Francois Badoux wrote:
Paul - Is that really so?? I thought that Diamond was firmly behind the
Thielert/MBZ Diesel - which make sense in Europe where the
fuel tax is so crazy. The last I heard your rotary guy was not
completely up to speed on the spark ignited heavy fuel operation.
In any case - this is probably what Norm would really like
a write up on possibly as a portion of a SNF report on
rotary activities (I wish I was going - I think Solly would
like for me to ride with him there in his Super Pulsar 100
but I lack enthusiasm for that ride)(incidently that plane
would be a match for the smaller 2 rotor)- Vance
Thielert/MBZ Diesel. Too expensive, too heavy and too little power.
The European governments are catching on to the diesel tax loop hole.
Paul Lamar
You are correct on both accounts, Paul.
I hope I'm not going to bore you guys too much with a little information on the international aviation fuel situation (by international, I mean non-US +
Canada). But I'll take the risk:
In a former thread I volunteered a little study I made of worldwide 100LL and Jet-A prices. Some people were a bit disoriented because it was a study dating
back to late 2002, a time when oil prices were substantially lower than nowadays. But the bottom line is that, outside North-America, there is a 1.5:1 to
10:1 price ratio between those 2 fuels... per liter (or gallon for that matter)... notwithstanding the higher calorific content of jet fuel per volume unit.
So, the day a couple of attractive, certified jet-fueled engine lines will hit the market, I don't bet much money on the future of gasoline aviation engines
outside North America. And if you have, let's say, 50% of the international market, it's as good as having 20-25% of the US market... not a bad target to go
after, don't you agree?
Now, what about diesel fuel? Well, you know better than I do that airports offering mogas are few and far between. Airports offering diesel are even fewer.
In these countries, the only real fuel alternative is jet-fuel... and the good news is that a) it's cheap, everywhere, b) it's available, everywhere and will
stay so as long as airliners don't fly on hydrogen (see another recent discussion thread), and c) it's safer than gasoline. I'd be interested to hear the
point of view of US and Canadian pilots on the matter.
Then, to my knowledge, there are only 3 engine technologies that can or could potentially use jet-fuel: turbines, compression-ignition engines (diesels) and
rotary engines. I won't elaborate on the first to concentrate on the latter two. Diesels, or rather turbo-diesels have 2 great advantages: they already
work on jet-fuel with few modifications (but read on) and they have great BSFC. But, as Paul has outlined above, they have a number of very significant
drawbacks in aviation applications. Furthermore, as the ignition of diesels cannot be actively timed, they rely on their fuel's fixed KETANE RATING (the
equivalent of octane rating in gasoline) to insure that the mixture ignites consistently at a given compression ratio. Ketane rating is therefore a strongly
controlled parameter in diesel fuel. However, as turbines are constant ignition engines, jet-fuel's ketane rating is NOT controlled and can vary widely from
one country to the other, one refinery to the other and even one batch of fuel to the other. While ketane rating in jet-fuel is relatively uniform in North
America and in Europe (around 65 if my memory serves me well), it can be widely different in some other parts of the world (I was told it is around 25 in most
South American countries). Therefore, if you fly in, let's say Brazil with a turbo-diesel powered aircraft with an engine made for the US market, you may
never fly out! I never tried, but I have this information from the head technical guy at AeroShell UK.
Conclusion: The answer is SPARK-IGNITED jet-fueled engines. And, IMHO, there is only one presently available engine technology that fills the bill:
rotaries. Now, Dr Wankel's and Mazda's technology has to be substantially modified to run on Jet A well enough to achieve aviation certification, but with
modern technology it's possible... and I think well worth the challenge!
Fly safe!
Francois Badoux
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.