Subject: Oil injection in the fuel
From: ACRE
Date: 1/8/2005, 12:51 PM


frank barbot wrote:



Hello,



I am working on engine conception (and a part of production)
for

7

years, in

the past on gasoline and automotive and aeronautic
applications.



I am now working for Mistral engines, with a base of Mazda

rotary

engine

13B

for aeronautic application.



So i would like to participate to your discution as a
member.



I already do have a question.



The oil going to the head of rotor and apex seal coming from
the

"secondary

volumetric" oil pump, through oil injectors, is mixed with
air

coming

from

the inlet manifold. When is this flow usefull, what is his

fonction,

can

i

suppress this in certain condition ?



This question is very important for me, i am dimensionning a
new

lubrification system dedicate to our application on that

function.



Best regards



Frank BARBOT



Welcome Frank. I'll repeat what I just said to Francois.



I don't have much on the pneumatic part other than what is in
the

shop

manuals which is also not much. Mainly checking the one way

valves.



I think they function when the pressure is lower in the intake

chamber

than atmospheric. As far as I know no positive air pressure is

used

to assist the oil injection. Mazda main thrust on the design
is

to reduce the quantity of apex seal oil as much as possible to

reduce emissions. A small positive displacement pump may be
all

that you

need. Use a separate tank for the 2 cycle apex seal oil with a
low

oil

warning light.



Here is one I made quite some time ago. I used off the shelf
gear

pinion

stock for the rotors.



Paul Lamar



Frank,

I don't know if what I say will contribute anything BUT someone
on

this

discussion group ( I can't remember who) said the 'oil metering

pump' was

a

two stage pump with a small amount of oil in Idle and fully on

(100:1)

just

above idle.



This may be different for the later Series 6 and RX8 models as
they

are

electrically controlled metering and as Paul said the emphasis
was

on

emissions control. Personally I would measure the out put at

different

RPM's, while running the engine on pre-mix.



Now having said all that, a recent trip to my local engine
builder

mates,

informed me that they couldn't put an aftermarket engine
management

system

on a Mazda, without first replacing the 'oil metering pump' with
an

earlier

model manual pump- why! because there wasn't a Engine Management

System

manufactured to cater for 'oil metering'- why! because no other

engine

required this facility and it was a system for Mazda alone.



Is this the case with the Mistral Engine Management System?



George (down under)



Frank's job is to design the system for Mistral.



Paul Lamar





Mistral's DEM system can electronically manage electro-valves

precisely

metering the oil.  Frank wants to know if he can do away with the

pneumatic

system in this set-up.  I must admit we don't know as we have not

worked on

this system so far because it works fine... except that it's
bloody

expensive to manufacture and to install (we are talking of copper
or

steel

lines replacing Mazda's nylon line Paul "loves" so much for their

durability! :-)  ).



Cheers



Francois (across the pond)





I looked it up in the RX8 Service Highlights manual. Ironically I
have

more info

on the RX8 than any other 13B. The function of the atmospheric air

supply

and the one way air valves in the injectors is to prevent the intake

chamber from sucking

oil out of the injection lines when the pressure in the intake
chamber

is below atmospheric

which will happen big time if the throttle is closed while the
engine is

still turning at significant RPMs. Definitely an emissions issue.

Probably

not a problem in an air craft engine. If the the oil is mixed with
the

fuel

before injection that too would solve that problem. In other words
no

direct injectors.



The PCM changes the electronic stepper motor metering pump according
to

engine speed, engine

coolant temp and the amount of intake air. The fail safe mode is;
the

injected

amount of oil is minimized and oil is injected only according to
engine

RPM. The failure

of the stepper motor can be sensed by the PCM. The PCM then limits
the

amount of

fuel and hence the RPM and the power the engine can generate. Again
a

fail safe

emissions issue since too much apex seal oil does nothing except

increase the

Hc emissions. In other words a limp to your car dealer mode :)



Aren't computers wonderful? :)



Paul Lamar



Ben Schneider wrote:



I don't know too much about them, but how does a 2-cycle oil injection

system work? (as on a snowmobile) Would something like that work, as
you

would still have a seperate oil tank, but it mixes with the fuel
before it

enters the engine. Perhaps more simple, and maybe less complicated?
Just a

thought.



    Ben Schneider

I know very well were people are coming from with this practice of
mixing 2-cycle oil in the fuel tanks or to inject it somewhere in the fuel
lines.  It makes the complicated and expensive oil
metering system redundant and results in acceptable or even good
lubrication of the apex seals and running surface with what is probably the
best oil to avoid gum deposits in the seals' slits.

