AUTOMOTIVE NEWS APRIL 25, 1960 Wankel Engine in U. S. Car by '65? WITHIN the next few months NSU, the German auto maker, will sign contracts for its controversial Wankel engine with two top European auto manufacturers, according to Dr. Ing. G, St. von Heydekampf, NSU president. In an Automotive News interview, von Heydekampf said he is visiting this country to work out development and marketing plans for the e n gin e with CurtissWright Corp., United States licensee since 1958. There's a good possibility, he continued, that the Wankel engine will be used in an American car in the next four or five years. In Detroit, there has been much skepticism about this engine. The question, "Is the Wankel engine a phony or not?" has been asked by hundreds of industry people, ranging from junior draftsmen to General Motors executive vice-presidents. Time will tell. Briefly, the Wankel engine consists of a triangular piston that rotates in a somewhat-oval-shaped (Trochoidal) combustion chamber. The four phases of combustion intake, compression, power and exhaust-are produced by the rotation of the single piston in the chamber. Called Vibration Free COMPARING the Wankel engine with the present piston engine, von Heydekampf said it's half as big, half as costly and is entirely free of vibration because there are no reciprocating parts. "This engine definitely will be in production in 1961," he continued, "probably for a generator, pump or stationary engine-some application where you don't have the up and down motions that you have in a car. This engine isn't only for autos-but wherever you need an engine. "As to whether this engine will be used in a 1961 NSU, nobody knows-not even I, although it's a possibility. It depends on a number of developments. However, I feel stronger than ever that the thing is a technical reality." " (Other sources have told AUTOMOTIVE NEWS that the NSU will definitely introduce this engine next year and that an experimental engine was installed in a car as early as last May.) Asked about the skepticism that this engine has provoked in the United States, v 0 n Heydekampf said: "The skepticism isn't nearly as great as I expected. I fully expected to be called a fool in public; thus far it's only been done privately. We were expecting the experts particularly to be critical, unless they studied the engine. "After all, engineers have been working on this idea for 80 years. The many patents on this principle have only shown failures or vagueness. Most engine engineers have given up hope on the idea. So, why should the 350th attempt to solve this problem be quickly accepted? Most people say it (solving the problems of the rotating piston engine) can't be done because it hasn't been done." However, he said the Wankel engine has been much more enthusiastically accepted by Eropean engineers. He said the "tide was turned" in Europe after a seminar was held for 2,000 engineers in Munich, Germany, which he described as the most important meeting of European engineers since 1900 when Rudolph Diesel introduced his famed engine. Informed sources also have admitted that the debut of the Wankel engine/here Was marred by the timing of its announcement, which came shortly before Curtiss-Wright made an unfavorable financial report. When asked how NSU happened to become associated with this engine, von Heydekampf asserted that his engineers Wanted to use Felix Wankel's experience on sliding valves that eliminate the need for tappets, and that Wankel eventually told them about this engine the rotating piston. that he had been working on for Pressure-backed wi per blades 30 years. 2 Big Problems Solved he said Wankel had solved two major problems that had stumped engineers for 80 years. These were a new form of motion for the piston and the matter of seals between the cylinder wall and the rotating piston. Pressure backed wiper blades solved the seal problem. This is somewhat snnilar to the Job done by piston rings in conventional engines, von Heydekampf added. The question that most U. S. engineers ask about the engine is: "How do you keep that rapidly rotating piston from getting too hot?" Von HeYdekampf said this was accomplished by circulating oil through the rotor shaft and into the rotor. The oil acts as both a coolant and a lubricant. In response to other questions, von Heydekampf commented: 1. No special metals are needed for this engine; components can be made of aluminum, iron or steel, depending on how much importance is attached to cost, weight, etc. 2. The basic principles of the engine are sufficiently proven for all engines up to 500 horsepower. However, development of the Wankel engine, like that of the two-stroke engine, will go on for years through the improvement of materials, cooling and other things. 3. This engine is currently a side line for NSU, although it's possible that the engine may become more important than the company's main line-cars. ASKED about the working arrangement between NSU and Curtiss.Wright, von Heydekampf said "Curtiss-Wright was licensed by us 18 months ago. But there is no duplicating efforts-each company is allotted certain engine sizes. "But We consider the United States market to be such a huge field for this engine, that there should be separate designs. Of course, We wouldn't Supply the United States with engines from Germany." It's understood that under the NSU-Curtiss-Wright agreement, Curtiss- Wright will license United States firms which want the engine. However, NSU must approve each American licensee. NSU also has the right to import cars with this engine into the United States. Concluding his remarks, von HeYdekampf said, "We've had this engine for several years now. We took two years just to make sure of the patent situation and to ask the wise guys: 'Where are the weak spots?' Naturally, there were some and we're taking care of them. "We're not pressed for time and we're determined not to come out with this engine until it's thoroughly 'debugged," he said. "That's why we're taking our time." One thing is quite certain. If the contracts between NSU and the two top European companies are made as predicted, the cloud of skepticism that has surrounded the Wankel engine since it was introduced last year will be pretty thoroughly dissipated.