Salt Speed by Paul Lamar A friend of mine recently attempted an assault on his own 240 MPH land speed record with a 771 horsepower, 3 rotor, 3 turbo charger Wankel engined 1992 Mazda RX7. One or two relative uneventful runs were made with peak speeds over 230 MPH. On the third run the car was seen to snap sideways and instantly lift off the salt to an altitude of about ten feet, snap roll and do what is called in aerobatic aircraft competition, a Lomchavak. An excellent film was made of the unfortunate event by a Japanese film crew in an ideal position near the course. The car finished by spinning down the salt on it's roof. Fortunately my friend was shaken but not hurt physically. Although I had nothing to do with the engineering of the car I thought it interesting enough to analyze what happened in the first 90 degrees of the car snapping sideways. This is accomplished in the following BASIC program. I have not been involved in race car engineering since 1973 or so. The last 20 years of my life have been spent with computers so I decide to use the computer to analyze this event. Back in 1965 while I was working for Chaparral Race Cars in Midland Texas and indirectly for Chevrolet Research and Development we were using IBM Mainframe computers to model race cars and analyze the potential lap times. I published a paper on the Aerodynamics of Group 7 Race Cars in the proceedings of the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics in 1968. In this paper I used a mathematical model of the Group Seven race car of it's aerodynamic characteristics and it's tires. At that time it was known by those of us at Chaparral and others the large role aerodynamic down-force played in the stability and cornering speed of high speed vehicles. So it was natural for me to attempt to do a mathematical model of the 1992 Mazda RX 7 salt racer. The body of the Mazda RX7 salt racer had only minor modifications. The internal layout and structure of the car were entirely different of course. The special 3 rotor engine was set well back in the chassis to achieve 50 50 weight distribution. A mistake in engineering in my opinion for reasons explained later. A belly pan was added underneath the car completely sealing off the normal radiator cooling air exit. A large transmission tunnel was fabricated to accommodate the longer engine/large transmission and duct the cooling air rearward. An unsuccessful attempt was made to enhance aerodynamic down force at the rear with an up sloped underpan. Several instrumented relatively low speed runs were made at El Mirage dry lake in Southern California where lift forces were measured. Down force of 200 pound on the nose and zero lift or modest down force on the tail were estimated by extrapolation to be available at 200 MPH. Due to certain stock body rules at the Bonneville meet it was decided to run the car with this unfortunate configuration. How unfortunate this configuration really was was not fully appreciated at the time by my friend. No effective wing at the rear was used. The stock rear "spoiler" or vestigial wing was mounted too close to the body to be effective. Several aerodynamic engineers have suggested tail fins over the years as a solution to the vehicle stability problem. These aerodynamic engineers have been, in general ignorant, of the role that the tire thrust characteristics play in the stability of a automotive vehicle. >From Von Doenoff's book "Theory of Wing Sections" the lift coefficient as a function of the angle of attack is a function of the aspect ratio. Low aspect ratio wings require high angles of attack to generate high lift coefficients. As a rough rule of thumb a wing with a 10 to 1 aspect ration has a max lift coefficient of around one and that lift coefficient is achieved around 10 degrees angle of attack. Since the wing used as a tail fin is oriented vertical on the rear of the car the yaw angle would have to be 10 degrees to achieve a lift coefficient of one. For a typical tail fin with a aspect ratio of one the angle of attack or yaw angle of the car would have to be roughly 45 degrees to extract a significant restoring moment. Let us calculate the restoring moment per degree of yaw angle of such a tail fin at 200 MPH. Let us say we have two such tail fins 1 foot high and 1 foot wide. Since the dynamic pressure at 200 MPH is 100 pounds per square foot we would have 200 pounds of lateral force from the tail fins at a yaw angle of 45 degrees. At a yaw angle of 1 degree we would have only roughly a insignificant lateral force of 4.45 pounds. Now let us calculate the effect of several pounds of down force on the rear of the same car. Lets us say the coefficient of friction on the salt is 0.4 and the tire generates its maximum