Subject: Combined cycle car turbo compound.
From: ACRE
Date: 2/1/2005, 9:50 PM


"Kent, Russell" wrote:

The rear muffler just ahead of the rear bumper is redesigned as a
combination muffler and water vapor condenser to recapture the
water in the exhaust.

Hmm.  If it works, you might not ever need to add water, as one of the
combustion byproducts is water vapor.  But it might not last long: I
suspect that the working water will quickly become very acidic from the
nitric and sulfuric acid byproducts.  How long do you expect the exhaust
plumbing to last when you're injecting superheated acid inside it?  :-)

Russell Kent


Very very good point Russell and I am already thinking about it. You are on
the ball as usual. There must be a way of neutralizing the acid.

BTW DS, this is your A student competition.

Paul Lamar


Paul
for the past few days I have been communicating with a gentleman name Jim
Crank.  Jim holds a Bonneville world record for steam powered engine in an
automobile and has worked for the state of California on several projects
concerning steam powered vehicles.   Here is what he wrote me when I
explained your steam injection idea.

 Please understand a version of the turbo-compound shown below will be
built.

The final design uses a belt to the rear e-shaft.

The steam compound motor, (if that is what it is called) is just in the
preliminary discussion stage.

I would appreciate your thoughts.

Thanks

Doug


Doug,

Now I see what you are up to.

My thoughts are these:
This whole idea has been proposed dozens of times, going back to the early
1930's. It has never been successfully accomplished because of system space
and added weight far exceed the original guesses.

Binary cycles work in stationary power plants where the added machinery is
easily accommodated and this [idea] goes way back into the beginning of the
20th century. The actual gain was never worth the investment.
Con Edison used a mercury turbine tacked onto a super critical power plant.
It was later scrapped.

The amount of money needed to do what Paul proposes is going to be vast. The
development costs, assuming the proof of concept model even works 10% as
well as expected, is going to be eye watering.
A steam or organic bottoming cycle will not nearly be as efficient as simply
using a compounding turbine on the exhaust of the IC engine.

What basis Paul is using to think that a binary cycle is more efficient than
a simple exhaust turbine geared to the shaft is highly suspect. Look at the

Wright Turbo Compound aircraft engine. It worked.
You are going to add a lot of weight and bulk to the existing engine for
very little gain.

Controlling the vapor pressure and temperature on such a system is a nasty
problem. This Paul doesn't even address.

The vapor generator he proposes is going to be vastly larger and heavier
than any pipe run up the IC engines exhaust pipe.

Personally, I wouldn't spend any time, or money, with this one, it just is
not practical.

Jim

The basis I use is the heat left over after the kinetic energy is extracted
from the exhaust using the turbo compound principle. We just published those 
numbers on the Scania turbo compound diesel engine. 950 degrees F is surely enough 
to make ten HP worth of steam. He appears to be unfamiliar with the COMBINED 
cycle as he refers to the engine as the COMPOUND or the binary cycle. 

I think he is missing something here.  Perhaps he is thinking of a full scale
engine. This is a miniaturized version of that. We need only  20 HP out of 
the combined cycle turbine total to double the MPG of a car doing a steady 
70 MPH. What is new about this idea is we are only going to use it for steady 
state road load which amounts to 40 HP total. Half of which comes from the 
main engine and half from the COMBINED cycle gas turbine. Ten HP kinetic and 
ten HP steam.  We are not building a 300 HP combined cycle steam engine. Perhaps 
he needs to think this through again.

There is new technology out there in the form of computer controls. I am not 
sure how familiar he is with real time computer control of processes but 
I feel confident I could write the software to control all the things 
he mentions and then some using a a 6502 processor found in an Apple II. 
That is what I did for 30 years.

Well then what are we to do? Go on wasting 2/3 rd of the energy in every gallon of
gas burned in a billion cars around the world? Or are we going to solve a
few problems with a ten HP heat exchanger, steam control system and a condenser?

He mentions money. How much money is the 2/3rd of the fuel thrown away 
in a billion cars in one day worth?

I am looking for people that are willing to solve the problem and not
dismiss it as impossible.

Good thing the Wright brothers did not take no for an answer.

Paul Lamar
 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.