Subject: Moller in USA Today
From: ACRE
Date: 4/1/2004, 1:03 PM


I saw him interviewed yesterday on CNN or MSNBC. He's almost got his
flying car to work. Really. I'm not fooling this time. I've been out of high
school for 26 years now and I remember reading about his revolutionary "Sky
Car" when I was back in High School. It was just on the cusp of being
operational then. He must be really, really, really close now.
Brian Trubee


ROFL

Paul Lamar

george wright wrote:

for what its worth, the Moller Skycar isn't looney conceptually.  I worked
in the 70's and 80's for companies evaluating "quad-rotor" and "quad-lifter"
systems.  It isn't surprising that it has taken so long to get to this
point.  He clearly used the cash flow from his attractive "sexy" project to
fund the really necessary item(s) - the engines.  Now they spin it off to
protect a genuine asset (engine technology) from bad days.  I love reading
the "info" on his web site.  It tends to tell the truth, but perhaps not ALL
of the truth.  Especially about development costs and resistance by the
existing infrastructure.   The key(s) to a design like his rests in three
places - installed horsepower (you remember the bit about the barn door?);
transition into forward flight (look that the shape of the "car body", tops
of the tilting fans and the horizontal stabilizer aft as lifting surfaces;)
and finally the issue that stumps me - fuel consumption.  Where is blazes is
he going to put all that fuel?  I have no idea what throttle level he
intends to fly with, but it will probably be at least 40% (all engines
running) or 60-70% if they shut down half of the pairs.  I believe this
vehicle is intended to have about 1200 installed horsepower.  I assume the
SFC will be 0.45 to 0.48 lb/hp hr.  Do the math.  Where is the fuel?  For
its all-up weight, the Skycar is grossly overpowered by airplane standards.
The primary reasons are redundancy during TO, Landing and Hover, and the
need for significant thrust to deal with cross winds and vertical gusts.
This is why he has the complexity of differential thrust and what appears to
be a "single" electronic throttle.

It intrigues me that he hasn't received a NASA or DARPA contract to test his
vehicle full-scale in the NASA low-speed wing tunnel.  The data generated
would be of great interest to all.  Please note that they did this with the
Mellinium Jet twin-duct flying frame and the results are published on the
net.  The Army and Marines have wanted a "flying jeep" for about 50 years.
It may be that Moller is concerned about public release of aerodynamic
information critical to his type of vehicle.  If it looks good, someone else
will jump on the idea.  Frankly, I don't see the government allowing anyone
except the military and emergency response services to operate these things
in the near future.

George Wright

The guy running the company is not a loony. He is a very shrewd con artist.
It is a simple stock scam. They are selling worthless paper and not hardware.
They have no intention of ever making it work. 

Since when does NASA make reasonable decisions? What general aviation
program sponsored by NASA has ever come to fruition?

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.