Subject: Combined oil pan and oil cooler.
From: ACRE
Date: 10/21/2004, 8:58 AM


Paul,
You seem to have a lot of surface area with this design, which is good
-- because you are going to need it. The oil that you are removing the
heat from in the oil pan is essentially quiescent (sp?), it will be
flowing very slowly across the heat transfer surface, essentially by
natural convection as it dribbles down the channels from the top of
the oil pan to the pick-up point on the bottom. The average velocity
in an oil channel will be much lower than in a conventional Mazda oil
cooler, because there are more channels.

The trade-off will be whether the increased surface area compensates
for the lower heat transfer coefficient on the oil side.

Bill Schertz
KIS Cruiser # 4045


Yes I totally agree Bill. Performance is very questionably. One thing it
has going for it is the air tubes are always surrounded by oil. The oil
level would be right up to the top of the pan. It is a configuration not
covered in the Kays & London  Compact Heat Exchanger book to my
knowledge. Would be interesting
to build and test a small scale version using a hot plate and pump to
continuously heat  a small quantity of oil. Perhaps I can get a thermo
professor at UCLA to do an analysis or a test set up. We could try that
with and without fins on the oil side.

Another problem is the length of the air channels. By the time the air
gets to the back of the pan the air temp should be significantly higher
reducing the delta T and therefore the rate of heat transfer.

I think it might also benefit from a thermal insulator between pan and
engine.

It remains an interesting idea and would simplify the under the cowl
situation if it worked.

Paul Lamar

Matt Prather wrote:

I haven't taken a thermo class, but I know that rapid flow of the cooled
fluid is not necessarily the best for tranfer of heat.  Rapid flow can cause
turbulence which is detrimental to heat transfer.  Slow movement over
a large surface area is probably better.

Paul, were you intending for the gravity head pressure of the hot oil to be
the force causing flow through the cooler?   Can the oil to get into the pump
pickup only by draining through the cooler?  If so, I think that would work
well.  However, if hot oil can get to the pump without draining through the
cooler, I think that is a problem.

I can think of two other issues.  The system is not inverted capable.  Not
a big issue, since lots of aircraft systems also aren't.

The other (and probably more serious) concern is how will it work when
the oil is cold.  It seems like you might need some kind of bypass valve
so that thick oil can get to the pickup without passing through the cooler.

Regards,

Matt-

I think you are wrong about the turbulence bit Matt.
Turbulence causes the molecules near the surface to interchange position
with molecules not so near the surface thereby improving the heat transfer
to more of the fluid. "Turbulators" are added to the interior of oil cooler
tubes for that reason. If you check the fins on most radiators you will also
see little louvers punched into the fins designed to increase air turbulence.

I have heard of laminar flow oil coolers but I suspect
that they work by drastically decreasing the distance between metal surfaces.

Yes on the gravity flow.

Yes on the oil getting into the pick up area at the bottom of the pan.
There is about an inch of solid oil in the bottom for the oil pump pick 
up screen to suck from. A pocket for this would be better I suspect.

I agree the sustained invert capability is lacking.

I also agree on the cold thick oil problem but I run 15W 50 Mobile one and
it is pretty thin right from the get go. Up north I have no experience
with it. The drain back space between the tubes in this version is .2 inches.
That could be increased if this proves to be a problem.

Paul Lamar
 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.