Bulent Aliev wrote:
Scott Baker at Velocity sent this to the Velocity Reflector email
list. Innodyn is the same company as ATP. There were follow ups from
people who'd placed deposits that said the same thing.
Caveat Emptor.
To anyone who is remotely interested in purchasing an engine from ATP -
Affordable Turbine Power - LISTEN UP!
What follows may save you $10,000 (or more)!
ATP is selling "snake oil" as far as my opinion goes.
Several Velocity customers have placed orders and deposits for ATP engines -
and have been the victims of broken promises and outright fraud.
One Velocity customer placed a $12,000 deposit with ATP towards a +300hp
version of their experimental turbine - waited to the promised delivery
date - called for the delivery - and was told by the "good" folks at ATP
that:
a. They discontinued development of the 300 hp version of the engine
b. They had no immediate plans to renew development of the 300 hp engine
c. Despite the written order form that guaranteed all deposits would be
escrowed - ATP nevertheless spent his deposit, and
d. They have no plans to refund his deposit.
To add insult to injury, this Velocity builder had purchased a constant
speed propeller that works (for all intent and purposes) on a turbine
engine - so he is also "out" the money he invested in the propeller.
This is not an isolated case. Another Velocity customer that I spoke with
ALSO lost a substantial amount of money due to the fact that ATP could not
provide an engine and would not return his deposit.
In the last edition of AOPA's ePilot, it had an announcement piece promoting
ATP. I wrote to the editor of ePilot and told him about the fraud this
company has committed and gave him the names of two Velocity customers who
were cheated by ATP. The editor followed through - and attempted to reach
ATP for comment. They (ATP) refuse to talk with him. The customers did
talk with AOPA and told them what happened.
One year ago ATP had a booth at Sun n Fun showing their ATP powered RV.
Between SnF and Oshkosh the aircraft added (what is reported to be) less
than 10-hours of flight time. Think about that. 10-hours of flight time in
4-months. If I were selling a new engine - turbine or otherwise - I would
hardly boast about 10-hours of operation in 4-months. Something was (and
is) obviously amiss.
Incredibly, I am contacted by Velocity customers who have talked with ATP
... and ATP believe it or not, is giving Velocity as a reference! What
balls!
After SnF 2003, ATP went "underground" at last years Oshkosh and this years
SnF. They did not have a booth, but they did promote their "fantastic,
everybody needs to have one turbine engine" at an obscure Cub display. ATP,
you will find, is not in the show program.
These people have the lowest business ethics. If you are fool enough to
give them your money, they are happy to take it.
And that's all I have to say about that.
Scott B.
I think I identified this outfit as BS a couple of years ago at OSH based
on the extraordinary claims of high BSFC. Every pilot needs to learn
and totally understand BSFC :) I'll search for messages.
Experimental aviation is the happy hunting ground for scam artist
because of the typical builders emotional involvement. We WANT.....
neigh NEED to believe in the 100 mpg carburetor.
Paul Lamar
Bulent ,
Before I settled on the rotary, ATP's turbine was one of several engine
choices on the short list. They never would answer my questions though. So
now I am trying to translate "Snake oil" for my wife Michiwa :)
Doug in Japan
Old message:
__________________________________________________________________________
Subject: APT flies (Ithink)
Date: Thu, 14 Mar 2002 08:27:19 -0800
From: ACRE NL <rotaryeng@earthlink.net>
Russell Kent wrote:
ATP ("Affordable Turbine Power") is the "homebuilt" turbine engine
that was
displayed at Oshkosh 2001. See: http://www.atpcoinc.com/
Bill, where'd you get the photo?
Russell Kent
Quoting static thrust is meaningless when using a propellor.
Static thrust can be very high yet the prop can be useless for
use with an airplane. Static thrust is far more meaningful when
talking about a pure jet or turbo fan.
In fact optimizing static thrust with a prop can get you killed.
10.7 GPH at 120 HP is a BSFC of .535. Very very highly unlikely for a
simple turbine engine. I will believe it when somebody with no
interest in this engine tests it for fuel burn and HP. Billions of R&D
dollars
have been spent by turbo prop engine makers for the last 50 years and
nobody but nobody got the BSFC down to 0.535 with a simple low HP
centrifugal flow compressor and turbine combination. I would not be a
bit
surprised if the fuel burn was twice 10.7 GPH or about 20 GPH.
There are some highly inexplicable and suspicious claims from this
company.
Paul Lamar
They are using the Solar APU turbines- and as one person said in the
house of commons "Me thinks the gentleman from ###### holds the
truth quite lightly'' Solar data quotes sfc 1.3 lb/hp - good engines
and cheap used - but economical NO - Vance
Unless these guys are using a new turbine and compressor, have added
variable inlet guide vanes to the turbine, and installed a regenerator,
there is no way that they are getting the numbers they claim using a solar
APU. The overhung shaft solars are great for simplicity, but they suffer
from the same problems all small turbines do. Namely, boundary layer effects
and increased losses from clearances compared to larger turbines. There are
only two ways to get the BSFC of a turbine down:
1.) increase pressure ratio (the approach taken by all the big guys)
2.) use a low pressure ratio with a regenerator (possibly the way to a more
efficient simple engine)
The regenerator recovers some of the waste exhaust heat and uses it to heat
the compressed air, before combustion, thereby reducing the amount of fuel
needed. If you used this method, and installed a lean burn combustor and
variable inlet vanes for the turbine, you could probably make some real
gains in efficiency, which is currently horrible. From the looks of their
hardware, this has not been done. Maybe they have found a way to defeat the
laws of thermodynamics, but I would not be first in line to buy this thing.
Monty
______________________________________________________________________
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.