Subject: Second stock turbo bites the dust
From: ACRE
Date: 7/7/2004, 7:46 AM


Is anybody running a Turbine Inlet Temperature sensor and gauge?
Even aircraft
turbo's have TIT gauges and you are limited to a TIT number. We
just don't know
what that number is for the stock turbo. As I recall it is somewhere
near
1400 F for an aircraft turbo. Since the current Mazda engine is
known for
exhaust temps up to 1700 F it is kind of remarkable the stock
turbo lasted
for two hours at MAP 38.

38 MAP for two hours is pretty high manifold pressure  and way
over flat rating.
29 MAP at 11,000 feet would be flat rating. It is all well and
good to experiment
but you need some numbers to know what it is you are experimenting
with.

Paul Lamar

I don't have a TIT because there is no good place on the stock
manifold and
I wouldn't want to crack it anyway.  But I do have a TOT which has
been
quite high.  500c (930F) at about 22MAP, and over 900C (1650F) up
around 30
in. MAP.  You know my TIT is significantly higher than that.

Dave Leonard


Thanks for the TOT turbine temps Dave.

You can get thermal couples that go under a nut on an exhaust manifold
stud.
Might be a good idea. On the other hand it might be worth the risk to
drill
a hole in the exhaust manifold because it is cheaper than a turbo.

Just because the rotary engine will tolerate 40" MAP does not mean the
turbine
will live at whatever exhaust temp that is. I have always maintained the
engine will outlast the turbo.

You guys flying turbos are going to have to come up with
some sort of lean mixture cruise map that lowers the TIT while still not
causing
detonation. I think both a TIT gauge and a detonation sensor are
essential
to achieve this. The side exhaust port RX8 engine will make this more
viable because the EGT is 200 F cooler but we are a year away from
low compression RX8 rotors.

At first glance 1700 F does not look that bad relative to 1400 F but
unfortunately high strength high temp materials lose a lot of strength
from 1400 to 1700 F. Here is a chart for exhaust valve steel.
Strength is near zero at 1700 F. Turbine steel is probably similar.
Max take off (short term) TIT for a Lycoming turbo is 1600 to 1650 F.

I consider a TIT gauge essential. In the mean time and in the absence of

TIT I would cruise the TOT at 1300 F to save the turbo.

Francois do you have a TIT gauge on the Piper's instrument panel? If so
where
did you drill the hole in the exhaust manifold?

Paul Lamar

Hi Paul,

We did install TIT gauges on both rotors by drilling holes in the
exhaust manifold (from the bottom up, no risk at doing that). We
initially read temperatures between 950 and 1000°C (1740-1830°F),
although it was quite easy to let them go over that limit by reducing
the advance on ignition timing.  BTW, we found out that advancing this
timing quite aggressively (up to a limit, of course) improved BSFC,
lowered EGT substantially (over 150°F) and improved the knock margin.

However, there seems to be a problem with measuring TIT on a Mazda
rotary:  in our tests, TIT did not react the way it should to changes in
timing, mixture, etc, while EGT (or TOT) did (gauge installed 2 inches
after the turbo).  We assume that the reason is that the TIT gauges have
to be installed SO close to the exhaust ports that they in fact measure
flame temperature from the "post-combustion" of the unburned HC.  The
size and geometry of that flame could therefore affect the TIT reading
in ways not representative of the temperature of the whole charge.  As
we were burning one EGT gauge after the other, we gave up measuring TIT
and now only measure TOT.  We initially read 1650°F at 35 MAP and 1720°F
at 39 MAP in the Arrow (max power at 2000 prop RPM/5650 shaft), but
lowered max TOT to 1550°F thanks to our improved mapping.  Next step is
going lean of peak at cruise settings, which will help a lot but is a
bit tricky to implement.

While I believe that you are overly conservative with your 1300°F TOT
limit, you are perfectly correct in saying that there is a turbo life
issue which we are addressing in more than one way.

Best regards,
Francois Badoux

Good info Francois. Thanks.

I looked up the air cooled aircraft TIT limit in the Sky Ranch Engineering
Manual and the highest they recommend for cruise is 1450 F. I have no reason to believe
the stock turbo has any better turbine material than an aircraft turbo turbine so
our limit should be close to the aircraft limit. Since I am guessing about
the temperature drop between TIT and TOT being about 150 F that is where I came
up with the 1300 F TOT cruise limit. Since the aircraft people use up to
1650 F for take off a  TOT of 1500 or so should be OK for takeoff.

I think those building non RX8 side port engine turbo's should use those numbers 
for awhile until they get a better reading on the life of the turbo. It can 
be rather discouraging to burn out a $2000 turbo every now and then. I would
hate to see that happen. Apparently people are learning this lesson the
hard way.

BTW  We have had things as simple as a water hose 
coming off causing a crash and completely freqing people out on the rotary 
and causing them to give up. I can name three people that have given up on
the rotary in the past six years mainly due to pressure from their wives. 
This hobby appears to be best suited to a single man or woman :) 

I can also name two fatal crashes involving rotary powered airplanes.
The fact that all these events were probably caused by builder or pilot 
error is besides the point. Never the less these events have been somewhat
discouraging for me. The three people that gave up were on the
newsletter for at least a year and some for much longer than a year.

I would not want that to happen with turbo rotaries. I would rather scare the 
heck out of somebody ahead of time rather than have them spend five years
or ten years building a rotary powered airplane and then have them crash 
and give up, or worse, die. Not good PR. What I am attempting to do with this
newsletter and web site is get the info out on what is required to make a successful
rotary installation. The problem is not the engine. The problem is properly
engineered and quality constructed installations. Only when dozens of rotaries 
consistently show up at the major air shows will the rotary be accepted 
by the vast majority of pilots.

I know you know all this Francois and I am sorry to bore you with this
but we always have new subscribers that may not have heard this before.

BTW www.Omega.com makes a thermocouple that is good to 4200 F with a ceramic 
insulating sleeve good to 3450 F. Perhaps a hole can be drilled in the turbo 
just shy of the turbine. Also remote sensing infrared thermometers can be 
use to look at the turbine directly down through a straight exhaust pipe.

Paul Lamar
 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.