Subject: Freedom Motors/Rotapower Engine Info follow-up from Dirck
From: ACRE
Date: 7/25/2004, 8:25 AM


-"Bruce E. Calkins" wrote:

Dear Mr. Lamar:

You (or your representative) are more than welcome to visit our
facilities
in Davis, CA.

Attached is a high-resolution shot of the Rotapower 1300cc dyno report
conducted by Rotamax of Brooklyn Park, MN.  The contact there is Mr.
Dave
Wiese (763) 566-2030.  Freedom Motors has been working with Mr. Wiese
to put
the engine into production.  We are now in the final stages of the first
production-validation run of about 60 engines.

Could you explain in more detail your comment "The center e-shaft
coupling
could be problematic if it is real"?  Also, why is it peculiar to be a
company incorporated in Nevada with facilities in California?  Nevada's
corporate tax structure is much more attractive than California's and
to my
knowledge that was the only reason we incorporated in that state.

Again, we are NOT looking to sell this engine at this stage (i.e.,
without
field-tested and verified performance data) to anyone for an aircraft
application.  In fact FM does not have a license to produce the engines
for
these applications, and Moller International retains this right
exclusively.
Douglas contacted me and inquired about the engine and its availability
and
I responded accordingly.

Regards,

Bruce E. Calkins
General Manager
Freedom Motors
(530) 756-1230
www.freedom-motors.com

Thanks for the HP curve Bruce. That type of coupling has historically
given
problems in crankshafts of all kinds of engines. I think Porsche recently
abandoned the trick as I recall. A bit of wear soon aggravates
the torsional stiffness problem. I believe several Wankel licensee had
similar problems. Mercedes also comes to mind. In due time I will look up
some references on this. I don't like having to be the messenger
as I would really like to see you succeed. The method
Mazda used on the three rotor is theoretically better as any small
motion is damped out by the long, large area taper. Even better is
to do away with the two rotor coupling and use the Curtiss Wright
method of supporting the center main bearing. A 3D of this method
is shown below. At this point in your production a minor change.

BTW I might point out you will have little control over what people
use your engines for. I guess you could always sue someone if you found
one of your engines in an airplane. I am not sure that would work as it
is hard to sue someone over the use of their private party. You could
always lease the engines :)

Two comments on the Sweep RPM test below. IMHO the reason the EGT is
higher
than the Mazda is your use of charge cooling for the rotor. That adds
unnecessary heat to the intake charge and the EGT. The strange
torque curve is also related to this practice. It is rather hard to
tune the intake when using charge cooling but perhaps longer intake
runners might still help. An oil cooled rotor and side exhaust
ports would lower the EGT by about 500 degrees F. No small amount needless
to say. In the bargain you would probably pick up 50 HP with a much lower
BSFC. However this would be a major redesign.

When (after OSH) can I show up for a factory tour?

Paul Lamar


PaDirck Hecking wrote:

Doug,

I jumped right on your link to FM the other day to check things out. I am
happy to see substance that means something to me there. Paul's post of the
1300cc dyno report means something to me and I will be passing it around to
my neighbors. For me, I am impressed at what hp - tq they get at 5000rpmfor
a good weight. Day to day all I need for the Searey Experimental is 100-115
for T/O.  The 110 hp unit in the PWC looks exciting.  The team at FM  may
have a product that might work for me, if it is ready in time. I have
lurked on the Mollar project since they first came out with the SS5801,
M4400 SKYCAR, MADE IN CHINA  push-toy which I am looking at on my desk
here..  :^) So, when Bruce C. relates to the SKYCAR, which is  project I
have lurking knowledge gives me some confidence. I respect Dr. Moller as a
man making good decisions and keeping company with others like him... My
dilemma, the empty engine space, still remains So, what I have to learn is
whether he will approve/sell an engine to me?  Anyone got a solid email
address?  Help!

 Dirck

Like I said Paul Moller is a good guy but I don't know if he wants the
liability of selling an engine to someone putting it on a experimental
plane.  He has a tough time with insurance for his own work.  But as Paul
Lamar indicated, after you buy an engine, how and where you use it is your
choice.  I guess that is where the 'experiment' comes in experimental
category. No one will guarantee it will work in your application though and
the  responsibility for a safe and good installation is yours. You have one
advantage though.  There is one heck of a lot of talent in ACRE to find your
answers.

Might be other rotary option lurking out there as well.  How knows:)

Doug in Japan

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.