Charlie,
Going back to 27 th Feb 2002, you recommended a 2 part polymer,
polysulphide from Morton Chemical.
I kept this info as I know how much a problem this can be.
There are also coatings recommended and sold by Wicks and Spruce(
can't
remember what they are).
So what do you think of this Jeffco Novelac ?
George (down under)
George,
Polysulfide is a type of rubber. I have never tested it in
gasohol
but
it does have an excellent reputation for being resistant to very,
very
aggressive solvents. Whether this would extend to gasohol fuel is
not
personally known to me but the performance of fluorinated
polymers are well
characterized. The automobile industry does not use polysulfide for
one
reason, it is extremely expensive and it is not promoted by the
manufacturer. BTW, Morton does not make this material anymore.
I believe
they got out of the business a year or two ago. I understand it is
being
made in France; probably by a division of Total.
I used the Jeffco product to seal my tanks based on how it
performed
in
the gasohol fuel testing I did. Gasohol is deadly compared to
most anything
else you might put into the tank. I wanted to use polysulfide but
it
was
going to cost about $400 to go that route and I did the job
with Jeffco for
about $100. The Jeffco is just not nearly as flexible as
polysulfide.
As a side note, I understand from my colleagues in Europe
that biodiesel
(RME) can also be quite aggressive in the high pressure common rail
fuel
injection systems. It seems they run under very high pressure
causing the
fuel to get hot as it recirculates. With the presence of water, the
fuel
can decompose to form a highly oxidizing acid that attacks rubber
components. This may be something to keep in mind when
deciding on rubber
parts or inspection schedules for those types of fuels.
Charlie Smith
KIS Cruiser 4021
Charlie,
Thanks , that clears that up for me !
George (down under)
Charlie
You are definitely right about RME. If can be quite aggressive IF the
producer didn't properly process the fuel. Sometimes glycerol remains
and
that is definitely water absorbent and combined with traces of caustic
soda,
and soap and methanol is corrosive and can carbonize the engine. It it
so
easy to make that sometimes people make it to easy and don't test it
at
each
processing stage
Doug in Japan
The fuel tanks in the wings I am currently flying on are made from
Dow 411-350 vinyl ester resin and I did not slosh the tanks and have
had no problems and I use gasohol. I am now making a new set of
wings and have considered sloshing these tanks.
Also note that the Randolph sloshing compound that is alcohol
resistant is vinyl ester based.
Ken
Ken
I believe my Seawind wings are made of the same Dow vinyl ester resin. No
epoxy resin on my plane I am told. I am still compiling my notes and I
hope
to present the report of my trip to Baylor University in Waco Texas.
Suffice
to say that their lab was very professional and well funded and they have
numerous planes running on 95% ethanol. Two of the planes are certified
Cessnas I they had a Velocity that went across the Atlantic on ethanol and
a
Pitts they use locally. One drawback to ethanol is cold starts. They
solved the problem by installing a small heater coil to the fuel system
that
only needs to be on for a few seconds. They sloshed their tanks with some
kind of sealant (I am waiting for the brand name now) and they use
appropriate fuel lines that are resistant to alcohol. They have been at
this research for more than 20 years and seem to have licked all the
problems. They also have several grad students working on different
projects
and several dyno booths. I will have to find out more info about sloshing
tanks. It seems like an iffy process at best.
What percent alcohol fuel are you using Ken?
Doug in Japan
Doug if I were you I would leave the R&D to Baylor and focus
on your goal. Use aluminum tanks. You have plenty on your plate.
Paul Lamar
Paul,
Yes I have taken your advice to heart and have looked into designing two 53
gal. tanks (one for each side) to replace the present 110 gal. wet wing.
That challenge is even greater and involves assuring the strength of the
wing is unaltered, as I would now have to make a good bond between the
aluminum tank with its internal ribs and the fiberglass skins. I would
still have to slosh the tanks or Proseal them. Hey if it isn't one thing it
another. Nah... I'll wait a bit on this one and see if a solution :)
presents itself.
On a lighter note I am making progress on setting up the 13B to begin turbo
compound testing next month.
Doug in Japan
Doug,
If you are using 5/95 gasoline/ethanol, as memory serves me this mixture is
little more aggressive than pure ethanol. I'll see if I can dig up the old
charts showing the effect of blending ethanol with gasoline on standard NBR
fuel hose. Data are always convincing. Unless you plan to run 85/15
gasoline/ethanol mixtures, the Jeffco system should be plenty of protection.
It is what Bill Schertz and I have in our wet wings. The testing I did with
the 85/15 fuel blend (the most aggressive blend ratio) looked fine after
about one month of exposure. No cracks or crazing. Either fluid alone is
not that bad as far as exposure to polymers. There is something magic about
the 85/15 ratio that really tears up polymers. As far as my wings go, unless
I run gasahol, I'm not in the least concerned about leakage through the
Jeffco. Avgas and standard mogas do not present much of a problem with
Jeffco.
