"Kent, Russell" wrote:
Paul Lamar wrote:
Heck I think they ought to teach it [the rope trick] in A&P school
since stuck valves are a way of life in piston engines :)
You might first need to convince the A&P schools that they need to
teach *anything* about piston aviation engines (beyond the FAA
minima).
Russell Kent
Matt Prather wrote:
I think the rope trick is a bandaide way to get home with a worn
out engine... I am pretty sure that exhaust valves only stick when
the clearance between the guide and the stem is loose enough
to preclude proper heat transfer from the valve into the head. When
this happens the stem gets hotter than designed and causes oil to
burn and stick and the buildup gets severe enough to stick the valve.
At least that's my understanding of the situation.
Sure, you can ream the guide and clean the stem, but 20 hours later
you'll probably be back to where you started. When you get to this
point, sometimes putting a new valve in will return the clearance to
service limits, but the fit won't be correct (the guide doesn't wear
straight nor straight), so the solution is short lived. Replacing the
guide AND the valve is nearly as expensive as just putting a new
cylinder on. Plus, by the time the guide and valve is worn out, so
too are the rocker bosses and you need a bore (talking old TCM
cyls here).
On Lycomings, I think the stem size is larger - more area to tranfer
heat, so the situation is different. It seems that for whatever reason,
usually the Lyc's break the valve off instead sticking - probably because
they are hollow, "sodium cooled" stems - tough to make a strong
joint between the stem and head.
Both the Cont and Lyc cyls are okay, but they require knowledgeable,
honest people to work on them and more often than just about anything
else would.
Matt-
VE N34RD, C150 N714BK (both C O-200 powered - arghhh).
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.