Subject: Combined oil pan and oil cooler.
From: ACRE
Date: 10/21/2004, 2:36 PM


Matt Prather wrote:

I haven't taken a thermo class, but I know that rapid flow of the
cooled fluid is not necessarily the best for tranfer of heat.  Rapid
flow can cause turbulence which is detrimental to heat transfer.  Slow
movement over a large surface area is probably better.

Paul, were you intending for the gravity head pressure of the hot oil
to be the force causing flow through the cooler?   Can the oil to get
into the pump pickup only by draining through the cooler?  If so, I
think that would work well.  However, if hot oil can get to the pump
without draining through the cooler, I think that is a problem.

I can think of two other issues.  The system is not inverted capable.
Not a big issue, since lots of aircraft systems also aren't.

The other (and probably more serious) concern is how will it work when
the oil is cold.  It seems like you might need some kind of bypass
valve so that thick oil can get to the pickup without passing through
the cooler.

Regards,

Matt-


I think you are wrong about the turbulence bit Matt.
Turbulence causes the molecules near the surface to interchange position
with molecules not so near the surface thereby improving the heat
transfer to more of the fluid. "Turbulators" are added to the interior
of oil cooler tubes for that reason. If you check the fins on most
radiators you will also see little louvers punched into the fins
designed to increase air turbulence.

I have heard of laminar flow oil coolers but I suspect
that they work by drastically decreasing the distance between metal
surfaces.

Yes on the gravity flow.

Yes on the oil getting into the pick up area at the bottom of the pan.
There is about an inch of solid oil in the bottom for the oil pump pick
up screen to suck from. A pocket for this would be better I suspect.

I agree the sustained invert capability is lacking.

I also agree on the cold thick oil problem but I run 15W 50 Mobile one
and it is pretty thin right from the get go. Up north I have no
experience with it. The drain back space between the tubes in this
version is .2 inches. That could be increased if this proves to be a
problem.

Paul Lamar


Matt Prather wrote:

Hi Paul,

I guess it shows that I haven't taken a thermo class.  Perhaps I should
have before I spoke...

I found a couple of writeups relating to heat transfer and laminar versus
turbulent flow.  What you said now makes sense.  Here are a couple of sites
which amplify on the idea.

http://www.coolingzone.com/Guest/News/NL_March_2001/Cathy/Mar_cb_2001.html

OR if above is broken...

http://tinyurl.com/6un7g

and

http://www.overclockers.com/articles511/index02.asp

I guess what I was confused about is the desire to maintain laminar flow
into a cooling plenum.  In fact, I think you want the laminar flow
anywhere that
you aren't transfering heat so that you can get a large pressure differential
across where you are transfering heat (in a turbulent zone) - better
efficiency.

So, it seems like good characteristics for a gravity feed oil cooler might
be rather small tube diameter (good for Reynolds number, turbulence),
and tall height (larger head pressure).  Maybe you even want to have the
majority of the oil stay above the heat exchanger to provide better pressure
drop through the cooler, with a very shallow pickup in the bottom.

Also, I wonder if it might be good for the airflow to be transverse through
the cooler with an inlet plenum on one side and an outlet duct on the
other.  It looks like from the current drawing, airflow goes front to back.

Thanks for making me think a little...  :)

Regards,

Matt-

 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.