Thomas J Hankamp wrote:
Is it possible they are using mechanical injection?? Has anyone
investigated mechanical injection such as
Hilborn (used on sprint cars & some other modifieds)??
Tom
Early Power Sport engines used mechanical fuel injection.
The engine is much easier to start under all conditions using
electronic fuel injection.
Paul Lamar
> FYI -- I had a Porsche 914 with mechnaical fuel injection. It came
that way
when Porsche/VW tried to get more power from the VW erngine. It was
big big
pain!! Hard to start, would not start when hot, and suffered from fuel
starvation. Most people replaced it with twin carbs.
Yours for fun flying -- Buck Buchanan.
P.S.: About twenty yeasrs ago, Continential or Lycoming tried
mechanical
fuel injection. It was like the Porsche 914, hard to start, would not
start when
hot.... GHB
Alan Tolle wrote:
Paul, occasionally a question comes up which I think I should respond to,
since I know more about it than anyone else.
Powersport under Everett Hatch used a clone of the Bendix manifold pressure
controlled mechanical fuel injection system that was created by Don Rivera
at Air Flow Performance specifically for him --- the same fuel injection
system that has flown millions of hours on Lycoming engines. The
modification was separation of the air pressure measuring system from the
fuel metering system, the former being incorporated as the air intake of
the plenum, the latter being linked to the throttle plates.
Injectors were one per cylinder just like everything out there flying with
fuel injection. Injectors were at first screwed simply into the oil
injection ports, later were positioned in the intake runner bend so that
they pointed directly at the throttle plates. The latter worked very
well. And as you remember the positioning of the throttle plates right at
the trochoid housing completely solved the problem of idle roughness at low
engine rpm.
Some might object to the injectors being on the hot side of the engine, but
if you shroud the exhaust system in a stainless steel heat shield as you
should there is no problem.
You are aware that we spent a lot of hours on the dyno tuning the intakes,
varying both length and diameter. The result was 20% more horsepower more
or less free --- and much less complicated that a turbo. We also spent a
lot of time on exhaust tuning, pretty much at my urging (since I had
developed the cross over exhausts system for the four cylinder Lycoming
engines for the RV series) No less than 9 different systems (your would
not believe some of them) were tried and no matter what, all hurt the
horsepower out put. The 32 inches of one and three quarter pipe for each
cylinder was just what was required to get the fire out of the cowl. It
was light, simple, durable, noisy, and it also hurt power out put, but less
so.
Thinking of Everett, you, Paul, have sometime noted that the rotary engine
in aircraft is still 10 years behind where Powersport was in 1997. In some
ways this is true because his goal was reliability, not innovation, hence
the Bendix FI rather than EFI, peripheral ports rather than turbo charging.
He said we all must learn to walk before we can learn to run. The rotary
engine enthusiast should first build the engine and make it work on the
test stand, then choose an approiate airframe to install it in. It seems
that often it works the other way around, that is the builder chooses the
airframe he likes and then tries to make the rotary engine work in it.
Unproven engine, unproven installation, unproven airframe is a formula for
disaster.
Final note. In the five hundred hours plus that I flew the Bendix fuel
injection on the rotary engine not once, emphasis not once, did I have a
start problem, hot, cold, or otherwise. I can not say the same for my
experience with Bendix FI on Lycoming engines, but as we all know Rotaries
and Lycomings are apples and oranges.
Alan Tolle.
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.