Subject: SPAM [low]: New aircraft engines? Actually MOTORS
From: ACRE
Date: 3/15/2004, 2:18 PM


I agree.  In a previous post, I mentioned that fixed nuclear reactors
are the
real solution to cost-effective production of  hydrogen.  The
environmentalists
are the main impediment here, despite the fact that the overall
risks of
nuclear are far less than those of buying oil from the mideast,
transporting
it
halfway around the world, refining and burning it.  Solar and wind
would be
nice, but it is my understanding that geography and physics don't
make
these
viable alternative for much of the nation's power needs anytime in
the
forseeable future.

I've also wondered that, since replacing the gasoline-based
infrastructure
with an H2 distribution network is such a huge and expensive
undertaking,
wouldn't
it be possible instead to have small H2 generators and pressurization
units at
home?  After all, we all have the raw materials at home:  water and
power.
Could home units produce and pressurize enough hydrogen overnight to
recharge
our cars' H2 fuel tanks?  If this were possible, you'd need far fewer
"gas"
stations.

Scott Gettings

The only thing that will stop this is the lack of profit margin...
AND a
way to
tax it. Business needs to make money at it. If you are making your own
fuel (you
could augment it with wind / solar) then they and the government will
be
cut out
of the picture... I don't think this will be acceptable.

In Michigan, in the early 80's, so many people were switching to
diesel,
that
our road tax revenue dropped about 30%. So, the Governor enacted a
diesel
only
fuel tax increase. The truckers were so outraged, they did an 18
wheeler
blockade
of the capital.

--
-dave
mailto:dave@arb.net
http://arb.net

Obviously home-generation of H2 for auto use would potentially cut out
huge
road tax revenues from the gov't.  Profits would then come from selling
these units and the cars themselves.

It would be interesting to see what kind of taxes the gov't would levy
on
H2 generators.  Or maybe try to outlaw them??  The gov't could
partially
make up for the gas taxes with registration taxes instead, but everyone
would share them equally, instead of those who used the roads the most
paying the most.

It will be interesting to see how this plays out.

Scott Gettings

I think you are being a bit optimistic Scott. Vance has a lot of
experience
with hydrogen being a real rocket scientist. If everybody started
to use the electric supply to generate hydrogen the demand would go
up and so too the price of electricity. Solar cells are not cheap and
you
probably will not get a significant amount of juice out of solar cells
to generate the amount of hydrogen you will need for a car. Also as
Vance pointed out it takes real HP to compress a gas to 3000 PSI
necessary to get any range out of a hydrogen powered vehicle.

One HP is 746 watts and a solar array that will generate 746 watts
is one expensive device. Pratt and Whitney uses a turboprop engine
among other sources of power to power their high altitude turbofan
engine test cell. This engine runs on natural gas from the city supply.
It takes a 750 HP diesel powered compressor to compress the natural gas
just so the turboprop engine can run. I was not allowed to take any
pictures inside the test facility or I would show you the size of this
750 HP diesel compressor. It is about the size of a trailer as in
tractor
trailer.

You need to run ALL the numbers. Hydrogen will not be practical or cost
effective  any time in the near future.

Paul Lamar


Hi Paul,
according to my rough (and I do mean rough) calculations for solar
cells, about 100 watts of energy per sqare meter at high noon in the
summer;  you'll only need a solar array that is 1.36 acres big to power
that compressor.  Who says solar power isn't viable.. :)

Chris Cosman

The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.