Just for the heck of it I thought I would calculate
> the velocity of the water going through a 1.5 inch pipe.
>
> The area of the pipe is 1.77 square inches.
> A gallon is 235 cubic inches so the length of pipe
> needed to hold a gallon is 132 inches long or 11 feet.
>
> At 50 GPM that means water is moving down the pipe at
> 550 feet per minute or 9 feet per second. 5 MPH.
> Not much. Half the area would be 10 MPH. One quarter
> the area or 3/4 inch ID would be 20 MPH. Now we are getting
> up there. Inside the valve when the valve was nearly closed
> the water would be zinging along however the length of the valve
> is minimal so not much friction HP would be lost.
>
> To quote Kays and London again:
>
> "The design of a heat exchanger involves a consideration of both the heat
> transfer rates between the fluids and the mechanical pumping power expended
> to overcome fluid friction and move the fluids through the heat exchanger.
> For a heat exchanger operating with high-density fluids, the friction-power
> expenditure is generally small relative to the heat transfer rate, with the
> result that the friction-power expenditure is seldom of controlling
> influence."
>
> That may be true but it could be partially the cause of the high HP requirements
> we are seeing.
>
> "The friction-power expenditure is also increased with flow velocity, but in this
> case the power varies by as much as the cube of the velocity and never less
> than the square."
>
> Ah ha!!! So this is why we where blowing circuit breakers on one and two HP motors
> and why it took a five HP motor to pump water through the system at 7000 RPM and
> 75 gallons a minute. Long passages in the radiator and engine block could
> generate considerable HP loses due to friction alone.
>
> Paul Lamar
> Paul, as I recall the CW and Deere engine designs used 12 FPS as a maximum coolant velocity for hot zone coolant passages. This was because the occurence of cavitation erosion would
increase
> dramatically at higher velocities. (Cavitation erosion is very localized at the metal surface, and is influenced by metal temperature, vibration, coolant contaminants, and metal surface
finish among
> other factors. It is evidenced by tiny "worm holes" into the metal or in more severe cases spongelike erosion of the metal over a wider area.)
>
> Jon Lauter
> Rotary Power Marine Corporation
Good to get some actual engineering data from engine designers. Thanks Jon.
BTW Chuck Dunlap mentioned some deposits in his radiator after a few years.
Have you heard of this happening with anti freeze solutions when used
at 230 to 250 F?
Paul Lamar
I've seen gel-like deposits in cooling systems that have been well maintained. I believe I was told they were precipitates of the silicate additives. I don't think I ever knew what the root cause
was. I don't have a lot of experience with coolant temperatures as high as 230 - 250 F.
Jon
Continental discovered this in their liquid cooled engine cooling systems designed to run
at 250 F.
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.