But let me set the record straight (at least from my point of view and I
recognize there are others), this practice has big and unacceptable
drawbacks for a commercial product IMHO:

1. Everyone is trying very hard to atomize and inject the fuel as well
as possible to get the best possible combustion and efficiency.  That means
keeping as much fuel away from the walls as
possible.  This objective is totally in opposition with depositing a
layer of fuel-mixed oil on the trochoid surface.  In addition to 80-90%
(hopefully) of the oil droplets that would stay in
suspension and be rejected either burned or unburned with the exhaust
gases without having had any role in lubrication, you have 50% or more of
the oil which get in contact with walls that are not
the walls you want it deposited onto, because they either don't need
lubrication (rotor surfaces) or get it in another way (side-housing
surfaces).  It means that from the quantity of oil you
introduce, something like 5% only does the job it was intended to do.
Talk about a waste and talk about unnecessary emissions!  How much is one
supposed to mix?  2 to 4 ounces per gallon is the
recommendation if my memory serves me well?  That's 10 times more than
what we use.  FYI, s piece of data from our Oshkosh trip:  Florida to
Oshkosh and back + a few flights around OSH, 19 hours of
flight:  1 (one) quart of oil used, total.



2. Worse: the oil that goes through the engine without playing its role
of lubricant is not some "innocuous" waste.  It sensibly increases the
propensity to detonate and it clearly contributes to
higher EGTs.



3. Picture yourself as a salesperson trying to convince a non-rotorhead
to purchase a rotary engine.  Now, you have to tell him or her that 2
different qualities of oil must be regularly added into

2 different tanks and, if one puts the wrong oil in the wrong tank, one
may seriously damage the engine. Oh yeah!  One more thing:  one of these
qualities of oil (the one you must add most often by
far) is generally not sold on airports.  ...If you can do it, then
please let me know, I immediately offer you a job at Mistral Engines with a
great compensation package!



I know that using engine oil in the metering system is not optimal, but
the option is much worse IMHO, at least for a commercial product.



BTW, we have not observed, so far, any gumming of the seals whatsoever
in hundreds of bench hours.  Maybe it's because we inject the right amount
of oil?  We'll be especially careful to take this
aspect of things into account when we'll issue a final specification for
the oil, but I already know that it will be an oil brand and/or quality that
can be purchased in most FBOs.


Sorry for being vocal.

Francois Badoux

Not a problem being vocal. That's is why we are here. Lets put some
numbers on it.
One fluid ounce per gallon is the norm. That is one part in 128 parts of
fuel.

If you look at this chart from Mazda you need 80 or 100 cc per hour per
rotor
or say 200 cc per hour to keep the seals cool. Since there are about 33 cc
per
fluid ounce that is 6.6 fluid ounces per hour. At 13 gallons per hour that
is
about half an ounce of 2 cycle oil per gallon. Since the Mazda rotary
racing world
has tens of thousands of hours on one ounce mixed per gallon 50% getting
to the
apex seal is not that bad. Also I might add the only way the side seals
get
oil is from the apex seal oil. In theory, if the oil scrappers are doing
their
job on the sides of the rotors they get no oil from the crankcase.

In the early days Mazda introduced the oil into the carb float bowl. It
was only
later they added direct injection and after the emission regs became
draconian.

This weird rotor housing wear obviously was the result of a failed apex
seal oil injector. Mazda also spent a lot of R&D time on how the injected
apex seal
oil was distributed across the rotor housing surface which I can document.
Not a fait accompli by any means.

Racing Beat with their 1200 HP 3 rotor turbo charged rotary found that up
to four
ounces per gallon did not cause detonation. (One part in 32)

I am not saying you have to mix it manually with the fuel. I am saying you
will
get better results if you inject it into the fuel and not into the rotor
housing
directly. I know you don't like the idea of forcing the pilot to mix it
with the fuel.

Check my arithmetic.

Paul Lamar

I'm probably wrong, but I believe that the carbon build-up on the seals and
rotors is mainly a result of the duty cycle from being used in an automotive
application. The higher temps and longer runtimes at high RPM in our
application seems to limit or minimize the problem.
So as long as your oil lines are in good shape, oil injection should be
fine.

Ron Freier

That is a new theory Ron. Conventional wisdom has it the motor oil is breaking
down at the 500 degree F the apex seal operates at WOT. Take another look
at the chart I just uploaded. 260 C is 500 F. Here is the chart yet again.

My test on motor oil where I cooked it in the oven for 1/2 hour and Idemitsu's 
test confirmed this fact. The other data is we have at least a 1000 hours on 
an engine in aircraft service with mixed 2 cycle oil and the rotors and slots 
are slick as a whistle. If you would like to confirm this test it is easy to do. 
Put one teaspoon of oil in a used cat food can and set your oven for 500 F. 

Don't take my word for it :)

BTW Mazdatrix now carries Idemitsu oil specifically designed for use
in the rotary. I picked up a case of 10W-30 and replaced the garbage
the dealer put in my RX8 when I got the 15,000 mile service.
 
Paul Lamar
 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.