Charlie Smith wrote:
I visited ATP about two years ago and despite writing them a
month
in
advance, they were not at all prepated to receive my visit. I
came to
discuss their data; specifically fuel consumption versus
aircraft
performance. They claimed to have data but that the power plant
was
undergoing "a major redesign that would make existing data
useless".
Chuck
Nearhoof absolutely refused several direct requests to view his
steady
state
data collected in his RV testbed. I did accept their offer to
tour
their
machine shop and test bay. When walking through the shop on the
way
back
from the test cell I noticed some equipment sitting in a corner
under
some
plastic. When I asked Chuck what was under the plastic, he
replied it
was a
dyno.
Next question- Then you have tested this engine on a dyno?
Reply- No. This dyno is set up for a piston engine. An engine
which
produces power in pulses. We need a dyno that is suitable for
an
electric
engine. Power that is produced smoothly and continuously.
Results
from
that dyno would not be valid.
My conclusion- Get out the hip-waders. They have tested and
couldn't
possibly believe the results.
If it were possible, I would ask for reimbursement from ATP for
my
gas
money
to visit them. A great concept backed by lousy execution and
even
worse
business practices. I intend to aviod them at all costs.
Charlie Smith
KIS Cruiser 4021
Thanks for the info on ATP and the turbine engine situation.
Another
thing builders should be aware of (that none of the vendors are
going
to
mention, if THEY are aware!) is that a person who wishes to
certificate an
experimental aircraft with a turbine powerplant MUST have an
approved
maintenance program for the engine and aircraft BEFORE the
airworthiness
certificate can be issued. This maintenance program must be
approved
by the
FAA Flight Standards District Office (FSDO). This approval process
could
take several months to complete, so the builder had better start
early so as
to have the approval in hand when the aircraft is inspected.
Further, not only does the aircraft need an approved maintenance
program,
but the pilot who flies the aircraft must have a specific letter of
authorization (LOA) in order to legally fly the turbine-powered
homebuilt.
So it's back to the FSDO again!
Food for thought when considering a turbine engine for a
homebuilt.
Joe
Greg Ford wrote:
Paul,
I have just returned from Oshkosh where "Innodyn' had a stand. I was
with a friend from Indiana who posed the question of fuel burn to all
innodyn personal on hand. The answers were not really forth coming as
to specific figures and that they were in the process of getting data
testing done by some US gov military authority who have "shown much
interest " in their product. They did have an RV6 on the flight line
fitted with a turbine as well as a Piper cub at the tent site. They
were quoting something like $50K US firewall forward.
Regards
Greg Ford
Australia
I'm convinced all ATP really wants to do is sell their patented fuel
management system to some big company for a royalty. All we are seeing is
their marketing approach to get to that goal.
When I went through this excercise way, way back when I seriously was
looking at ATP, a FSDO approved maint. plan was required but no LOA.
Somewhere in the FAR's is a catch-all that permits you to operate an ATP
type engine with only your private certificate as long as it is in an
amateur built aircraft. At least that's what the fine folks at EAA told me.
I probably still have the reference somewhere in the files (as if anybody
here is still seriously considering this engine).
Charlie Smith
KIS Cruiser 4021
Not sure I totally understand the LOA. 90 percent of the aircraft I have
flown have been turbine....(King Airs, C-23, etc)....I would need a LOA to
fly a single engine turbine? Paul Conner
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.