Subject: Miata rotary and more HP.
From: ACRE
Date: 6/20/2004, 8:56 PM


Paul,

Concerning the Miata... why not push for a smaller, say 2 liter, all
aluminum 4 rotor?  All things considered, isn't that the best package
for power to weight ratio?

Chris Cosman

One always must keep in mind the cost. That would  not be the lowest
cost
solution
for a low buck sports car like the Miata. Even an all aluminum 13B
rotary
would be a major investment on the part of Mazda. Probably a wider
rotor
and rotor housing for more displacement would be one of the lowest
cost ways
of increasing the torque and HP. The question is; can the EPA mileage
numbers be maintained with more displacement? Always a factor. The
electric assisted turbo charger can do wonders for instant torque
but I doubt it could improve the EPA mileage numbers. My vote
is still the turbo compound configuration. 20% more torque AND
20% better mileage in the same engine. Proven technology that
works.

Paul Lamar

-Douglas Fir wrote:

Paul I am meeting with Mazda VP the 24th of next month and I will show
him
your idea. For an airplane use what configuration would make more sense?
Larger turbine directly mounted to the e-shaft?

Doug in Japan-

Doug I am not sure you want to mention airplanes when you see this
Mazda VP. I suspect a meeting was had at the NY auto show between
the Mazda USA legal department and Mazda Japan management on the
subject of Mazda engines in experiential airplanes concerning product
liability issues. I suspect if Mazda claims they know nothing about it
they can better defend against product liability law suites.

This is all speculation on my part based on vague evidence since I got
back. This happened after my visit to Japan and I could be totally wrong
about this.

You might ask your VP contact an indirect question about this subject
perhaps phrased something like this; "I have heard that some people are
using Mazda engines in aircraft. How do you feel about that?" I am not
at all familiar with Japanese culture so I suspect you could phrase
it much better than me. However feel free to discuss any of the ideas on
here
in the non aircraft context.

The main thing IMHO is, Mazda is falling behind in the current HP race
here in the US. The engine lacks the low speed torque Americans expect
in their cars. High HP and a six speed gear box is not enough. They
need some sort of higher torque rotary. That historically meant more
displacement. The 13B has not been increased in displacement since 1974.

They also need a rotary in an up market low volume status vehicle
such as a 4 rotor Jaguar XK capitalizing on the publicity from their
win at Le Mans. This I feel will synergistically add sales in the
RX8 price segment of the market. Much as the Corvette does for Chevrolet.

The best configuration for aircraft use would be an all aluminum turbo
compound rotary engine optimized for low fuel consumption in the 5000 to
6000
RPM cruise range. Firstly an RX8 based  two rotor engine but an RX8 based
three rotor version would also be wonderful of course. These engines would
dominate the less than 600 HP aircraft engine market given enough
marketing
muscle. Above that HP range the turbo prop engine starts to make more
sense.

There is some engineering opinion that a large turbine connected directly
to the
e-shaft is not the way to go. I would like to see it tested however.
It is certainly the simplest way of building a turbo compound engine.

Paul Lamar


IMHO neither the turbo compound nor the turbocharger is the answer to
the torque perception of the rotary in automobiles. The turbines are square
law devices, and provide vitually no power at "road load" cruise points.
Something like the Eaton supercharger would fill this hole in a much more
satisfactory manner. Airplane use - the turbocharger wins hands down.
Vance

I think you missed the point of my tuning the turbine for road
load and bypassing it for higher powers. Please study this one again Vance
and get back to me. Perhaps I am missing something. Please read the note in the
lower left corner.

Paul Lamar
 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.