There were some ill informed and technically uneducated people
connected with
Power Sport in some way or another at OSH bad mounting the planetary
again.
If I were Power Sport I would put a stop to it. I have heard from
certain
potential customers that all the bad mouthing convinced them not to
do
business
with people selling Power Sport products. It is always a bad idea to
demean
your competitors if you want to run a successful business.
I am working on a technical article for EAA Sport Aviation magazine
comparing
the planetary drive to internal spur gear drives used by Power Sport.
BTW Dave Atkins stated at his engine workshop on tuesday that the
weight of the
internal spur gear Power Sport PSRU is 70 pounds while that of the
Ross is 35 pounds
and that of Tracy Crooks's PSRU is 45 pounds both being planetary's.
So too is the
Bell 47 helicopter planetary final drive about 45 pounds. This last
gear box,
according to Bell engineers, is capable of 1000 HP with a rotary
engine running
at 6000 RPM.
Dave Atkins has all the incentive not to over represent the weight
as
he is selling
the Power Sport PSRU. Dave could save 25 pounds on his own RV6
installation if he just bought
Tracy Crooks PSRU. IMHO This strange situation is due to two factors.
Either Dave has some
sort of grudge or bias against Tracy Crook or he just wants to make
money selling PSRU's.
Any PSRU :)
Here are pictures of the Bell and Mistral planetary gear boxes taken
at OSH
this year. I don't have a weight yet on the Mistral box.
Paul Lamar
Theodore James wrote:
Paul,
I am sorry to see this posted on your site: To be clear, (though I was
there for a couple of days), we did NOT HAVE ANY representatives at
OSH. I am sorry that someone may have misrepresented themself as a
part
of Powersport but clearly we have no control over this.
On the other hand, you yourself have once again misrepresented
Powersport's product in comparison to the others that are offered. The
relevant weight is the total installed weight. Considering that the 70
pounds you quote from Dave Atkins is the complete installation (all
bolts mounting plates etc.) and INCLUDES the
flywheel/starter-ring/counter-weight, at a minimum one would have to
add these weights to any other installation to make a fair comparison.
BTW I have inspected carefully the Mistral gearbox and I have spoken
at
length with them about their system. I think their gearbox looks nice
and may have great potential. But to be fair, their system is no more
proven than anyone else's. They have a great deal of testing to do by
their own admonition and a price is yet to be determined. (BTW what is
the installed weight?)
I will be interested in reading your article when published.
Paul, I thought you and I had ironed this out once before, but it
seems
clear to me that you must have some personal bent against the
Powersport effort. If on the other hand this is not the case then
please be more careful in representing the whole picture.
Respectfully,
Tedd James
Tedd James
612-676-0118 Office
612-840-1717 Cellular
612-617-7743 Fax
Wrong on the personal bent. From an engineering point of view I always
thought the internal spur gear was a dumb idea. Even back in the early
days when Everett's design failed at Sun & Fun. See the picture below.
So did the US Army. Ray Richardson was too stubborn to listen. Allison
learned, listened and went to an external spur gear.
One of the persons that made these statements in the Mistral tent was
a former employee of Power Sport now working as a part time aviation
journalist. The other person continuing to bad mouth the planetary is
Dave Atkins. Apparently one of your dealers. You are also out to
lunch on the torsional resonance problem which I will prove in the
next installment.
Nothing like a 70 pound PSRU to give the rotary a bad name. The flex
plate and balance weights used by everybody else probably weigh less
than 5 pounds.
As far as proven is concerned the the Ross planetary and others have
been
around for about 30 years with hundreds sold accumulating tens of
thousands
of hours. Only towards the end when Ross quality control hit the
skids, after Lou
Ross died, did people start having trouble with Ross gear boxes. So
far nobody
has had any trouble with Tracy's properly machined and designed gear
boxes.
Furthermore how are people going to get parts for your gear box when
Power Sport stops making them? The Ford C6 six pinion planetary gear
set cost
less than $150 brand new. There are also literally a million used C6
planetary
gear sets out there most in excellent shape.
The cost and weight of your gear box was one of the main reason Power
Sport stumbled
and Tracy Crook spectacularly succeeded in building a successful small
business.
BTW That guy in the tent pissed me off. I don't like being pissed off
:)
Paul Lamar
Theodore James wrote:
Paul,
I decided to go and make sure that I have in my possession all of the
facts before I responded to the posting seen below. I do this because I
would rather not continue with BS and inaccuracies that lead us
nowhere. I believe the ACRE folks deserve the truth, don't you?
First, the picture you posted is of Everett Hatch's spur gear. The
circumstances around this failure must be explained. I went out into
the hanger and personally looked at the gear you have pictured (yes we
do still have it on the shelf) then sleuthed out its history. This
failure was caused by the fact that Everett used a brass bushing as a
"thrust plate" on the front of the internal gear. When Everett and
Allan Tolle ran Nitrous through the system at Sun 'n' Fun, the bushing
overheated and deformed the internal gear causing a misalignment of the
teeth. The result is what you pictured. (The same year Allan blew by
everyone in the "Time to Climb Challenge.")
NONE THE LESS - I FAIL TO SEE HOW THIS HAS ANYTHING TO DO WITH
POWERSPORT! Our gearbox shares very little (outside of basic concept)
with the one you have pictured, and you know this.
As to the torsional resonance thing, let us just say that we believe on
the other hand we are not "out to lunch" on this issue. (As does
Hartzell, Lycoming, Macaully, Continental, and most others, all of whom
spend millions on testing their systems to assure they do not have
torsional resonance problems.)
Again to be clear we are not saying anyone else has the problem, only
that we do not.
As to the 70 lb. gearbox ... I took it upon myself to go and weigh one;
66.5 lbs! MINUS 9 lbs. worth of parts we remove and do not use. That
makes 57.5 lbs.
Just the facts. If we are honest about this we can see that the
proximity of the installed weights is much closer than you have
represented. Further the fact that our complete firewall forward weighs
less than a O-360 leads us to believe weight is not a problem with our
system.
As to parts availability, I guess in 20 years when someone needs a
replacement part and if Powersport is not around, (we expect it will
be) then they could have the part they need made at a machine shop from
the specifications we would gladly supply to all customers at the
dissolution of the company should that need arise.
Paul, let's stick to the facts and the truth in our discourses.
Distortions will not serve any of us well.
Finally, I do now know who it was who you spoke with at the Mistral
tent. I have asked him for a response and I will forward it to you when
he supplies it.
Oh and PS: Powersport has not "stumbled." and PPS: Powersport is (as it
always has been) 1 word.
Respectfully,
Tedd James
Tedd James
Office: (612) 676 - 0118
Cellular: (612) 840 - 1717
Fax: (612) 617 - 7743
Office:
1315 4th St. S.E.
Minneapolis, MN 55414
70 or 60 pounds what difference does it make? It sends the wrong message
about the torsional characteristics of the rotary engines. The rotary
is far smoother than a 4 cylinder and as smooth as a six. Everybody knows
that. A 35 pound Ross works fine when properly machined. Tracy has sold a
hundred gear boxes in the same span of time you have sold half a dozen. Making
a custom gear set would cost a person ten or twenty times what he would pay
for a Ford C6 part.
Power Sport screwed around for three years trying to get it to cool. I have
the changes documented in pictures taken at OSH. You never ever flew
the airplane anywhere near Florida or Arizona. I offered Ray Richardson free
hangar space in California if he wanted to do some cooling development
in the winter time. He refused.
If Power Sport had an open mind six years ago the rotary would be
miles ahead of where it is now. A gross waste of $500,000.
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.