Subject: Another approach to the tuned intake
From: ACRE
Date: 12/10/2004, 5:42 PM


     In this implementation the second pipe is so short and fat it
will be
tuned to a RPM range out of a normal operation of the engine. A
similar
system is used in the RX8 motor except the second pipe is longer and
tuned
to the proper range. The RX8 injectors of course are someplace else.

Since the tuned length of a runner is related to its diameter the
smaller diameter
pipe needs to be even shorter than 17-18 inches. My guess is a tuned
length
of about 15-16 inches is about right. The center line length of the
180 is
about 7.8 inches. Add two inches where the pipe comes straight out
of the
port and you have 9.8 inches. Add 6.2 inches for a straight section
and
the plenum is right on top of the motor.

Also a smaller diameter pipe has a somewhat smaller tuned range.
(Higher Q)
To broaden the HP RPM range the second 2" pipe can be about 19
inches or 15 inches
depending on whether you want to move the HP curve up or down.
shorter will
give more power on the top end. Longer will broaden the curve
downward.
The peak power will suffer however.

Good luck getting the mixture the same in front and rear rotor.

Due to the smaller pipes the HP generated will not compare to the two
inch Russell manifold. The area of a 1.5 inch pipe is about 1.76
square inches.
The area of a two inch pipe will be about 3.14 square inches.
The air velocity in the smaller pipe is almost double so the skin
friction
drag in the pipe will be four times higher roughly.

You have enough meat in your P-ports to ultimately open them up to
an area
equivalent of a two inch pipe.

Paul Lamar

     BTW I thought the whole idea of the Russell was to get a low
profile
     for your manifold to fit under the cowl. I suggest you get or
make a stock cowl
     to be sure everything fits.

     Paul Lamar

Jerry, I have never seen a system such as you have described. This
doesn't
mean that it won't work, but there are several questions. First: Air
in motion
doesn't act exactly as an electrical circuit and that causes several
problems.
There are several efficiency losses caused by the transition into the
varying
diameters. (result, lower max flow) Second: The location of the
injectors in
the "plenum upwind" position here could be a significant problem. The
into
the bellmouth injectors in F1 cars have a super short path, about 3-5
inches
with the ability to fire the injector when there is likely
significant intake vacuum
to draw the mixture in. In the system you have drawn, the fat tube
could
cause wave reversal (bounce back) at some RPMs which would make
tuning almost impossible.

Warning, anecdote: Several high RPM four cycles
that I have tuned ran into SEVERE areas of reversal where if you
gradually
applied throttle the engine would actually stall at a certain RPM. If
you
were wide open and rolled thru that RPM the engine would "catch" and
pull strongly to redline. The thing here is the single tube with
bellmouth is
almost certain to work. If you have to run over-the-top then run as
large
a diameter tube as you can and make it several inches longer. You may
and probably will lose a little over the "perfect" length but it will
run well
and have a consistent vacuum signal. Tuning will be vastly easier and
so
will fabrication. Rolfs layout may work well, but you will probably
need to
inject close to the engine for tunability. I like the square plenum
squirt
across system that we have been talking about. The need is to be able
to time the injection so you get the mixture sucked up, or you will be
buying yourself a great deal of trouble. Remember. I WANT YOU TO
SUCCEED HERE.  Hang in there.
Bill Jepson

Thank you,    Bill
Remember that I am seeking the right intake design.  I have settled on
nothing.  After hearing Rolf's comments,  I tried to share what  he was
saying and offered up the sketch to clarify matters. Although I do like
the Russell intake in many ways and I recognize that is a significant
breakthrough,  I do not consider it the perfect solution.  Probably
there is no such thing and we have to decide which compromise hurts the
least.

Considering the Russell intake,  what intake length would  you
recommend for the 2 inch version and also for the 1.5 inch version.
The " length" seems to change every day.   Paul, please jump in here if
you are not too pissed off.   I am beginning to think the ideal length
is where ever we end up after we build the damn  thing.

One thing I can do to help clarify things is to build both the 2 inch
and the 1.5 inch intakes. I like that idea.   I wonder how I could take
Paul into designing the 1.5 inch version?        Jerry

Jerry, why in hell would you want to build a P-port engine with half
the total pipe area of a stock engine?

My turbo intake manifold design for the side port engine used two .190 OD big
pipes and two 1.66 OD small pipes. About exactly the same as the runner
sizes on the stock 2nd gen 210 HP turbo engine and the stock 165 HP NA 
engine for that matter.

Paul Lamar
 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.