Performance Data
A minor drawback of the use of ethanol fuel is the slightly reduced
range. A
liter of ethanol produces about two-thirds the heat of a liter of
avgas.
However, the effect of range loss is reduced by the higher
thermodynamic
efficiency of ethanol. A Cessna 152 fitted with a Lycoming 235N2C
engine
uses about 13.8 liters/100 km on avgas and 15.7 liters/100 km on
ethanol.
The high octane level of ethanol allows the use of higher compression
ratio
engines that deliver more power for the same throttle setting. The
lower
Reid vapor pressure of ethanol helps to prevent vapor locking. Ethanol
is
cooler and cleaner in use than avgas and is more resistant to
detonation,
resulting in fewer vibrations and longer engine life. "
Doug in Japan
But the alcohol ruins epoxy tanks in no time!
That is not a minor issue
Jerzy
Very good point Jerzy.
Paul Lamar
Brian Alley wrote:
Doug, Any composite tank should be coated internally
with Jeffco Novolac. Jeffco developed Novolac to coat
the inside of comercial tanks used to store acids and
alkyes. Nothing in any fuel will damage this coating.
Well not so fast Doug. Far be it for me to dispute a fellow Mountaineer but
damage is a relative term and needs to be defined.
Jeffco 9700FCR is an excellent product but it is not completely immune to
gasohol. Alcohols in fuel will rapidly attack any synthetic polymer system
reaching a maximum aggressiveness at approximately 15% by volume. This
attack will tail off linearly as the fuel mixture approaches 100% alcohol.
Methanol is worse than ethanol. The attack will manifest itself in rapid
and severe volume change. For instance, a typical nitrile (also called NBR
or Buna-N) fuel hose formula will swell about 20% in gasoline with
commensurate loss in physical properties. The same nitrile formula can
swell as much as 80% in a 85/15 blend of gasoline/Methanol. And yes, it can
loose up to 80% of its strength and ability to stretch. Fluorinated
polymers and plastics are very immune as are certain types of epoxy, such as
novolacs. But it is important to stress both are attacked and are damaged
by gasohol.
I have conducted some testing for the KIS builders group in concert with
Bill Schertz. I immersed several test coupons in 85/15 gasoline/Ethanol for
about one month. As memory serves me, it swelled about 25%. The samples
were too small to test for anything else. They showed no visible signs of
cracking or crazing. By comparison, the control samples, made of pure
Aeropoxy resin, cracked into several pieces within a couple days. Granted,
the appearance was good but the exposure was only one month and with no
vibration at all. Also remember that you can never ever coat the entire
composite tank entirely. There is always an exposed bond line that will be
attacked by gasohol. Not a good thought having the bottom skin wanting to
pop away because the adhesive was weakened. At best, you could find
yourself chasing persistent fuel leaks.
So we've covered your tanks but what about the rest of the fuel system? You
don't plan to run metal all the way from the tank to the fuel rail, so you?
You need pieces of rubber line to connect for vibration isolation. Gasohol
will eat through Neoprene in a hurry and pray the fuel line never ever dries
out after exposure. If so, look for gasoline to spray out all the cracks
that will form as a result. You need hose where the inner layer is FKM or
some fluorinated plastic such as THV.
Don't forget difficulties with fuel vapor pressure due to alcohol content.
Best to avoid the stuff if at all possible.
Charlie Smith
KIS Cruiser 4021
Charlie
Thanks for your information. Lots of food for thought, drink?:)
I suspected ethanol might be a tad nasty but I had no idea it was so bad.
Makes you wonder what it is doing to our livers.
My company uses kynar tubes and fittings through-out our high concentration
6% ozone generators equipment. Of course we are only running at 120psi.
Pretty tough stuff and flexible. Injector parts seals concern me and of
course fuel tanks as well. I was also wondering how to coat the joint line.
To use ethanol what type of tank would work? Some type of Teflon or Kynar
bladder? Thin welded stainless?
Sorry to be repetitive to all of you who have heard this before but:
my plane project's purpose (challenge if you will) is an attempt to fly the
amphibian around the world on renewable fuels, preferably spending weeks to
make it myself in each location as I go.
Running biodiesel with a an 300+ hp aircraft engine was my first choice four
years ago when I started the project. No maker has gone ahead and actually
made an aircraft diesel engine of this size though they keep promising
"SOON". In frustration I started to explore other options. I explored the
turbine engine and in turn the rotary.
I was thinking of running 100% ethanol or if there are some other advantages
a biodiesel/ethanol mix. Gasoline is not the preferred option on this trip.
Making biodiesel is a no brainer and we usually add 20% alcohol to the mix
before cracking the fatty acids. I doubt at this point 100% biodiesel in the
20B will give me the Hp. and range I need. Coking problems may happen as
well. I would loved to be proved wrong however. Properly made biodiesel
runs fine in diesel engine farm equipment and trucks and burns cleaner and
has a lubricating quality as well. Making pure ethanol is a little more
involved to make and as you point out corrosive, but there are several
airplanes and numerous car running on 100% ethanol already. I wonder why
they are only selling 85% or 95% blends (for diesel engines) and not 100%
ethanol fuels? I am not sure what you mean by the 'fuel vapor pressure
problem' with ethanol. Could you explain in more detail?
Doug in Japan
My recollection is that ethanol fuels have a different vapor pressure than do any other gasoline blends. This can lead to different cold and hot (ambient temperature that is) performance. I think EAA's website has more on that part of the story. As my intention is to avoid alcohol in fuel, I cannot say I can recall all the details.
Charlie Smith
KIS Cruiser 4021
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.