Building and then sealing aluminum tanks would be a real pain and may leak
more than your wet wing ever would. If you really want to go that route, I'm
fairly certain automotive fuel tanks are made from high density polyethylene.
Maybe somebody could mold a couple HDPE tanks for you or you may find some
existing HDPE tanks that could fit your wing geometry. I've never looked so
have no idea of what's available.
Good luck,
Charlie Smith
KIS Cruiser 4021
Charlie,
Thanks for your advise and warnings. I share your sediments, ... I mean
sentiments, and plan on initially using 5/95 blends gasoline/ethanol like
Baylor University is doing and benefiting from their know-how. A year from
now with Baylor Univ.'s assistance I'll try diluting the ethanol with
biodiesel. In the formulation of biodiesel about 20% ethanol or methanol is
used along with traces of sulfuric acid (in the acid phase of the two step
method) and then caustic soda/methanol or KoH/ethanol in the base phase to
crack the fatty acids and convert them to esters. Esters are drain off the
top and further washed and micro filtered. Biodiesel readily mixes with
ethanol and has a built-in lubricating quality when run in 50% or greater
concentrations in diesel engines.
These high concentrations of heavy fuel probably will not bode well for the
rotary engine performance but perhaps I can find a compromise that has some
lubricating merit at say 20/80 blends???
In reviewing my Seawind wing assembly manuals today I came across a lot of
calls for aluminum drain plates, and aluminum pipe. Not good for high
concentrations of ethanol. The SeaWing wet wing uses the leading edge
between the "D" shaped ribs as a series of eight chambers that are grouped
into "main" (6 chambers) and "auxiliary" (two chamber) tanks to prevent
fuel sloshing all the way out towards the wings. I thought incorporating
baffles in tanks prevented that but I am lacking the expertise on the nature
of fuel flow in uncoordinated flight attitudes like say a side slip to
landing. The wings do have a 3 degree dihedral which should convince the
fuel to go the correct way during coordinated flight.
Of course it is feasible to have HDPE tanks blow molded to fit those
cavities and connect them together or ditto for welded bladders. For fuel
line I'll go with stainless or Kynar with the later being much more
flexible.
The manual suggests coating the insides of the tank with DOW Derakane 470-36
if the plane will be running on unleaded or in tropic environments where
internal temps. could get up to 125°F. This resin probably won't be strong
enough for my purposes. Obviously after the top skin goes on, only two of
the fuel chambers on each side can be accessed, to further coat the tank
leading edge bond seam and the upper part where the skin bonds to the ribs
and spar.
Another option is to install 1 inch metal inspection screw-in ports in
the top of each chamber which I could conceivable..... Uggh!!... introduce
a sealing liquid to slosh or squirt around. I would need to add a coloring
agent to verify I had an good uniform coating. Might end up screwing up the
fuel
About Baylor Univ.,
They are a multi-million dollar funded branch of the university which tries
to sample air quality as well as develop fuels for aircraft that are low
polluting. They are situated in the heart of oil country but seem to have
good results and good press.
They modified the Pitt's I0-540 Lyc. engine and were able to install
helicopter pistons and raise the compression ratio to 11:1. because of the
low vapor pressure of ethanol The aluminum tanks they used were sloshed
with a chemical to prevent the slight oxidizing effect ethanol has on
aluminum. In performance the engine was producing 300Hp and now is putting
out 350Hp.
The spark is modified and as Lynn H. can surely attest to, the spark
duration is longer. One problem I mentioned on a previous post was the
difficulties in starting the engine in temperatures under 55° F.
They solved it with two different approaches.
1. Start on gasoline from a small tank and the switch to alcohol. Nah!:(
2. Use a 300 watt fuel line heater from a Dodge 'Celebrity' and turn it on
for only 10 seconds. Yes...This way seems more elegant.
I was shown one of their dyno rooms that had a small 4 cylinder aircraft
engine on the stand and besides the usually array of pipes and intravenous
drips, they had pressure sensors rings under each spark plug. One of the
researcher's discovered that each power stroke exhibits a unique pressure
signatures and as such can visually indicate desirable tuning
characteristics. I am not sure but I guess they might have found a way to
monitor near detonations events as well. The researcher mentioned something
about the certain spikes showing up in the burning event.
In order to catch this moment the grad student wrote his own software and
used a sampling rate of 44,000/sec. or roughly 1000 times per revolution.
Now all I have to do is find the memory card adapter so I can send you some
pictures.
Doug in Japan
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/‾rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.