Subject: Revised Rotor verses the Piston 1
From: ACRE
Date: 9/23/2004, 7:26 PM


Please reread this revised text of the article on the ACRE web
site and let me know what you think before I upload it back to the
web site.

Paul Lamar
_________________________________________________________________
_______________

The Rotor Verses the Piston.  By Paul Lamar

Lets analyze the motion of an aircraft piston engine rotating at
2500 RPM. The bore is five inches and the stroke is five inches.
At the three o'clock position of the crank the piston is moving
down the bore at maximum speed. At the nine o'clock position the
piston is moving up the bore at maximum speed. At noon and six
o'clock the piston is stopped at top and bottom of the bore
respectively.

The circumference of the crank is pi times five inches or 15.7
inches. That is 1.31 feet.

Since the RPM is 2500 the RPS is forty two revolutions per second.
 So
the speed of the crank-pin is forty two RPS times 1.31 feet or
fifty five feet per second moving in a circle. The piston speed is
therefore the same as the crank pin speed at the three o'clock and
nine o'clock positions.

Bear with me here as we are steadily getting to the point. It
takes the crank one second divided by forty two or .024 seconds to
rotate once. To rotate from noon to three o'clock it took one
quarter of that or .006 seconds. Therefore the piston accelerated
from a dead stop to fifty five feet per second in only .006
seconds! The average acceleration is then 9200 feet per second in
one second. Well now lets see. One G is only thirty two feet per
second in one second so 9200 divided by thirty two is about 290
G's!!!!!


Hi Paul,

The motion of the piston is a sine wave and you can get a the exact
value for the instantaneous acceleration by taking the derivative of
the motion.  (My wife is waiting to go to dinner, so I can't think
about it right now, but it's pretty straightforward.)

Bob White

--
http://www.bob-white.com
N93BD - Rotary Powered BD-4 (soon)

When you get a chance please explain in layman's terms and we will
rewrite it.

Paul Lamar

Hi Paul,

Here is my calculation.

The position of the piston (y) at any given time (t) can be defined by:

y = r * sin(2*PI*R*t)

where r = radius of the crank, R = revolutions/sec, and angle is in
radians.

This is not exactly right because the connecting rod moved back and
forth 2.5 inches also which changes y slightly, but it complicates the
equations, depends on the length of the connecting rod, and dosen't have
much effect on the peak acceleration, so it's ignored.

velocity is the derivative of position:

velocity = (2*PI*R) * r * cos(2*PI*R*t)

* * * * *
In general,

  for y = sin(THETA), dy/d(THETA) = cos(THETA)
      y = cos(THETA, dy/d(THETA) = -sin(THETA)

  y = sin(THETA), THETA = function(t)
  then dy/dt = d(THETA)/dt * d(y)/d(THETA)
  for y = kt, dy/dt = k
  then for y = 2*PI*R*t, dy/dt = 2*PI*R
* * * * *

acceleration is the derivative of velocity:

acceleration = -((2*PI*R)^2) * r * sin(2*PI*R*t)

I want the max acceleration so I set sin(2*PI*R*t) to +1 or -1:

max acceleration = (2*PI*R)^2 * r

using R = 42 revolutions/second
r = 2.5 inches  (5 inch stroke)

max acceleration = (2*3.14*42)^2 * 2.5 = 173923 in/sec^2
                 = 14493.6 ft/sec^2

Peak acceleration occurs at the top and bottom of the stroke where the
piston changes direction, moving to zero acceleration at mid-stroke
where velocity is the highest.

Bob White

--
http://www.bob-white.com
N93BD - Rotary Powered BD-4 (soon)

So my number for average acceleration  is about half of peak acceleration.
Thanks guys.

Paul Lamar

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.