> Doug, I am pretty sure you are not putting the right
numbers into the
> calculator, as those numbers just are not right. There
is no way that my
> compressor outlet temp is 431 deg, and the P/R should be
much lower than
> that. My guess is that you are entering an absolute
manifold pressure when
> it is looking for a "boost" pressure. Try using the
attached calculator
> instead. I modified it to use an absolute manifold
pressure. I have also
> loaded it with the initial conditions at time of turbo
demise: 12500MSL,
> under cowl temps only about 80F, 32.5 MAP, 6300RPM,
measured intake temp 130
> (oh and traveling at 189KTAS :-)
>
> This give a more realistic temp drop across the
intercooler of 110F and a
> P/R of 2.01
>
> Dave Leonard
Dave:
I think our differences are in the understanding of the
formulas and the values which go into the formulas. We both need
to get on the same track...because as we discussed, your installation is
basically exactly what I had planned, including the stock
turbo. Let me go first and see if I can explain the possible
differences, from my position. I am very interested in resolving
these issues
as it is critical if I am to be able to go "Stock Turbo" to
turbo-normalize.
1. As the altitude increases, the outside air pressure
decreases (as does the air density) at approximately 1" Hg per
1,000 feet density altitude. This is highly important to the
turbo as this is
the inlet side of the pressure equation. So....if the turbo is
to maintain say 36" for example, let us assume that it starts at
sea level by having to only compress the air from 30" to 36", a
pressure ratio of 36/30 = 1.2...very easy to accomplish and
probably below our wastegate setting. In order to maintain 36"
at 12,000 feet density altitude it must compress the air from what is now
a 12 x 1" Hg reduction =18" Hg inlet pressure (equivalently
lower air density) into the compressor to 36"outlet. A pressure
ratio of 30/18 = 1.67.
The boost gauge is normally an absolute pressure (not
differential pressure) gauge and will still read the same 36" it
did when it was at sea level. Meanwhile the turbo is working
very dutifully at
12,000' to maintain that 36" MAP which was very easy at sea level.
A boost gauge normally measures MAP...vacuum at idle, then
boost after the MAP exceeds "0" MAP (Manifold Absolute Pressure).
Boost as an engine control indicator is mostly only of interest to auto
operation at sea level and typical auto operating altitudes so
that the driver doesn't blow the head gasket out with over boost
at low rpms. It is of minimal value to a pilot only in that he
doesn't ask more of the turbo than it can deliver, and even
then it is the pressure ratio which really matters. Yes, it is
an analog for engine output HP, but gives no indication of the operating
condition of the turbo. So...use the boost gauge to obtain MAP
and divide it by the outside air pressure and obtain pressure
ratio and determine if one is still inside the high efficiency
bucket...and not outside the desirable operating conditions.
Note: Perhaps you have a differential pressure boost gauge
which compares the outside (inlet) pressures versus the turbo
output pressure?? In this case, you could indeed control the
pressure ratio
by not exceeding a total boost requirement from the turbo!
Horsepower = fuel flow. One can get 25 lb/min mass flowrate at
many combinations of rpm, but the engine still has to be able to
flow 25 lb/min mass flowrate of fuel:air mixture to obtain the
equivalent HP. If the rpm is low, the throttle can be opened
more (if possible) and the turbo tries to compress the mixture
even more to flow even more lb/min fuel:air to achieve the desired power
output (25 lb/min) requested by the throttle. Again, one of
the most difficult auto issues is WOT at low rpm which causes
extreme boost attempting to increase the mass flowrate but is unable
usually due to the driver being in too high a gear, ergo the
complication of the wastegate is required. The solution for the
mechanically adept? Downshift, increase the mechanical advantage in the
drive system and allow the engine to increase in rpm and
process more mass flowrate of fuel:air mixture, thus achieving
the desired mass flowrate (HP).
