DaveLeonard wrote:
After careful consideration, I think I am going to switch to Evans NPG (100%
propylene glycol) during my annual this year when I flush the cooling
system. Here is how I see it:
Disadvantages:
1. I will probably run a higher cooling temp, about 20-30deg higher best I
can tell, This will put my hottest temps up around 250F. I think the
coolant o-rings should be able to withstand that. Otherwise, the increased
temps will improve heat rejection and possibly BSFC without other negative
impact. Running higher coolant temps should also partially offset the
decreased specific heat of the NPG (better temperature difference in the
radiator).
2. Initial cost and hassle flushing the system.
3. Higher oil temp. - Oil temps are not a problem for me, if anything I
would like to see them up into to 180 range (currently 140-160).
Advantages:
1. No risk of boil over. I had one in-flight boil over when using 50/50 EG.
That was a real pain. Once it gets to boiling over it is very difficult to
get it to cool down, and it can be hard to find water at some airports.
Also, a small leak in an EG or water system will drop the pressure and cause
boil over very quickly.
2. Antifreeze. Running water with water wetter did decrease my temps by 20
deg, but I could not leave the plane parked overnight in the mountains for
fear of possibly freezing the coolant. So before flying to any place cold I
had to drain out the water and add EG. That was a real pain, and now my
temps are back up near the boiling point of the water /EG mix.
3. Longer coolant life and better corrosion control. Evans clams NPG+ will
last the life of the engine, but I will obviously replace it every 5 years
when replacing the cooling hoses.
4. Non-toxic. I am frequently dripping EG in the hangar every time I do
work on something. Would prefer something non-toxic.
5. Low pressure cooling system that does not change pressure with
altitude... I eventually plan to get into the flight levels but that would
mean that my boil over temp drops dramatically.
6. Better control of nucleate boiling. Not sure if this is good, bad, or
indifferent. Evans claims it significantly improves the margin of safety
for detonation and allows increased spark advance. Others claim that
nucleate boiling is important for cooling very hot spots.
Comments? Anyone have real life experience with NPG they could share?
Dave Leonard
In theory there is worse heat tranfer between the metal and the coolant but
Ken Welter has been running it for a few years in his Coot without
apparent problems.
Paul Lamar
Yes I used NPG for several years and several hundred hrs and it
worked fine but I have switched back to 60 percent Sierra propylene
glycol to 40 water mixture, the reason was that NPG gets real thick
when it gets cold and I fly in subzero temps in the winter so I had
concerns about it gelling and creating cooling problems and maybe
undo stress on the water pump belts if it got to thick on startups or
on decent's.
Rob Golden at Pineapple racing uses it in all his race cars and
swears by it but he also had concerns about the cold temp I fly in,
if your not flying in subzero temps I would use it.
Ken Welter
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.