cornering force at 4 degrees. Lets also say the car weighs 3200 pounds with 50% of the weight on the rear. At a yaw angle of 4 degrees the rear tires will be generating a lateral force of 1600 pounds times .4 or 640 pounds. At one degree it is roughly 160 pounds. This is 36 times higher than the lateral force achieved by the tail fins. Let us say the wheel base is is eight feet and the 25% cord line or center of pressure on the tail fins are located 5 feet behind the CG. The restoring moment from the tail fins is then 5 feet times 4.4 pounds or 22 foot pounds. Since the tires are located only 4 feet behind the CG the restoring moment is 160 times 4 or 640 foot pounds. Now these assumptions so far are based on a no-traction-from-the- rear-tires condition. Let us assume that the maximum traction force from the rear tires is a constant. In other words if we are using all the available traction to accelerate with we have none left to provide stability. The equation is MaxTract^2 equals LatTract^2 plus LongTract^2. You might recognize this equation from geometry as r^2 = x^2 + y^2 or the equation of a circle. Mark Donohue made this relationship famous by calling it the friction circle. Rearranging the equation and solving for Lateral Traction we get LatTract equals the square root of MaxTract^2 minus LongTract^2. We have already calculated max traction at 160 pounds so 160 squared is 25,600. Let us say we are using 90 percent of the available traction for acceleration or 144 pound to accelerate with. 144 pounds squared is 20,736. 25,500 minus 20,736 is 4864 and the square root of that is roughly 70 pounds of lateral restoring force. This is still 16 times higher than what we can obtain with the tail fins at one degree. Let us now assume we have a horizontal wing with a cord of 9 inches and a span of the 60 inches. The wing area is 3.75 square feet. the aspect ratio will be 6.66 and we are running it at a negative angle of attack sufficient to generate a down force coefficient of one. At 200 MPH the dynamic pressure is roughly 100 pounds per square foot or we have 3.75 times 100 pound or 375 pounds of down force. Max Traction is now 1600 pounds plus 375 pounds equals 1975. 1975 times 0.4 is 790 pounds. Let us say we are using the same throttle opening we had without the wing to accelerate with or 144 pounds. Going back to our equation of a circle we have 790 squared equals 624100 minus 144 squared or 20736 equals 603364. the square root of that is now 776 pounds of lateral force. the restoring moment on the car is now roughly 3100 foot pounds. Foul you say? We now have the drag of the wing to overcome as WELL as the mass of the car so we now need more traction. OK let us calculate the drag of the wing. Von Doenoff in his book gives the equation for the induced drag factor of a wing of any aspect ration as Cl^2 divide by pi times the aspect ratio. Since the down force coefficient we are using is 1 and the aspect ration is 6.66 we have an induced drag coef of 3.14 times 6.66 or 20.9. 20.9 divided into 1 is roughly .05. At 200 MPH the drag from the wing is the drag coef (.05) times the wing area (3.75) times the dynamic pressure (100) or 18.75 pounds. So let us add 19 pounds to the traction trust generated and see how much that reduces our lateral restoring moment. 144 plus 19 is 163 pounds. 624100 minus 26569 equals 597531. The square root of that is 773 pounds or roughly 3100 foot pounds of restoring moment around a vertical axis through the CG. With one feel swoop we have increased the stability of the car and made more potential traction available for accelerating. So you can see you are wasting your time using tail fins. This article takes and approach to the mathematical analysis of a complicated subject by using the personal computer in lieu of differential equations and other higher math techniques. The personal computer is ideal for doing an enormous number of repetitive calculations. The benefits of this approach are many. First of all it is much easier to understand. Another benefit is an automatic plotting of mathematical relationships by merely inputting the output data from this program into a spreadsheet program such as Lotus 123 and allowing it to plot the data. You will soon see what I am describing. Surprisingly the automobile is a much more complicated dynamic system than an airplane. It has both a road interface and an aerodynamic interface while the airplane has only the air to deal with. Good tire data is hard to come by so we will make a few assumptions along those lines. One is that the cornering force, up to about a slip angle of about 4 degrees, is is directly proportional to slip angle and to the load on the tire. For pavement this is not true. The