with a gear drive and will donate 6 ounces of used
oil for the group?)  Once we get some samples from folks running gearboxes,
we can start to get a picture of how the redrives are wearing.  Then we'll
be closer to knowing if we need to change anything.

Andy

Tracy is already running Mobil 1 in his engine. The problem is the oil
in the engine runs 220 degree F. The gear box does not need to run at
that 
temp. The life of the gears is sure to be higher if the box is kept
cooler while using oil that is best suited to gears. That means
extreme
pressure gear lube synthetic 15W 50 or some such.  Also as some one
pointed out a problem in the engine does not need to destroy the gear
box and
vice versa.
 
Paul Lamar 

The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.