Subject: Not just rings. RE: Petroleum. Break In Oil]
From: ACRE
Date: 6/16/2004, 9:13 PM


 Not much info there. Actually I don't buy it.
there is no part in the rotary that wears like that. For all practical
purposed the bearings in a rotary last for ever. The apex seals
have a linear rate of wear and then the seals must be replaced
and perhaps the apex seal slots in the rotors reground for  a wider
apex seal. That might hold for a monkey motion piston engine where slop
causes one part to impact another or its bearing in the block. The more
the slop the greater the impact. Typical for reciprocating mechanisms.

Paul Lamar

Paul, the chart shows the trend for ANY piece of lubricated equipment - from
a single bearing thru a complete gear box assembly, IC engines, compressors,
hydraulic systems, etc.  The slopes will shift, the 'bumps' will be smoother
or not, but that's what equipment does thru it's life.  This isn't about
JUST piston engines.  We have gears in our engines and redrives, bearings of
various types, spring-loaded seals that scrape across areas of the engine by
design.

You're correct - we don't have the same types of materials in contact in the
combustion chamber that a piston engines has.  But we have metals in contact
and we have NO perfectly smooth faces, bearings, or other parts.  The engine
WILL break-in and you'll be able to follow its lifecycle thru fluid
analysis.  The general path of the chart will appear in the metal counts in
the oil. This holds for all lubricated equipment.

The length of the chart is percentage of lifespan.  An abused piston engine
with no oil changes that is constantly overheated will have a relatively
short period of time between zero and 100%.  A rotary on synthetic oil with
some synthetic 2-stroke mixed in the fuel that runs steady-speed with no
load on a test bench will have a significantly longer period of time from
new to dead.  But the initial wear metal generation and friction will be
higher at the beginning, will drop as everything 'gets used to each other',
and will climb at the end of it's life when it's time to go.

The chart is from an industry-standard oil analysis course textbook.  Here's
a piece of text that went along with it:  "It is important to know equipment
age when determining whether or not wear metal levels have become excessive.
The graph to the right depicts the typical rate of wear that occurs over the
life span of a piece of equipment.  Note that at first the rate of wear is
high as new components are breaking in or seating themselves.  Once this has
been accomplished, the rate of wear will stabilize and remain so for the
majority of the equipment's life.  As the equipment nears the end of its
life or a breakdown, the rate of wear increases significantly.  In order to
properly interpret oil analysi9s data, it is important to know where a piece
of equipment falls on this curve at the time the oil sample was taken."

You're comment about slop and recip motion is correct.  But contact happens
in our engines as well - and not just at startup.  Put synthetic oil in a
freshly built engine and you guarantee that break-in is significantly
extended and efficiency is lowered until everything seats.  This is
real-world data that's been collected for the past 30 years.

Andy

I still don't buy it. Wankel rotary engines are a drop in the ocean of mechanical
mechanisms.

Rotary engines are rebuilt for three main reasons. One; somebody overheats
the engine and it has internal cooling system leaks. Two; turbo related detonation
fractures an apex seal. Three; and most rarely, somebody wears out the apex
seals beyond Mazda minimum specs. There is NOT one shred of evidence that
the RATE of wear of the apex seal increases just prior to exceeding
the minimum size limits.


Paul Lamar
 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.