coefficient of friction is reduced with load but for this analysis we are dealing with a road surface of hard moist salt. The coefficient of friction of the salt is assumed to be 0.4 however it can vary with the condition of the salt from year to year. Side force drag coeff = .7 Dynamic pressure at 200 MPH = 100 pounds per square foot Car is on the average 3 feet high and 12 feet long or 36 square feet side area. Side area = 3 * 12 = 36 * 100 * .7 = 2520 pounds The CP starts out roughly 1 foot in front of the CG. The C.P. moves rearward as the car rotates to a 90 angle relative to the direction of motion. A similar CP movement occurs with wings when the flaps are lowered or when the wing stalls. The C.P. in fact may move behind the CG because of the set back passenger compartment creating a stabilizing moment. The following algorithm is used to estimate this situation. The CP starts one foot in front of the CG and ends up 1 foot behind the CG when the car becomes 90 to the relative wind. At a yaw angle of 45 degrees the CP is at the CG. AeroMomArm = (45 - yawangle) / 45 IF yawangle > 45 THEN AeroMomArm = -((yawangle - 45) / 90) In any event the aero side force is minor relative to the destabilizing force from the front tires. It has Little effect on the yaw velocity achieved. This is true even though the coefficient of friction on the salt is 0.4 or less. This analysis ignores the decrease in velocity the car will experience from the large side forces from both the tires and the increased aerodynamic drag. This is justified as the spin to 90 deg requires less than .4 seconds. At this yaw angle the car will levitate from the surface of the salt because of a huge lifting force. The program is written in QuickBASIC 4.5 however it will work with whatever version of QuickBASIC you might have. QuickBASIC came with all versions of DOS beyond 5.0. Initial conditions. You may change these of course to meet your needs. thrust = 640 'Thrust from rear tires due to throttle opening. 'This amount of thrust is = to 342 HP at 200 MPH PA = 60 'plan form area of the car looking down on it. LCf = .6 'lift coeff of the car moving sideways Wt = 3200 'Car total weight FDF = 200 'front down force at 200 MPH RDF = 0 'Rear down force at 200 MPH SteerAngle = 1 'initial steer angle at the tires input by the driver. k2 = 1360 'Rotational inertia of the car k1 = .1 'Tire cornering coeff per degree or cornering stiffness 'up to 4 degrees on salt. MaxSideForce = 2520 'Pounds of aero side force CLS PRINT PRINT PRINT " SALT SPIN2 Copyright Paul Lamar 1992 " PRINT " (310) 374 1673 " PRINT PRINT PRINT INPUT " Press any key to start "; z$ CLS date1$ = MID$(DATE$, 1, 2) date2$ = MID$(DATE$, 4, 2) date3$ = MID$(DATE$, 9, 2) time1$ = MID$(TIME$, 1, 2) time2$ = MID$(TIME$, 4, 2) filename$ = time1$ + time2$ + date1$ + date2$ + "." + date3$ OPEN filename$ FOR OUTPUT AS #1 PRINT #1, "Time FCF RCF Torque Y.Acc Y.Vel Y.Ang Aero Mom Lift Net Wt" PRINT #1, "Sec Lbs Lbs Ft Lbs D/S^2 Deg/S Deg Ft Lbs Lbs Lbs" PRINT #1, FOR Ti = 0 TO 1 STEP .01 'Time and time increment PRINT #1, USING "#.##"; Ti; steerangle = steerangle + yawangle fcf = k1 * steerangle IF steerangle > 4 THEN fcf = .4 'tire cornering force is limited after 4 deg frontdf = COS(yawangle / 57.295) * FDF fcornforce = fcf * ((Wt / 2) + frontdf - (lift / 2)) IF fcornforce <= 0 THEN fcornforce = 0 PRINT #1, " "; 'front tire cornering force PRINT #1, USING "####"; fcornforce; rcf = k1 * yawangle IF yawangle > 4 THEN rcf = .4 reardf = COS(yawangle / 57.295) * RDF c1 = (rcf * ((Wt / 2) + reardf - (lift / 2))) IF c1 <= thrust THEN GOTO skipit rcornforce = SQR(c1 ^ 2 - thrust ^ 2) GOTO skipit2 skipit: rcornforce = 0 skipit2: PRINT #1, " "; PRINT #1, USING "####"; rcornforce; Tor = (fcornforce * 4) + aeromoment - (rcornforce * 4) 'Total moment from front tires + aeromoment PRINT #1, " "; 'total yawing torque on car PRINT #1, USING "#####"; Tor; alpha = (Tor / k2) * 57.295 'k2 is polar moment of inertia PRINT #1, " "; 'Yaw accleration PRINT #1, USING "####"; alpha; yawvel = yawvel + alpha * Ti PRINT #1, " "; PRINT #1, USING "####"; yawvel; yawangle = yawangle + (yawvel * .01) PRINT #1, " "; PRINT #1, USING "##.#"; yawangle; IF yawangle > 90 THEN GOTO endit AeroMomArm = (45 - yawangle) / 45 IF yawangle > 45 THEN AeroMomArm = -((yawangle - 45) / 90) AeroSideforce = SIN(yawangle / 57.295) * maxsideforce aeromoment = AeroSideforce * AeroMomArm PRINT #1, " "; PRINT #1, USING "#####"; aeromoment; lift = ((LCf * PA * 100) * SIN(yawangle / 57.295)) - frontdf - reardf PRINT #1, " "; PRINT #1, USING "#####"; lift; wtoncar = Wt - lift IF wtoncar < 0 THEN GOTO endit PRINT #1, " "; PRINT #1, USING "####"; wtoncar NEXT endit: PRINT #1, CLOSE #1 CLS out$ = "more<" + filename$ SHELL out$ END