Subject: MRE engines and Robinson helicopters
From: ACRE
Date: 3/16/2004, 9:34 AM

MRE-FB wrote:

Thomas y Reina Jakits wrote:

For a little calculator exercise: How about a 4-rotor, turbo-charged
and/or -compound, diesel/Jet A,
spark ignition engine, 400 - 600 hp, what would be the weight?
Robinson Helicopters would be waiting just for that!! Give them a call!

They are/where waiting for the Zoche Aerodiesel (which looks awesome on
paper!), but it seems Mr. Zoche is just waisting his time away. If you
can do this engine in as short a time as Thielert is doing his, I am
sure Robinson might be interested in helping you out in the finacial
department, besides he would be one hell of a launch customer, minimum
numbers guaranteed, and the best of it: IT WOULD BE A ROTARY!!!

Ooh.....................just woke up. But what a dream!!

Thomas J.

PS2: Robinson can't use the new Thielert V8 diesel - to heavy and mainly
not enough power. They need at least 400-420 hp...
PS3: Feel free to answer via the Rotary newsletter!

Thomas,

First, I must thank you for a particularly good, pertinent and helpful
analysis on our new corporate name proposals.

Here are my answers to your dream's main points:

We are not, for the moment, thinking of a 4-rotor engine model, or for
that matter of a 1-rotor model.  The reason is that we want to
standardize parts as much as possible.  Our redrive, for example, was
designed to last 3,000 hours taking 300 hp continuous.  It will be fine
for up to a 360-380 hp turbocharged 3-rotor.  It may well be
under-dimensioned for a 4-rotor.  On the other side of the power range,
it is over-designed (both in cost and weight) for any engine below the
160-180 hp range.  We also believe that 4-cycle internal combustion
engines start having a hard time competing against small turbines above
400 hp or so.  Maybe jet-fuel capability will change that, we'll see.
This is the rationale for us targeting the 180-380 hp range as a
priority.

Spark-ignited jet-fueled engine:  we are working on it.  It has been
done (Rotary Power International for instance... former
Curtiss-Wright-John Deere-Lycoming rotary engine development program)
but never succeeded producing a viable aviation engine.  We believe that
one of the main reasons for this lack of success was the unavailability
at the time of FADEC and modern high-pressure common-rail injection
technologies.  With modern technologies it's possible but not obvious,
take my word for it.

Helicopters:  of course we thought that helo manufacturers would be
interested in our engines, as a matter-of-fact we made a little
comparative study on that market.  Rotary engines are in fact IDEAL for
helicopters.  Think of that:  a) choppers need redrives anyway(generally
belt-driven on light helos), so they could take our engine WITHOUT its
redrive (only need different size pulleys)... talk of weight and cost
savings!... an MRE 3-rotor engine with no redrive will be almost 150 lb
lighter than an IO-540 for MORE power... I don't even tell you the
weight difference with the very bulky and heavy Thielert 300hp diesel.

B) Rotary engines are very reliable and extremely unlikely to fail in a
dramatical way (I don't have to tell you that), good things for any
aircraft... even better for helicopters, don't you think?!  No need for
Robinson to derate an engine to achieve desired reliability and engine
life.  C) very compact engine, very compact installation as the radiator
can be placed anywhere the airframe engineers want.

Of course we are going to contact the Robinson and Schweizer of this
world as soon as we have the credibility that a flying engine will give
us!

The Raven II has 205 hp continuous and can be pushed to 245 hp for 5
minutes.  Our 2-rotor turbo model can achieve these numbers (we pushed
it to 300hp on the bench, nopraw... well, almost..., but it's too much
for a safe and sensible engine life), our atmospheric 3-rotor model will
deliver that without working a sweat.  My question is:  why would
Robinson want a 400-600 hp 4-rotor?  Are they developing a 6-place
helicopter?  I'd love to have better information on what they are doing,
can you help me?  Would anyone be in a position to introduce us to
Robinson and/or Schweizer?  It would be better than a cold call.

So, I share your dream Thomas, and all of us at MRE are working pretty
hard to make it happen... but it's a rocky road to paradise!  :)

Take care,

Francois Badoux

I am very, very happy to have you on here Francois. Looking forward to meeting
you at Sun & Fun. It would be nice if you could bring a few bits and pieces
over with you that we can display in the Rotary Engine work shop tent.
Perhaps some parts from a reject PSRU or a rear cover. Also I might add
if you can arrange something with an existing air racer it is a very effective
way to gain instant publicity and acceptance for rotary engines. 

I can introduce you to Tracy Saylor who happens to have the fastest RV6 in the world. 
Tracy is currently rapidly completing a new RV10 that would be perfect for
a three rotor. He intends to race it.

I am also friends with Dave Anders who races an RV4 (256 MPH) in EAA races and a Questair 
Venture at Reno. Qualified second in the SportsMan class at Reno before a run away prop
caused a crash landing. I also have contacts in the Nemesis Nxt camp (Reno SportsMan) that
a turbo three rotor would be perfect for. (The gear box only has to last 15 minutes).
Jon Sharp of Nemesis fame is a Lockheed Skunk Works employee that has dominated 
Formula 1 air racing for many years.

One of my hanger neighbors Jim Wright is building one of the first Nemesis Nxt 
airplanes. Jim has won the Sun & Fun 100 outright at well over 300 MPH in his SX300. 

I am not sure if any of these people are going to Sun & Fun this year but if you can 
come to California with a portfolio I can set something up after Sun & Fun.

We currently have a fund called the Everett Hatch Memorial Prize that rewards people
with cash for flying rotaries in air races. By winning his class last year Tracy Crook
made the front page of the Sun & Fun daily newspaper.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.