Keith Moore wrote:
Paul:
Another thought; use the exhaust turbine (90,000 rpm) to direct
drive a two
pole generator and rectify to DC electric power. Then power a DC
electric
motor/generator connected to the rotary shaft (direct or by belt)
Perhaps you have seen Capstone located in Chatsworth? Very
interesting
tour!
Capstone Turbine was started by a couple of out-of-work engineers
who
configured a Garrett turbocharger connected to a rotating magnet.
They then
added "air-bearings" (no lube and no wear), a burner and heat
recovery HX.
Voila! - 30 KW at +30% efficiency, and very low emissions.
http://www.capstoneturbine.com/technology/techUnderHood.asp
Regards,
Keith Moore
LEZ
When you run the numbers it does not look that great 29 Kw = 39 HP
2.9 gallons per hour diesel fuel. BSFC = .56.
You are not done yet. You have to convert that electrical energy back
into mechanical energy. 80% motor efficiency is 31.2 net mechanical HP
out
BSFC now goes up to .70. A rotary is one heck of a lot more efficient
than
that. To top it all off the weight is 225 pounds for eng/gen and 151
pounds
for the controller for a grand total of 376 pounds and we still have
not
weighed the electric motor. So typical of hybrid cars.
The last fly in the ointment is there are no details on the all
important
recuperator.
Stock scam time.
Paul Lamar
Irrelevant snips.....
Keith Moore wrote:
Perhaps I can try again!
For an alternate scheme* to build a compound power package (to extract the
exhaust energy from the rotary exhaust and add it back to engine output),
utilize the conventional turbocharger "exhaust turbine" coupled to a high
strength 2-pole magnet (about 1 in. dia. and 6 inches long). The very high
magnet RPM (est 90,000) allows use of a small light weight generator.
Rectify the high frequency electrical out put to DC; use this energy source
to drive a motor coupled to the rotary output shaft.
The reference to CAPSTONE demonstrates such a "turbine-generator" scheme is
already used in a commercial product.
*Instead of the complex mechanical approach; a new turbine disk, high
temperature manifolds, and gear reduction, etc.
I guess I did not make my point. My point was the electrical approach is inefficient
in both energy conversion and weight. We have been over this several times in
the past.
The generator is less than 100% efficient and the motor is less than 100% efficient.
Lets us give them the benefit of the doubt and say they are both 90% efficient.
90% times 90% is 80% efficient. Now we know CW got 20% more power or 20% less fuel
burn out of the R3350 TC engine including all mechanical losses using a turbine.
Lets say our rotary is 200 HP. 20% of that is 40 HP. So we need a 50 HP generator
and a 40 HP net electric motor.
So if we take that 20% and multiply it by 80% we are down to a 16% improvement
in fuel burn. Further more a 37 KW (50 HP) alternator and 30KW (40 HP) DC electric
motor are not light weight or cheap. A 3 HP permanent magnet starter weighs about
7 pounds. Modern starters are high RPM. They get the torque by planetary gearing.
In addition to the built in starter gearing the pinion and ring gear alone are
about 10 or 12 to one.
Lets say the starter is only 5 pounds with out all the gears. With the same
level of technology that means the 50 HP alternator and the 40 HP motor are both going
to weigh about 60 pounds each give or take 10. That is at least 100 pounds
for both and probably more. We still have not considered the weight and cost
of the required electronic controller.
All you need do to verify this is compare the weight of any hybrid car
with any similar car of the same size and HP. The problems are the same.
You will find they are 500 to 700 pounds heavier.
Another clue is the weight of the Capstone 29 Kw (38 HP) engine at 225 pounds less
the controller. The biggest turbo charger I can find weighs in the neigborhood of
50 pounds. Where did the other 175 pounds come from? Surely not the burner cans.
I rest my case.
What this has to do with adding a large supercharger to the end of the rotary I have no
idea :)
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.