Subject: Meeting at Irvine, California during SevenStock on Saturday September 11, 2004]
From: ACRE
Date: 9/15/2004, 9:58 AM


Mr. Lamar,

The previous e-mail sent to you was the draft version of the attached letter.  Sorry for the inconvenience.

It would be appreciated if you can let me know your opinion on these matters.


Dr. Francesco Iannetti


F.Y.I.  my last name is pronounced as follows:  Ian-netti



	D   E   S   I   G   N      I   D   E   A   S,  Inc.


September 15, 2004



Mr. Paul Lamar, Editor
Rotary Engine Newsletter
ROTARYENG@EARTHLINK.COM


Mr. Lamar,

It was good to finally get to meet you last Saturday at the Seven Stock event.  I would have liked to have spent sometime in the discussion of the rotary engine status for airplanes.  Perhaps next
time!

I want to expand on the statement that I made to you during our meeting that ceramic apex seals are not recommended for aircraft application.

First, all of the current apex seals available that I am aware of (metallic or ceramic based), have the potential to destroy an engine when a catastrophic seal failure occurs, i.e., when a seal or a
multiple number of seals inside the engine break into pieces.  The scenario for this failure to happen is due to premature combustion of the mixture as a result of detonation and/or pre-ignition,
which cause severe pressure spikes inside the engine which can not be supported by the strength of the apex seal.  As you are aware, pre-ignition and detonation events are caused by different engine
conditions.

When the engine experiences "strictly an over-temperature condition", apex seals made from a metallic material are more likely to first deform which results in a partial loss of power due to a
decrease in sealing capability.  The operator of the engine can notice this loss of power and has additional time to react to a potentially catastrophic situation.  This failure mode is desired in an
engine used for passenger airplanes.

Under a similar over-temperature condition and depending on the type of ceramic apex seal used, the ceramic type apex seal will not deform as much, if at all, and the engine will likely not experience
a noticeable loss in power.  This condition will promote the likelihood for an increase in the severity and uncontrolled pressure spikes inside the engine because it will continue to operate under
non-standard conditions which initially may be unnoticed by the operator.  Under this non-standard engine operational condition, the quality of the ceramic apex seal, i.e., its material and the manner
in which it is manufactured will determine its load carrying capacity.  Low grade, usually low cost or cheaper ceramic apex seals will definitely break long before our latest, state-of-the-art ceramic
version of the Iannetti Apex Seal.  This IAS has been designed to support the largest load carrying capacity of any apex seal available in the market place, especially the 3 mm version, as well as
provide a substantial amount of beam deformation prior to failure for a brittle material.  However, even the best that we can make will currently break under the severe pressure spikes that occur when
the engine experiences dramatic uncontrolled combustion events as a result of a major engine malfunction.

A fact of life is that it is impossible to prevent a failure of any kind from occurring sometime.  One must consider the risks and benefits of any solution prior to making a choice for its use.  When
the risks are as high as encountered with a catastrophic failure in an airplane engine during flight, it is important that one strives to achieve the best possible balance between always minimizing
the risks for performance at a given cost.

What is always recommended in high potential risk activities such as flying is to make sure that the engine is tuned following manufacturer procedures, that it is supported with adequate peripheral
equipment to control key parameters such as temperatures, spark, fuel and oil deliveries and pressures during flight under as many standard and non-standard conditions as it is possible to predict,
that it is properly attached to the structure to minimize fatigue failures as a result of undue vibrations, and that it is maintained according to established practices for a flying application as to
the number of hours or actual time between maintenance cycles.

Life is all about risk management in a sensible manner.  When the risks are as high as encountered in a flying application, I feel it is always important that one is reminded of these facts of life.


Regards,

Dr. Francesco Iannetti

Francesco, 
First thank you very much for your thoughts on these matters.
I agree with the vast majority of your letter and we certainly have given
these matters a lot of thought over the past six and a half years.

We have found that 3 mm steel apex seals hold up much better under
detonation conditions. The aircraft application of the rotary engine
rarely requires running outside the range of 4500 RPM to 7500 RPM
so the heavy 3 mm seals seem to be perfectly adequate. In fact the
propellor guarantees the engine will not exceed 7500 RPM with the
gear ratios we are currently running. We have also discovered that
turbo charger continuous  boost levels in aircraft use must be held at modest
levels (30" Hg) or the turbo charger is soon destroyed. 

Since it is a well known fact the apex seals are cooled by the apex 
seal oil we find that mixing one oz of two cycle oil per gallon of 
fuel seems to keep the seals cool enough under all conditions we are 
imposing on the engine. In other words we have yet to notice a loss
of power caused by an overheated apex seal.

I have taken the liberty of adding  you to our mailing list so you may
acquire a feel for what we are doing. If the email gets too much please let
me know immediately and I will remove you from the list.

Paul Lamar
 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.