MAP of 46" (8 psi:16" Hg boost over sea level ambient of 30"
MAP) at Denver, as another example, is still 46", but the turbo
must work MUCH harder to accomplish this MAP at Denver's 5,000' altitude
than at sea level. The WOT at low rpm situation in Denver is
an even more difficult "system" condition for the auto system to
manage. In most situations, the driver couldn't care less, "Saab was
supposed to deal with this" however, it presents very real
issues for turbo autos here in this area.
Note: Dealing with all these demands of drivers and their autos
is the Product Engineers job, and thanks to mechanically
challenged drivers it makes for a career, and a very difficult
one at that!!
2. In finer detail, the air cleaner and associated intake
plumbing will reduce the inlet turbo pressure to even lower air
pressures than the outside environment. This is normally on the order of
1-2" Hg. Ask any pilot who flies even a fuel injection plane
and they can confirm this fact. Carbys are worse. My Mooney
typically can only realize outside pressure minus 1" Hg. through the air
cleaner and plumbing. With the ram air on, this goes up about
1.5" to 0.5" Hg above outside air pressure. Thus, the pressure
ratio is even higher than the ratio of (MAP/outside air pressure) would
suggest. That means even higher on the turbo curves heading
toward the rpm stratosphere and/or surge line.
3. Let's go post-turbo. As the air comes out of the
compressor it is hot. Adiabatic compression and all that. I
didn't invent these rules, God did and the formulas explain Man's
best manner to
explain and calculate these temperatures. The air is HOT! 431
deg F doesn't surprise me at all. It is nearly hot enough to
ignite paper. Incoming air at this temperature would almost certainly
cause detonation even at very low compression ratios. That
high temperature is the driver for the intercooler. Not only
does the intercooler cool the air, but in the process the air density is
greatly increased.....resulting in more HP for the work effort
which the turbo performed.
Note: Moderate boosts at sea level were years ago accomplished
without intercoolers. Why? Because the operating conditions
were mostly in California and other sub-2000' altitude venues as well as
the boosts were quite modest. At the time were weren't
attempting to get 2.0 HP/cu. in. either!! However, as the boost
demands grew and the engines were designed to accommodate these boosts,
intake temperatures rapidly increased and would lead to
detonation. To avoid detonation, timing must be retarded...thus
reducing HP....reducing ones effort in a closing circle. Ah Hah!! Let's
cool the hot output of the turbo with an air:air cooler....thus
result the evolution of the intercooler.
4. Intercooler. Alas, all is not free. There is a pressure
drop through the intercooler and plumbing of 1-2 psi (2"-4" Hg).
Not a major loss, but again it is more compression required from the
turbo that the MAP never sees. It is loss in the system that
the turbo must make up to achieve our previous 36" of MAP. Bad
news, this makes the pressure ratio even higher again.
Dave: Your measured intake temp of 130 deg F tells me that
either your intercooler is not particularly efficient or your
under cowl temperature is higher than 100 deg F in the area where
the intake
air is obtained...next to the turbo?? Outside air which
decreases from sea level at approximately 2 deg C (3.6 F) per
1000 feet should be about 45 deg F outside if the sea level
temperature was 90
deg F {90 - (12.5 x 3.6) = 90 - 45 = 45} on the ground at sea
level below. Note: in order to evaluate conditions at altitude,
temperatures are essential. Without the temperature one can be off
very significantly.
5. So....your 32.5" MAP required an actual pressure output of
your compressor of 32.5" + 3" (intercooler loss) + 2" (intake air
cleaner loss) = 37.5" at the compressor outlet. Your outside air
pressure at 12,500 feet density altitude would be 1319.85
lb/sq. per my "Principles of Aeronautics" handbook (9.166 psi =
18.68" Hg) Pressure ratio = 37.5/18.68 = 2.007
My recollections of your operating conditions were obviously in
error and reflected higher engine output demand. I recalled you
were at a higher altitude and with higher MAP. Your actual
conditions would make the turbo outlet temps a little lower and
the I/C outlet temp even lower yet.
My suggestion: There is some disconnect between our
understandings of MAP, boost, differential pressure, Total boost
pressure?????
Let's chase this one to the end, so we are all on the same
page. I like the 189 KTAS!!
Doug Dempsey