-"Decker, Michael" wrote:
Have you taken a look at the tensile modulus for polycarbonate lately?
It's
not that hard to design bubble shapes that spread loads in tension of
this
type. The abuttments are a little bit harder but not impossible.
Would I stake my life on this, (as will the test pilot), NO.
I do agree on the point that scavenged turbo is a poor source of
pressurization.
My major experience of this type is in vacuum chambers, not pressure. I
like this subject, though, and invite those who've been there and done
that
to opine.
Mike Decker
Don't keep us in the dark Mike. What is it? Most people use acrylic
windshields. I tried to buy a Lexan for my Cruiser and nobody
wanted to do it.
Paul Lamar
"Decker, Michael" wrote:
My (somewhat) carefully considered response...
I can think of a few different reasons why people would prefer not to do
windscreens in polycarbonate, (Lexan) the foremost is the temperatures
needed for thermoforming compared to acrylic (210F vs. 285F). this means
that your oven for big parts can become complex (read expensive). Couple
that with the tendency toward optical distortion and the fact that polycarb
is nearly impossible to polish, and I can see why it is difficult to find a
vendor to form it for you.
If I did a job like this I'd chemical etch the words, "NOT FOR USE IN
AIRCRAFT", on the part. That being said, I'll remind you of the post by the
carbon fiber guru who explained how a company decides what a job will cost.
To build one only of most things requires much more labor/piece than to
build 10 or 1000 or 1000000. I think most fabricators of acrylic goods
would shy away from this because there is a lot of front end work involved,
and the likelyhood of a pissed off customer is high. The list of potential
complaints is practically endless and most of them are not easily overcome.
If there is a precise specification and a sufficient market someone will be
willing to build it.
I will most definitely be putting a polycarb windscreen/bubble on my Cozy.
It's one of my favorite materials to work with and it is beautiful to behold
when crafted correctly. I won't mind making 3 or 4 attempts at the custom
job because the last one will make me very, very happy.
Now, something of a reply to your inquiry. If my goal was to pressurize a
cabin in my experimental aircraft I'd keep 3 basic things in mind, some of
which might disqualify the project in the eyes of many people.
1. Avoid compound curves, or at least do your best to allow large radii.
They can mess up the optics and concentrate loads in undesirable ways.
2. Correlary, non-compound sectional arcs with large radii are good.
3. Understand from the get go that a scratch is going to stay scratched, and
most things you will do to fix it will only make things worse.
I hope that helps.
Mike
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.