There were some ill informed and technically uneducated people connected with
Power Sport in some way or another at OSH bad mounting the planetary again.
If I were Power Sport I would put a stop to it. I have heard from certain
potential customers that all the bad mouthing convinced them not to do business
with people selling Power Sport products. It is always a bad idea to demean
your competitors if you want to run a successful business.
I am working on a technical article for EAA Sport Aviation magazine comparing
the planetary drive to internal spur gear drives used by Power Sport.
BTW Dave Atkins stated at his engine workshop on tuesday that the weight of the
internal spur gear Power Sport PSRU is 70 pounds while that of the Ross is 35 pounds
and that of Tracy Crooks's PSRU is 45 pounds both being planetary's. So too is the
Bell 47 helicopter planetary final drive about 45 pounds. This last gear box,
according to Bell engineers, is capable of 1000 HP with a rotary engine running
at 6000 RPM.
Dave Atkins has all the incentive not to over represent the weight as he is selling
the Power Sport PSRU. Dave could save 25 pounds on his own RV6 installation if he just bought
Tracy Crooks PSRU. IMHO This strange situation is due to two factors. Either Dave has some
sort of grudge or bias against Tracy Crook or he just wants to make money selling PSRU's.
Any PSRU :)
Here are pictures of the Bell and Mistral planetary gear boxes taken at OSH
this year. I don't have a weight yet on the Mistral box.
Paul Lamar
I don't know any of the details, but I think he's had a couple failures
of the Ross drive he was using, the most recent one forced a dead-stick
landing. The source of those failures could be investigated and
solutions made, you would have to contact him to find out what happened.
He thinks Tracy's drive is basically the same design and so he thinks
it's failure-prone too. This was from a brief conversation I had with
him last February in Puyallup.
Don't shoot the messenger, I'm just reporting all I know about it. My
personal opinion is the planetary is certainly superior, and perhaps
Tracy has solved any problems that were in the Ross box.
Perry
I would never shoot you Perry :)
Well yes of course the Ross had its warts. Late version were extremely poorly
machined and almost all had a missing helical gear thrust bearing. But Dave
Atkins knew that. What he knows about Tracy's drive I cannot say but it would
behoove him to find out as much as he can.
Power Sport's use of the internal spur gear was rationalized on the erroneous
conclusion of Everett Hatch's that the rotary had a severe torsional resonant
problem. Nothing could be further from the truth. The torsional characteristics of the
rotary are much less severe than a direct drive four cylinder engine. Everett was
a sharp engineer but like me not always right :) I think what happened
was the failed shaft he used to connect the rotary to his dyno had a torsional
resonant frequency that happened to coincide with the rotary pulse frequency.
In other words two pluses per engine rev or 12,000 pulses per minute at 6000 RPM.
It does not take long to accumulate several million fatigue cycles. Only about 2 3/4
hours of dyno time.
Prior to that Everett was testing much lower RPM aircraft engines and higher RPM V8
four pulses per rev engines. Those pulse frequency ranges would be far away from a two
rotor engine at full chat.
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.