Making hydrogen is energy intensive. So is harvesting crude
oil,
> transporting it etc. It also matters where your energy comes
from. If it is
> from distributed wind, solar, and nuclear, who cares if it
takes a little
> more. There may be some merit to the hydrogen thing, but
currently the
> storage technology is lacking.
Monty, I will continue this thread this one more time as the rotary
is
the best ice for the use of H2 fuel. Since I work for a business
that
would directly profit from the fuel cell technology I'm well aware
of
the efficiency of fuel cells and the newest sema motors etc. In fact
the
storage issue is even handled by newer carbon/kevlar tanks that can
easily store gas at 10k psi. To the naysayers the tanks use a liner
and
have withstood crush tests that would totally destroy any car
without
bursting. The problem is scope Monty. In an article for Custom
Planes
they talk about the dissapearance of 100LL. This will happen fairly
soon.
The fact is that manufacturers pump around 100,000,000 US gallons of
100LL per year. That sounds like a lot doesn't it? The fact is that
that
is the amount used by the whole of auto consumption in ONE DAY!
The funny part is that if we wanted the lowest POLLUTION level we
would use Nuclear Power to produce H2. But since I just put the
word nuclear in a post I am expexting to be censured by the Sierra
Club within the hour. There are several ways to make H2 work but
I don't expect to see the infrastructure for it in the next 20
years. And
I would like to see it work.
Bill Jepson
I agree. In a previous post, I mentioned that fixed nuclear reactors
are the real solution to cost-effective production of hydrogen. The
environmentalists
are the main impediment here, despite the fact that the overall risks of
nuclear are far less than those of buying oil from the mideast, transporting
it
halfway around the world, refining and burning it. Solar and wind would
be nice, but it is my understanding that geography and physics don't make
these
viable alternative for much of the nation's power needs anytime in the
forseeable future.
I've also wondered that, since replacing the gasoline-based
infrastructure with an H2 distribution network is such a huge and expensive
undertaking, wouldn't
it be possible instead to have small H2 generators and pressurization
units at home? After all, we all have the raw materials at home: water and
power.
Could home units produce and pressurize enough hydrogen overnight to
recharge our cars' H2 fuel tanks? If this were possible, you'd need far
fewer "gas"
stations.
Scott Gettings
This is not without merit, but not too financially gainful. With a wind
generator or solar power
you could have very good feelings. However making Hydrogen from retail
electricity is not
cheap, and you have just move the pollution NIMBY. [not in my back yard].
Also the horsepower to pump
H2 to 4000 psi is not insignificant. Home units are available for doing this
with your
gas line for auto use - you do duck taxes, and that is attractive. Vance
Taxes are significant. Gasoline is worth about $1.39 gallon. The rest is
taxes. Imagine the enormous amounts of money the European governments
are taking in from gasoline taxes alone. Most of the many major roads in
Europe are jammed with cars. Admittedly most are tiny cars by US standards
but they drive much faster so MPG is probably not that much different.
Paul
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.